Mafia 73: Werewolf Game!

[jbradt]

Chill, it seems to me that the question you need to answer for yourself is what would you rather trust to place your vote: the best two cases that I've seen presented for scum (ie. Labby and Zaffy), or vague suspicions of what you would do "if" you were a wolf?

If you're not a wolf, then who cares what you would do if? If you are a wolf, then you're obviously lying. One way or the other, statements of "what I would do if" are irrelevant.

Fact is, there are a lot of reasons that the wolves may not have hit Kash: she may have had protection for the same reason she would make a good target, she was on to something d1 and it would have implicated a wolf or two, the very fact that we're having this discussion; and on and on and on. Do you have a better case on anyone? Have you seen anyone else present a better case on anyone?

I've noticed that you seem to like to start discussions this game on subjects that we can't really settle until after the game: why did they hit Wiz; Why did Kash not get hit. Seems to me like trying to start a lot of WIFOM :bs:. Not a good look, dude.

Seems a simple call to me.

 

[Zaffy]

I don't think that anyone believes that you were communicating with him at all. However the timing and content of your post along side Jpap makes me believe that there is possibility that you were trying to set him up. It isn't hard to make it seem like you were communicating with someone, it would be a very simple strategy to do so and then once they got lynched be all "see I wasn't communicating at all"

That theory combined with LR's whole "not dropping you off the list but putting you neutral, well not neutral but close to neutral on the scummy side" as she describes it makes me feel there is a connection there.

How did i set him up when my posts came before his?

Posted on mobile.aquariacentral.com

 

[AnniesNotOK]

opcorn:

 

[jbradt]

I vote to lynch Annie for not playing! :silly:

 

[Zaffy]

I can't quote kashtas full post. it makes my phone choke.

i just want to say i'm impressed by the amount of work you and your pack did to build a brand new case against me from scratch.

i encourage everyone to go over her post and check her claims on your own. make your own choice,

Posted on mobile.aquariacentral.com

 

[Fishfriend1]

opcorn:

I vote to lynch Annie for not playing! :silly:

Bala takes the one vote fer Annie to mean instant erradication, and hunts him down. When bala finds annie he secretly drops a banna peel in front of him, and cause annie was to buisly eating popcorn, he didn't see it in time and slipped, falling right into balas open mouth.

 

[jbradt]

Bala takes the one vote fer Annie to mean instant erradication, and hunts him down. When bala finds annie he secretly drops a banna peel in front of him, and cause annie was to buisly eating popcorn, he didn't see it in time and slipped, falling right into balas open mouth.

LOL... see... that's how much power I have! :raspberry:

 

[Dagamoth]

I was wrong last game when I found you suspicious for going after Ice so hard so I'm second guessing myself this game when I'm getting the same feeling but I definitely have a bad feeling.

You were liked a guided missle with built in scum detection last game and if your right this game then you're just scary good. Which leaves me wondering why the wolves didn't take you out last night.

That is exactly the only reason I have to suspect Kashta, she's just tooo freaking scary good. I really hope Kashta is innocent and if so the priest is at least considering protecting her.

 

[Dagamoth]

How did i set him up when my posts came before his?

Posted on mobile.aquariacentral.com

By playing into his theories yet keeping a distance. Encouragement for a line of question can do just as much as questioning without the direct correlation tying yourself to it.

 

[Lab_Rat]

You asked where you said Zaffy fell off your list....here ya go Labby.


You DID say he dropped off your list Lab, as I showed in the first quote of this post, so why do you continue to ask ppl where you said it?

As for your response to JB about how you play scummy...well to me if you realize others know this about you, wouldn't you change that? Pointing out the fact your are not play as you do when scummy, that just cracks me up and draws more attention to you IMO.

As far as the "timing" of Pap and Zaffs posts, yep they were one after another....AFTER Pap would post a thought, Zaff would follow with the same thought. Really if you look at how it played out, it doesn't look like they were playing "together" it looks like Zaff was hanging on and following Paps every post and thought.

Nope...I don't trust Rich, I trust NO ONE at this point...but with all the other stuff, being denied, or not answered, by others he DID answer the question.

You quoted where I said he dropped on my list. Never did he drop off. You are twisting my words. Actually, JB was the first to manipulate them, the rest of you just followed him. You've also got the timing of Zaffy and jpap's posts all messed up.

So tell me, what have I not answered. Rich has hardly posted anything helpful, yet you seem to be trusting him because he answered a question? And you don't question how an experienced vet like him could so egregiously misspeak? I think he slipped.

Interesting points made. I am leaning more towards LR than Zaffy. Zaffy is high on the list but Lr has me worried more. She is in armadillo mode, curl up and hope it goes by.

I vote to lynch LR.

Dude, if you knew my schedule and what my work now entails for this month, I think you'd take that back. I am getting up at 2:30 in the morning because I have to work up 18 trauma patients in the ICU before rounds, which start promptly at 6am. I wasn't done until after 3pm today, so before you accuse me of curling up and hiding take that into consideration. If I had known how crazy this rotation would be I would not have signed up for the game.

LR you seem really flustered and sloppy in your posting. I know you were working really long day and little bit of sleep but, you have gone way too aggressive after being extremely defensive in your posting. It's not your normal innocent style. To me it seems like you are swinging from extremes trying to catch hold of something that will throw suspicion off you. I believe you have given yourself away and most likely you'll be receiving my vote tonight.

No duh I'm defensive, and please, please, show me where I don't get defensive when innocent? It's something I've tried to work on, but when being attacked I can't help it. Tis my nature. You, of all people, should know that.

Now at this point it seems the only relevant information is that he has a connection with LR? Which is evidenced by her saying he dropped on her list. Not drooped off but dropped on. Is it a tell? could be but it's weak for the level of certainity I'm witnessing. Yes you guys know their play better than me and maybe I'm missing the boat I'll concede that.

OMG, someone who can finally read!!! :worthy: Now I have no idea what you mean as a tell, but I simply meant that I still think Zaffy could be evil (so I'm not clearing him), but there are others I feel are more evil. Obviously my words were twisted by others with ulterior motives.