I'm going to post my thoughts on everyone remaining.
Wiz-defended Kash last night and couldn't see how JB coming out would be beneficial. Wiz, you're smarter than this. I've also learned from playing with you that you are very stubborn, so maybe your not being able to see how JB was telling the truth was just your stubbornness coming out (yes, pot calling the kettle black argument applies here). Also, the day 1 banter you had with Kash seemed staged to me. I know a couple others commented on that as well.
RB-needs to drink his prune juice so he's not so cranky. I actually think he's innocent and just got bored with the game. I don't think the shot should be wasted on him, just let him UD when we're in a different format if he wants out of the game. Of course he could be using reverse psychology here.
Ogre-was 100% wrong about Zs and didn't video himself eating his mousepad. I suspect he may have been the turn, but idk.
Charlie-I'm really disappointed in Charlie's play if he's innocent. What happened to the great bush kicking Charlie from games past? He's done more joking and flirting than anything in this game.
JL-can't get a read on JL. Hasn't been super helpful to the town from what I can tell, but he also didn't get hung up on giving FF a super hard time, which I would have expected if JL were scum.
Fire-can't tell with her, she's told us more about her rl than she's posted about the game. Scum sliding by or just too busy for the game?
Noods-not getting a scummy feeling from her, also, she hasn't decompensated as she tends to do when she's scum. Now she didn't get onto Kash until after JB had revealed he was a CI, but she also didn't challenge JB's claim. For now, I'm leaning Noods a bit to the innocent side.
Dawg-what I've seen of Dawg, he's struck me as pro-town. Of course he's fooled me before...gonna lean him towards innocent for now.
Mad-his posts have struck me as pro-town, leaning him innocent. Haven't seen anything scummy from him so far.
Zaffy-I've got Zaffy as innocent. He picked up on Kash's inconsistencies last night before JB announced he was CI. No way scum would have done that with as well hidden as Kash was.
Rich-innocent since no scum turns since he was resurrected
JB-obviously innocent
Now it's hard to say who I would shoot. I've kind of listed them in a scummy order, I'd have to say it would be between Wiz and Ogre. JL scares me a bit, he could be scum hiding. Fire and Charlie's lack of play concerns me as well.
Regardless, I think the gs should listen to JB as to the final decision on who to shoot. That will protect the other remaining townie PRs as JB will obviously not tell you that they would be a good shot.
Wiz-defended Kash last night and couldn't see how JB coming out would be beneficial. Wiz, you're smarter than this. I've also learned from playing with you that you are very stubborn, so maybe your not being able to see how JB was telling the truth was just your stubbornness coming out (yes, pot calling the kettle black argument applies here). Also, the day 1 banter you had with Kash seemed staged to me. I know a couple others commented on that as well.
RB-needs to drink his prune juice so he's not so cranky. I actually think he's innocent and just got bored with the game. I don't think the shot should be wasted on him, just let him UD when we're in a different format if he wants out of the game. Of course he could be using reverse psychology here.
Ogre-was 100% wrong about Zs and didn't video himself eating his mousepad. I suspect he may have been the turn, but idk.
Charlie-I'm really disappointed in Charlie's play if he's innocent. What happened to the great bush kicking Charlie from games past? He's done more joking and flirting than anything in this game.
JL-can't get a read on JL. Hasn't been super helpful to the town from what I can tell, but he also didn't get hung up on giving FF a super hard time, which I would have expected if JL were scum.
Fire-can't tell with her, she's told us more about her rl than she's posted about the game. Scum sliding by or just too busy for the game?
Noods-not getting a scummy feeling from her, also, she hasn't decompensated as she tends to do when she's scum. Now she didn't get onto Kash until after JB had revealed he was a CI, but she also didn't challenge JB's claim. For now, I'm leaning Noods a bit to the innocent side.
Dawg-what I've seen of Dawg, he's struck me as pro-town. Of course he's fooled me before...gonna lean him towards innocent for now.
Mad-his posts have struck me as pro-town, leaning him innocent. Haven't seen anything scummy from him so far.
Zaffy-I've got Zaffy as innocent. He picked up on Kash's inconsistencies last night before JB announced he was CI. No way scum would have done that with as well hidden as Kash was.
Rich-innocent since no scum turns since he was resurrected
JB-obviously innocent
Now it's hard to say who I would shoot. I've kind of listed them in a scummy order, I'd have to say it would be between Wiz and Ogre. JL scares me a bit, he could be scum hiding. Fire and Charlie's lack of play concerns me as well.
Regardless, I think the gs should listen to JB as to the final decision on who to shoot. That will protect the other remaining townie PRs as JB will obviously not tell you that they would be a good shot.
