Mafia 73: Werewolf Game!

Fishfriend1 said:
IT IS NIGHT!

Final Vote Count:

Lab_Rat(0):Kashta, Jm1212, Dag

Kashta(5):Lab_Rat, User_Name,Lady G, Taysius,Chill

User_name(6):Pirahna86, Rocker, Rich, Kashta, JM1212, Dag
Click to expand...


What about the vote spread? any thing to be learned from this? I think the wolves would be spreadout so that when an innocent went down they wouldn't all be obvious. Of the switch voters two are cleared leaving Dag. He says he 100% accurate on reading you Kash - how are you at reading him?

I would think there was at least one wolf on Kash and User is cleared leaving LR, G, Tay and me.
I would also think at least one of the original votes on User was wolf as well. So that leaves Pir, and Rocker. I all ready said I think Rocker is scum but that doesn't clear Pir. This would be a good place for the wolves to be since the town seemed intent to do their work for them.

I'm going to sleep on this mess and see how it looks in the morning.
 
Kashta said:
No offense to you Chill, but I would rather hear your suspects and your thoughts right now than have you prompting me to reveal mine. My suspect list hasn't been anything to brag about thus far. There's no denying that. But since the wolves haven't killed me yet, I'm still stuck in this game having to figure something out. And for that, we need real input from all townies. That's also why we need to be very clear and do this out in the open. That's the only way we're going to find scum at all.
Click to expand...


No offense taken. I agree it's time to put our cards on the table. My thoughts at the moment were posted above before I read your post. As to a suspect list. I'm still hopeful with only 3 men at arms we're only dealing with three wolves but we better play for 4. Suspect list for what's it's worth as it's mostly gut reaction at the moment is:
Rocker
Dag
Tay/LG
Pir
 
I'm leaning towards Rocker, Dag and Piranha.

I am not sure about Chill. Nothing has stood out to me as scummy from him but I guess that's sort of the point.

Rich sorta half cleared Lab rat. It's not the same as a clear but I'm not confident in voting her.

I don't know what to think about Lady G either. It's like her niceness is blinding me or something. Maybe it's the innocent looking avatar?

I'm afraid to think too hard on anyone though. Especially after tonight's infopalooza. Wish I could have a drink!
 
I guess I will go ahead and vote. Always subject to change if something more promising comes up.

I vote to lynch Rocker
 
Chill said:
What about the vote spread? any thing to be learned from this? I think the wolves would be spreadout so that when an innocent went down they wouldn't all be obvious. Of the switch voters two are cleared leaving Dag. He says he 100% accurate on reading you Kash - how are you at reading him?

I would think there was at least one wolf on Kash and User is cleared leaving LR, G, Tay and me.
I would also think at least one of the original votes on User was wolf as well. So that leaves Pir, and Rocker. I all ready said I think Rocker is scum but that doesn't clear Pir. This would be a good place for the wolves to be since the town seemed intent to do their work for them.

I'm going to sleep on this mess and see how it looks in the morning.
Click to expand...

Only reason I swapped my votes was because I believed that Kashta was innocent before nightfall. I said i was 100% accurate on reading my sister (lab rat) every game we have played together so far. I am sure that Lab Rat is WW, I am confident that LG is werewolf. I also think that piranha is werewolf and can see Rocker being werewolf since my sister hasn't been grilling him about his lack of posting.

Also I pointed out that everyone who voted for Lab Rat night two was a target of the WW. Rich got taken out tonight by them which leaves only me for the people who voted for LR night 2.
 
Lady G said:
I'm still interested in this "one time PM" thing Kash is trying to say happened...I looked back to the rules, it says nothing about a one time PM for the Seer
Click to expand...

Lady G, I'll admit I had to skim the thread to catch up real fast and get my post submitted before nightfall. I don't recall saying anything about a one-time PM.

Where does that come from?
 
Stupid game makes it so I can't turn my mind off, especially with all the craziness at this nightfall.

My most scummy suspects are Dag and Rocker.

I think Dag is playing everyone for fools. His post tonight confirms this thought, he is still pressing that I'm a ww even though Rich "thought" I was innocent. His jump tonight shocked me...I can see why JM would trust Kash to jump like that, but for Dag to have blind faith in her makes no sense. The only thing that makes sense would be if he knew both Kash and UN would show innocent and he suspected UN had a PR. UN most certainly hinted at PRs this game. Being a werewolf, he would also know JM was innocent, so by following two innocents he's going to blend right in and not arouse suspicion of those two players. He's a smart guy, there is a good chance he'd made the connection that Kash and JM were CI since there is no other reason for JM's adamant defense of Kash unless they were teammates. I mistook this for ww teammates. Dag, being a ww, would know otherwise. Nice try Dag, but I'm not buying it. Additionally, Dag has done nothing to help the town, except try to railroad me, someone else he knows is innocent.

Rocker has done nothing for the town. He posts jokey posts, then absolutely nothing but votes so he doesn't UD. His vote helped lynch the priest. Other than that, there is nothing really to go on with him. A townie would have done more, rather than just laying low and not doing anything to help find scum.

Piranha- continual battle with UN, haven't seen much to help the town. possibly a noob that got too sidetracked fighting with another noob, who knows. I don't trust him as it seems he couldn't look beyond his wrestling match with UN to try and find scum, but the same could be said for UN and we all know what his role turned out to be.

Those 3 are my revised scum team, but there very well could be a 4th. Since I can't figure the 4th out, I'll give you guys my thoughts on the remaining players, other than Kash and JM.

Chill- Haven't seen anything scummy out of him, but I also haven't played much with him before, so it's hard for me to read him. Is he talented enough to fool the town this whole time? I haven't really seen him on anyone's suspect list. I'm don't get an evil vibe from him at this point but I had Kash pegged as alpha wolf, so take that with a grain of salt.

LG- Seems to have been helping the town this whole time and actively seeking scum. I don't like my vote on her right now as I'm not convinced she's a ww. I am confused as to why she couldn't see Rich declared Kash innocent when Rich was confirmed seer. That rapid vote she put out took me aback, each time we learn new information at nightfall it's got to be re-incorporated into a new hypothesis. That being said, I still don't see her as scum and my vote will likely go to Dag or Rocker.

Tay- Seems to be helping the town as well. She's picked up on the game quickly, but I haven't seen anything out of her that says scum. Her posts seem legitimately pro-town.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom