I wasn't sure about JM either, Lady G, which is the main reason I wasn't sure which way to read Pappy. But after Lab Rat's attempt late last night to sway us into still killing JM, I'd rather lean him innocent instead.
Mafia 73: Werewolf Game!
- Thread starter Fishfriend1
- Start date
I wasn't sure about JM either, Lady G, which is the main reason I wasn't sure which way to read Pappy. But after Lab Rat's attempt late last night to sway us into still killing JM, I'd rather lean him innocent instead.
Not saying it is ok the "clear" someone Zaff, although he did explain his thought on that and I accept his answer.
Ok, I can see what you are saying...Although, I still feel they could of easily been trying to pull something.
My vote will most likely be Zaff or Lab, just want to see Labs response to questions before I decide which way to go. I have to head to work now and will put my vote once home.
Ah, heck I may as well place it now..I can always change if need be...
I vote to lynch Zaffy
So we've got two "joke" votes that ended up staying there and killing off our hunter. One vote was from Zaffy and one from Rich.
The initial votes aren't what bother me, it's the sticking with it. I feel like Rich's claims of nowhere better to place his vote are weak reasoning. Zaffy's reasoning, as far as I can find, is to point the finger at Rich. What the heck?
I had a weird feeling about Rich yesterday, but Zaffy is really standing out with his dodging. I feel like he is more dangerous.
I vote to lynch Zaffy
The initial votes aren't what bother me, it's the sticking with it. I feel like Rich's claims of nowhere better to place his vote are weak reasoning. Zaffy's reasoning, as far as I can find, is to point the finger at Rich. What the heck?
I had a weird feeling about Rich yesterday, but Zaffy is really standing out with his dodging. I feel like he is more dangerous.
I vote to lynch Zaffy
Actually, Tay; your post was very well thought out and written. Hell, sometimes I spend half an hour on a post only to never hit "submit".
Let me just say, you're doing a fine job as a new player who doesn't know anyone you're playing with/against in this game... as the rest of us do. We all have our own "usual" style of play. Some of us are quite vocal; others are not. Since most of us have been in so many previous games together, your main disadvantage as a newcomer is having no clue which way to read people. That also means it's very difficult for you to interpret possible scum-tells from one individual to another.
You don't know Rich, as we do. Therefore, you had no way of knowing Rich is usually a player who doesn't post very much regardless of his role.
This also means that your observations and misgivings about him were (IMO) genuine. And from that standpoint, the posts you've made sharing your impressions with us in this game shows good effort on your part to help us find scum.
Can't say I disagree with you, Is it better to leave an iffy vote or move a vote to some else which was just as iffy. Should I have killed off some else, would that have been better? As it turned out it might have been but it could also have been worse. Maybe I should have made it a 5 way tie? I do not see how that would have helped at all. So I decided to just leave the vote there.
I vote to lynch Zaffy.
You used jpappy to attempt to build a case against me, where I questioned a vote early on that you have not even answered for now when others are asking you to explain. Votig for someone because they said that they may or may not have skimmed rules they have read a thousand times isn't a "joke" vote, it's a way for scum to seemingly get in on who they know is an innocent. You mirroring pappy put suspicion on both of you but moreso him because he was so overzealous. You used this to your advantage because you knew he was an innocent, and when he came ip dead it would be easy to cry "it was a joke vote! All of the other voters followed me and killed the hunter".
You used jpappy to attempt to build a case against me, where I questioned a vote early on that you have not even answered for now when others are asking you to explain. Votig for someone because they said that they may or may not have skimmed rules they have read a thousand times isn't a "joke" vote, it's a way for scum to seemingly get in on who they know is an innocent. You mirroring pappy put suspicion on both of you but moreso him because he was so overzealous. You used this to your advantage because you knew he was an innocent, and when he came ip dead it would be easy to cry "it was a joke vote! All of the other voters followed me and killed the hunter".
Yeah, so? I've been through all your posts already. Whatever your so-called "real" reasons were or weren't are of no consequence anymore.
Go away little doggie.
(Found Zaffy's actual response embedded in the quote he pulled.)
