Mafia 73: Werewolf Game!

I have to be honest, folks. I don't see a real case against Rocker. Yet, look how many people are leading us to believe he's more suspicious than anyone else in the game. Lady G and Chill put him up as their suspect. And so has Lab Rat. Lab Rat and Chill are actually voting him today. And so is Taysius.

Rocker is the one person participating less than anyone else. He's also rarely here at all. That makes him the LEAST likely person to put up a defense at all or even argue with anyone who actually posts.

And if his past games are any indication, he doesn't really follow the details all that much whether he's innocent or communicating evil.

That was true about his game all the way back to MY second mafia game where we recruited him to our evil team by resurrecting him from the dead. (Gotta love those games with blue mist.) Anyway, he didn't use a lack of posting or just making goofy posts as mafia strategy at all and I don't believe that's what he's doing now. It took me a while to remember this, myself, because it's been so long since he even played... and that's why I ended up voted him Day 1. Unless you know this about Rocker already (or remember how he plays), then yes he looks scummy whether he is or isn't.

For that matter, look when Rocker put himself up for a self-vote and Fishfriend had to tell him he wasn't allowed to do that, we (JB and I) don't think he would have called attention to himself like that if he was one of the wolves.

He also parked his vote on User Name (an innocent) for three days in a row. I don't think the evils would stand aside and let him do that either if he were communicating with them. Even if he wasn't paying much attention or cited some reason or another, his teammates would surely tell him to knock that off and spread his vote around a little.

Even unsupported, random voting would draw less suspicion against him (and their teammate) than that.

To those of you counting on Rocker right now as something of a scapegoat to get you through the day, do you really expect us to believe you can't find anyone scummier than him?
 
Kash, again I ask, where is all this awesome evidence you have on me? Besides JB "thinks" I'm scum. Because that's just plain lame. Not to mention how off you've been this entire game, now you're just keeping it up.

Lab Rat, the only reason you aren't dead already is I made the mistake of thinking it was okay to lynch Zaffy first and others agreed with me.

JB made a very solid case against you right before you killed him. And the only reason I didn't pursue you just as hard at the same time was because JB and I were communicating with each other. We knew it was risky enough as often as we agreed with each other in this thread that the werewolves were bound to realize we were communicating.

Nevertheless, we both felt there was an equally strong case against you and Zaffy both. And nothing you've shown us since then diminishes this in any way.

We've since learned that Zaffy was innocent. And based on your game we ended up lynching the wrong suspect. That worked out well to your favor because it helped kill off another innocent townie and it bought you another day of life to continue posting and scheming the way you had been, which is what made you suspicious to us in the first place.

There really isn't time now for us to let you split us up or sidetrack us now into bickering back and forth. You had the whole 3-day weekend to help the town find REAL scum when you were posting without anyone speaking up to challenge you. Most of the vets who know you and your mafia tactics are already dead. Of those who remain, the others only go through the motions of questioning you and the noobs have no way to tell whether you're filling this thread with lies or not.

Either way, at this point the game comes to a head tonight. Win or lose, one way or another. But I'm not going to let you wiggle away from scrutiny one more time to get us onto someone else instead.
 
:popcorn:
 
I have to be honest, folks. I don't see a real case against Rocker. Yet, look how many people are leading us to believe he's more suspicious than anyone else in the game. Lady G and Chill put him up as their suspect. And so has Lab Rat. Lab Rat and Chill are actually voting him today. And so is Taysius.

Rocker is the one person participating less than anyone else. He's also rarely here at all. That makes him the LEAST likely person to put up a defense at all or even argue with anyone who actually posts.

And if his past games are any indication, he doesn't really follow the details all that much whether he's innocent or communicating evil.

That was true about his game all the way back to MY second mafia game where we recruited him to our evil team by resurrecting him from the dead. (Gotta love those games with blue mist.) Anyway, he didn't use a lack of posting or just making goofy posts as mafia strategy at all and I don't believe that's what he's doing now. It took me a while to remember this, myself, because it's been so long since he even played... and that's why I ended up voted him Day 1. Unless you know this about Rocker already (or remember how he plays), then yes he looks scummy whether he is or isn't.

For that matter, look when Rocker put himself up for a self-vote and Fishfriend had to tell him he wasn't allowed to do that, we (JB and I) don't think he would have called attention to himself like that if he was one of the wolves.

He also parked his vote on User Name (an innocent) for three days in a row. I don't think the evils would stand aside and let him do that either if he were communicating with them. Even if he wasn't paying much attention or cited some reason or another, his teammates would surely tell him to knock that off and spread his vote around a little.

Even unsupported, random voting would draw less suspicion against him (and their teammate) than that.

To those of you counting on Rocker right now as something of a scapegoat to get you through the day, do you really expect us to believe you can't find anyone scummier than him?

I don't know why I'm even going to argue this but can you really blame someone for not once more following you unquestioningly. You and JB decided Pap and Zaff were communicating and Pap died, then you went after Zaff, then you took out user. You might be right on LR I don't know but excuse me if I hesitate. Even bringing this to your attention is counter-productive and probably hurts the town. Tell you what take a second think it over, if you're so sure you're right say the word and I will move my vote to the person of your choice.
 
I was going to ask JB to pass the popcorn
but popcorn ain.t going to cut it
6.gif
 
Lab Rat, the only reason you aren't dead already is I made the mistake of thinking it was okay to lynch Zaffy first and others agreed with me.

JB made a very solid case against you right before you killed him. And the only reason I didn't pursue you just as hard at the same time was because JB and I were communicating with each other. We knew it was risky enough as often as we agreed with each other in this thread that the werewolves were bound to realize we were communicating.

Nevertheless, we both felt there was an equally strong case against you and Zaffy both. And nothing you've shown us since then diminishes this in any way.

We've since learned that Zaffy was innocent. And based on your game we ended up lynching the wrong suspect. That worked out well to your favor because it helped kill off another innocent townie and it bought you another day of life to continue posting and scheming the way you had been, which is what made you suspicious to us in the first place.

There really isn't time now for us to let you split us up or sidetrack us now into bickering back and forth. You had the whole 3-day weekend to help the town find REAL scum when you were posting without anyone speaking up to challenge you. Most of the vets who know you and your mafia tactics are already dead. Of those who remain, the others only go through the motions of questioning you and the noobs have no way to tell whether you're filling this thread with lies or not.

Either way, at this point the game comes to a head tonight. Win or lose, one way or another. But I'm not going to let you wiggle away from scrutiny one more time to get us onto someone else instead.

Kash, that sounds like pride getting in your way...[sarcasm]you've been so right about everyone all game long. The equally strong case you had against Zaffy sure panned out well for ya, great results for the town. [/sarcasm] Can you not admit when you're wrong?
 
less then an hour till nightfall, be there or be square
 
Ok, i got a PM from Ice saying i should undo Dags follow thing.

Revised vote count:

Vote Count:

Lady G(3):Kashta, Lab,Dag, JM1212,Pirahna,Rocker

Rocker(3):Taysius,Chill,Lab_Rat

Dag(1): Lady G

Lab_Rat(2):Dag,Kashta , JM1212

Nightfall at 8 tonight, be there or be square!
 
AquariaCentral.com