Mafia #74...ACville Penitentiary!

I really thought that he was good, and that JM was evil. My whole flipping take on this game has been tossed around, and I don't know where to start looking. Why the hit on RB? Maybe to set-up bally?
 
Well that messed me up. Perhaps I can't read people as well as I thought.
 
good night Acville Pennitentary! Hopefully we can catch whoever was in cahoots with JB asap.
 
Zaffy said:
How do they get cleared in your opinion?
Click to expand...

They both voted JB. Maybe I shouldn't clear Chill as he was a late vote onto JB at a time that he was pretty safe. But 2H is cleared IMO for his vote on JB and because JB voted for 2H. I also think Noods is cleared for the reason that JB voted her. For now I'm going to consider these 3 as cleared though.

Now that I have some time,kid in bed, I'm going to try and see what JBs suspect lists looked like.
 
jbradt said:
Ok... had to take a break for a while. Now that I'm back, this is the first thing that caught my attention. I'm not seeing the coziness, Tay... she wanted to cut off my head for cigarettes. All that early stuff was day 1 banter. Not sure what you're seeing there.
Click to expand...

jbradt said:
Ok... Zaffy. I've got to say, Zaff; it took me a long time to even find something to comment on. I was about to comment on that when I found some actual content in your posts.
Finally after Jpap calls you out and specifically asks you who your suspects are you come out with this "list". I've read it a few times though; and while it seems you put a list together; it seems to be a list of things you're unsure of. Now that we have some actual info to work with; who are your suspects at this point?

I actually agree with this point about RB. It seems strange that he would stick with a (presumably) joke vote, when he seemed to have a pretty strong suspicion of me. Then again; who can tell with RB anyway; ever? Is that why you picked him to question, Zaffy? Did you realize that no matter how he answered it would amount to nothing anyway? Made you look kind of helpful though. :thubsup:

This post raises some hairs for me. It seems Zaffy's both defending UN and attacking his biggest accuser.

Zaffy calls out his own post as scummy. Why would someone do this other than an attempt to "innoculate" themselves from someone else calling it out?


WTF? What was the big revalation, Zaff? I realize that you were wearing your skimpants, but dang. You've been back and forth as much as User Name.

I don't want to challenge your reading skills, Zaff; so I'll put it this way:
Click to expand...

jbradt said:
2H:
I haven't pulled all 11 posts, because they were Largely :bs:. Here's the stuff I found that was actually game related.
Apparently, me, Zaffy and Vixen are suspects here. But I'm having trouble figuring out whether any of this is actual suspicion or joking. What say you, 2H? This is also the infamous slip re: Zaffy. It did take you a while to answer that question, 2H even though a couple people asked you about it. That worries me. If you are evil, maybe you took what Pir said about ignoring a question once to heart? He played a good game last time as scum... I can see another noob picking up on his hints.



Finally you answer the question. Did you feel responding to Tay would be easier than Labby? Also, who did you kick at... and when? I looked though all your posts and I must have missed that part... :huh:.

Pot, meet kettle. You can call UN out for not being "into the game", but at least he's posting and giving people a chance to read him. Let me reiterate that you've posted 11 times since the start of the game, and most of it has been pointless. (That being said, UN is on deck for scrutiny).

2H's response to Labby pointing out that he didn't answer her question about his comment re: Zaffy when he was asked before. Not sure if I buy it.

So you voted an innocent. That happens and I can't fault you for it. But where was any suspicion on Pir before this post? Did you really vote him because he played a good game last time? You call out UN for not reading the rules... I don't understand why you would play the game and not bother to post anything related. This all seems really off to me 2H. And "missing" this post or failing to respond will likely draw my d2 vote.
Click to expand...

jbradt said:
As promised... UN:
This is about 2H. User, you posted a LOT before this post (this was around 300 I think), but it was all :bs:. In fact, I feel like I need to apologize to 2H a little bit for giving you credit for posting so much.

Here is where UN jumps on JM's "mistake" and votes Pir. Seems a little odd after saying 2H was his only scumspect.

Numbers :bs:.

At least there's a little bit of a reason given here. Would have sat easier with me if these had been the reasons in the vote post, rather than JM's thoughts.

I don't know what to think of this post. Pappy asked before UN, and I don't see a response here... which post did you misread? And whose was it?

Frankly, UN; I find it hard to believe you haven't had "a whole lot of time to be posting", or that you've "only seen a handful of posts". You've posted quite a bit and responded to many posts.


I don't get this post at all... UN had already voted, and on one of the peeps he was going to break the tie against? Can you explain your thinking here, UN?
This makes the last post make even less sense. I think Ice pointed it out at the time. User, did you start drinking before you started posting? And what's with the unofficial second vote? I'm having trouble figuring out if you're really as confused as you seem to be, or if you're full of crap.

Right, your vote is subject to change since you DIDN'T REALLY CHANGE IT ALREADY. This makes me think the unofficial change was planned as opposed to a mistake...

More about Vixen.

To Noods.

How positive do you really expect to be, UN. How positive were you about Pir? Psst... he was innocent.

Again with wanting to be sure...

Comment on Zaffy calling himself out for being scummy... I have no idea how to interpret this post. At all. Even a little. I think FF really is playing.

To JM. Again... No real clue here.

Thanks for the input...

I'm reserving judgment on UN, as I am on everyone. I have trouble thinking anyone could be that confused. But I also have trouble believing anyone would purposely act so confused. I'd like to hear a response, UN. Like 2H; failing to respond will likely draw my vote.
Click to expand...

jbradt said:
Sorry you're not feeling well, Vix... I hope you play again.

I still like my vote on 2H, but I can see moving to JM or UN if that vote looks like it's going to be wasted. I'm also really looking at Zaffy still. His sarcasm coupled with his more recent silence has me worried. I'd really like to hear more from him before voting that way though.

I can see what Ice is saying about Noods, but again, I'd like to see more before going that way.
Click to expand...

jbradt said:
I have to ask about this, Noods. Your line about me almost sounds like you're trying to sow subtle seeds of doubt about me. Why would you say that you're "very easily fooled"? In one sentence, you admit that I'm working hard for the town, in the next it almost seems like you're using that to incriminate me. That plus the banter with Ice is something that makes me go hmmmm.

I have to go back and check on something...
Click to expand...


So pretty much these were the people he went after or ones who questioned him pretty good. This includes Chill who had a few good questioning posts.

That leaves me to think I can trust 2H Chill Noods Tay Zaffy UN

That leaves as suspects

Rich
Bally
Pap
DD

Doubt there are 5 snitches. So 1 or 2 of these players are innocent.

I'm leaning Jpap DD as last 2 snitches.

Thoughts??
 
The tinfoil aficionado and margarita to blood volume ratio in me are entertaining the idea that it's possible the scum team had control of the vote block and used it on one of their own.

I have no proof of this, but the choice of Chill just strikes me as very odd. He's not been particularly active (kettle meet pot).

It's entirely likely that I'm totally wrong on this. But I don't think it's worth ignoring.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom