Mafia #70: The Time Vortex

[jbradt]

I made a vote switch to save my ***. you would have done the same. I also stated HN made an opportunistic hit and run vote. HN was scum. Those are facts that can be verified by reading the game thread.

If you still want to dig that crap up and try to make me look scummy then maybe Ogre is right this time and you are scum.

If my death is what it takes to convince you all the GS shoot me.

Wiz, what do you think of JL?

 

[Lab_Rat]

Ok, this thread is way too long to try reading it from the beginning this late at night. I did go through day 1 and I still feel the Kash and Wiz bit was staged distancing. Also, almost all of Charlie's posts were on day 1 and most were all joking posts. He's not contributed much of anything at all.

JB, do you have any other investigation results that you can share with us that wouldn't compromise anything?

 

[dirtydawg10]

dawg, you seem intent in putting words in my mouth. I did not say it would hurt the town. I said I did not see the reason for it and that they should just shoot who jb suggests.

I guess there is no down side to coming out. In the original GS game, the GS just posted in bold who they are going to shoot. In this game it is done by jpap. So I am unsure how we will know for sure. I am also unsure why jpap does not want the town to know who the GS is. Maybe they can't come out.

I'm not putting words in your mouth. You first made it sound like a bad thing. The reason would be to narrow the field with another innocent being known so we can find the scum easier.

If the GS can't come out for whatever reason then I guess it is a moot point. But there is no evidence of that from what I can see.

 

[OgreMkV]

It does actually help. Thanks. Can you say more about your case on JL and Noods?

There were 5 players on day one with multiple votes that never voted Hooked. Those five players were Z, John, LadyG, Noods, Zaffy.

The next day, Zaffy and Z basically wasted votes. G ended up on Zsand, Kash voted G and (critically) both Noods and John voted for G and then switched to Zsand... It appeared to me that one or both of them might have known G was innocent and thus switched to Z (in appearance of helping us out, but really hiding themselves).

You see, if Z was mafia, then they would both look pretty good. If Z was innocent, then that move looks pretty scummy to me.

Of noods and John, Noods switched very late in the day. There were only four votes after her, one each for Z, G, Zaffy, and LabRat. Critically at this point, RBishops vote on LadyG was the deciding factor in that lynching.

Where did RB end up on Day three? I still haven't caught up yet. If RB didn't vote Zsand, then I might push him onto my suspect list because, he might have known not to vote for Z when it counted, but voted LG on Day 2 to take the heat off of Noods.... of course, the headline on night one implies that he's innocent... or well... not an alien... whatever that means.

Of the ones left, I would personally consider the following most likely to be innocent. This is based upon the day 1 vote for hooked. Fire, Mad, Charlie, JB, TheWiz, Dawg. It is entirely conceivable that one of them would vote for Hooked, but why? One more vote on Wiz would have protected Hooked. Might have looked bad, but hooked would still be in the game.

 

[the wizard]

Wiz, what do you think of JL?

Great guy, wierd sense of humor, loves to lynch FF.

I don't have a read on him yet. I played a very good game last time. The reason I did was because I pulled all the posts from specific players and brought out what was scummy.

This game we started with 21 players. Many of the older ones that haven't played in a while.I have never played against them so was concentrating my efforts on seeing if I need to pull their posts.

I didn't pay much attention to JL because of Ogres postings. I didn't trust his I know posts and so need to see him score to start trusting him.

 

[jbradt]

Ok, this thread is way too long to try reading it from the beginning this late at night. I did go through day 1 and I still feel the Kash and Wiz bit was staged distancing. Also, almost all of Charlie's posts were on day 1 and most were all joking posts. He's not contributed much of anything at all.

JB, do you have any other investigation results that you can share with us that wouldn't compromise anything?

Sorry, Labby. I wish we did.

So Labby, Wiz and Ogre; If you had one shot right now, who would you pick?

 

[the wizard]

To continue my last post, it does appear that JL may have misinterpeted some of JP's posts or he could have been putting us on.It is hard to tell with him. He seems to alternate from serious game play posts with joke posts and you never know which will be coming next.

 

[the wizard]

Sorry, Labby. I wish we did.

So Labby, Wiz and Ogre; If you had one shot right now, who would you pick?

If I were the gunslinger, my next shot would be RB. Aside from the posts he has made about the game formats we were in I can't recall any posts that would help the town.

 

[the wizard]

OK, no one wants to post. Going to watch a movie with hnk will check the game before bed.

 

[jbradt]

For the GS:

At this point, it looks like the top candidates are Wiz and Ogre. Jl and Labby are also candidates worth note IMO. Maybe Noods too.

I don't have any more concrete info to give... I wish I did. I can see arguments for and against all four of these. My gut tells me Labby's innocent, but it did last time we played this game too. But it's your call in the end. I have meetings early in the morning, then work tomorrow night, but I'll be on and off tonight and check in tomorrow afternoon again.

Like I've said before, I think the day will end when the GS hits a townie. I also think I'll be dead as soon as the mafia gets the ability again. I'll get out what information I can before that time. This game is infuriating in that being a CI is only true in title. Pappy's got an iron fist when it comes to communicating... :nutkick:.

Remember, you've got 48 hours from the time of your last shot to shoot again. Take your time and follow your gut.