Mafia #70: The Time Vortex

jpappy789 said:
TRS- Zaffy 29, JL 297
Wiz- Ogre 47, Hn 50, JL 163, Zsand 274, DD 305, Rb 426, Jb 433, LG 438, Noods 445, Rich 450, Hn 600
Zsand- Kash 62
Chaz- Zsand 141
ILM- Lab 209, Zsand 300
FF- JL 211, Chaz 264
JB- LG 243
HN- FF 267, Kash 308, Chaz 402, Mad 470, Dawg 477, Fire 496, Jb 497, Wiz 572
LG- Noods 362
Mad- Fire 492
RB- Wiz 373, Zaffy 418, JL 542

No votes from: ILM, TRS
Click to expand...

1st Nightfall.

Looking at the posts, if Kash got stuck on HN, and RB is scum like he says he is.

I would semi-clear Chaz, Mad, Dawg, Fire, JB because they all voted HN after HN started gaining ground.

Noods and Rich are on wiz late, rich is assumed innocent, (did they get a turn after he came back to life? is it possible he came back as scum?)



jpappy789 said:
LG- Dawg 698, Noods 728, JL 731, Lab 748, Jb 877, Chaz 895, Kash 929, Rb 942, DD 945
Wiz- Zs 747
Zs- Ogre 755, JL 853, Noods 884, LG 926, Wiz 943, FF 953
Chaz- FF 801
Ogre- LG 849
Lab- Mad 850, Zaffy 930
Zaffy- Fire 918

Everyone has voted...nightfall in 30 minutes...
Click to expand...

Kind of a landslide on LG, at least 2 scum were on her though. Zs was the next closest, but he turned out innocent, Noods was on him.



jpappy789 said:
SSSsssssssssssssHHHHHHHHhhhhhh!!!

Zs- JL 1004, Ogre 1027, FF 1035, JL 1042, Chaz 1057, Noods 1110, Rich 1113, Kash 1138, Lab 1175
DD- Lab 1102, Wiz 1115, Dawg 1225, Rb 1255, Fire 1290
Ogre- Zs 1168, Mad 1173, FF 1181, Zaffy 1211, JB 1224, Fire 1322

No vote from DD
Click to expand...

Kash and Noods both on Zs, strike 2 on Noods.

I think Noods might be scum. I haven't looked at her posts yet though.
 
jbradt said:
So, how about if we get people to post lists of their top 2 or 3 suspects? Unfortunately, we don't have any more concrete evidence to go on, but with Kash's role I figure we ought to be able to come up with something. A sentence or two from each person on why they suspect who they do would be awesome.

Based on interactions with Kash, I have several people that I'm strongly leaning innocent, and I'm not sure if I want to put those out there or not. Suffice it to say that there are several people in particular whose posts I'll be reading very carefully.

I am still looking at Wiz and Ogre.

Wiz: was suspect early on for oddly aggressive play. He calmed down after a little while and looked a little more Wiz-like. His defense of Kash (yes, say what you will Wiz; that's what it looks like), and total unwillingness to even look at the possibility that I might have been telling the truth don't look good.

Ogre: hinted at being CI in his pursuit of Zs. Kash was pushing hard for him along with me at the end. On the surface this seems to clear him, but Kash is **** good. She could have done that so it would clear him, thus protecting him. I think one of the reasons that Kash got by so well this game is that there was some truth in her lies.
Click to expand...

Finally someone remembered we are still playing and posted something.

Aggressive play? I took a poke at Ogre when I read his role play post before coffee. Come on, if that is aggressive I would hate to see what ACville thinks once I feel confident about my game play.

What can I say? HNK had me fooled. I didn't see anything scummy in her posts and by your own admission, with the game thread neither did you.

As far as willingness to think you might have been telling the truth? I asked for posts. According to our conversation that's where it was. You didn't produce any so, you got the scum that your invest revealed, but remember, I am not CI therefore that info was not available to me. I have to go by what I read in the game thread.

Also remember, this is now the GS day not the witch hunt day.
 
JL
Noods
 
Zaffy said:
1st Nightfall.

Looking at the posts, if Kash got stuck on HN, and RB is scum like he says he is.

I would semi-clear Chaz, Mad, Dawg, Fire, JB because they all voted HN after HN started gaining ground.

Noods and Rich are on wiz late, rich is assumed innocent, (did they get a turn after he came back to life? is it possible he came back as scum?)

Kind of a landslide on LG, at least 2 scum were on her though. Zs was the next closest, but he turned out innocent, Noods was on him.

Kash and Noods both on Zs, strike 2 on Noods.

I think Noods might be scum. I haven't looked at her posts yet though.
Click to expand...

First of all, you are taking Bob's scum claim for truth? You are kidding right? He is obviously bored and frustrated with this game play and wants to be put out of his misery.
Feel free to look at my posts. I know what side I am on and not worried about it in the least. Your analysis of the votes could be applied to anyone including yourself...two nights in a row you had a worthless vote and night three you hid in the middle of the votes for Ogre. Kashta did clear you too.....something to think about.
 
noodles62 said:
thought I'd check in....I agree with JB's thoughts on Ogre. I was ready to hang 'em high but Kash also had him on her top two list. Was that her plan, knowing she would get lynched thus protecting him? IDK. That is a tough call.
Wiz, I have leaning mafia based on past days play...

IMO JB and Rich are clear, and probably RB as well. That leaves me, JL, Mad, Dawg, Charlie (is he playing?), Labby and Firedancer, whom Kashta (conveniently?) neglected to add to her list...BRB..
Click to expand...

oops! forgot good old Zaffy!
 
noodles62 said:
First of all, you are taking Bob's scum claim for truth? You are kidding right? He is obviously bored and frustrated with this game play and wants to be put out of his misery.
Feel free to look at my posts. I know what side I am on and not worried about it in the least. Your analysis of the votes could be applied to anyone including yourself...two nights in a row you had a worthless vote and night three you hid in the middle of the votes for Ogre. Kashta did clear you too.....something to think about.
Click to expand...

He's quit over rules in past games. He's complained about them in this one. I don't see why not to believe him.
 
noodles62 said:
First of all, you are taking Bob's scum claim for truth? You are kidding right? He is obviously bored and frustrated with this game play and wants to be put out of his misery.
Feel free to look at my posts. I know what side I am on and not worried about it in the least. Your analysis of the votes could be applied to anyone including yourself...two nights in a row you had a worthless vote and night three you hid in the middle of the votes for Ogre. Kashta did clear you too.....something to think about.
Click to expand...


errmmm...he posted before I did...
 
Please, finish your thought. Do you really intend to quit this game?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom