Mafia #7 -- The Play

Whoa. That was so confusing.
 
Madcrawdad said:
See a possible opening and figure you'll take it, huh Newb? I would, too. Nice try. As soon as JL said he thought I could be mafia, I knew that I'd be hearing from you...

I was going to save this for a little later, but it seems you've tipped your hand. I vote to lynch Hooked Newbie
Click to expand...

Nope, if you're innocent then we're butting heads. If not, I think you're leading folks around with only your reputation and quoting abilities. Feel free to join the train. I'm still not changing my vote. Are you all so protective because I've found your Don? Great teamwork though.
 
I do see some of your points hn, but you pointed out that you weren't on the sway train way too many times to make me feel comfortable about you and the flip-flopping between "I wasn't convinced that she was mafia" and "I was concerned about the train" doesn't work...also the way you tried to explain your vote for dc is too suspicious to me. You are my top suspect so far...

But others...in no order...

Mee-mee- is too quiet for my liking, mostly just concerned me but now it's too suspicious imo

Chas- his gunning for mp has gotten out of hand, I see the positions for both sides of the story but saying "anyone against lynching mp is a suspect imo" is way too extreme for a townie at this point in the game

mp- still a top suspect because of yesterday's posts, though I understand the defensiveness in this situation

joander- night one "slip" and odd play all around
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Nope, if you're innocent then we're butting heads. If not, I think you're leading folks around with only your reputation and quoting abilities. Feel free to join the train. I'm still not changing my vote. Are you all so protective because I've found your Don? Great teamwork though.
Click to expand...

Wait did I miss something? Who...?
 
Mystery Player heads back to town just to find the meager dwelling that has been home destroyed, a caring towns woman offers shelter for the night, Mystery Player accepts.......
 
jpappy789 said:
I do see some of your points hn, but you pointed out that you weren't on the sway train way too many times to make me feel comfortable about you and the flip-flopping between "I wasn't convinced that she was mafia" and "I was concerned about the train" doesn't work...also the way you tried to explain your vote for dc is too suspicious to me. You are my top suspect so far...

But others...in no order...

Mee-mee- is too quiet for my liking, mostly just concerned me but now it's too suspicious imo

Chas- his gunning for mp has gotten out of hand, I see the positions for both sides of the story but saying "anyone against lynching mp is a suspect imo" is way too extreme for a townie at this point in the game

mp- still a top suspect because of yesterday's posts, though I understand the defensiveness in this situation

joander- night one "slip" and odd play all around
Click to expand...

Please read back. I've been against ANY "trains". Even if they are formed early and without reason on my best suspect, they make me nervous. I wanted people to talk about things and who they suspected along with why. I voted my feelings pure and simple. How is my vote for DC "too suspicious". Jo actually replied with substance so I retracted my vote thinking that DC was looking more and more suspicious. Mad votes for me (with a case) and within 5 minutes DC jumps on without a shred of his own thought. That's why I voted for him. Do what you like, lynch me. Look back at the end of the game at those 2 and tell me I was wrong on either.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Please read back. I've been against ANY "trains". Even if they are formed early and without reason on my best suspect, they make me nervous. I wanted people to talk about things and who they suspected along with why. I voted my feelings pure and simple. How is my vote for DC "too suspicious". Jo actually replied with substance so I retracted my vote thinking that DC was looking more and more suspicious. Mad votes for me (with a case) and within 5 minutes DC jumps on without a shred of his own thought. That's why I voted for him. Do what you like, lynch me. Look back at the end of the game at those 2 and tell me I was wrong on either.
Click to expand...

Without a shred of my own thought?! I resent that. I even explained my reasoning in semi-small words....If this wasn't the internet I'd storm off in a huff.....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom