Mafia #76 Game Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

jm1212 said:
I have to agree with pappy. Your case against chill was weak, but at least you had a case against him. But instead of that, you go with Bally? I vote to lynch DD just in case I don't get back.

UN, don't tempt me.
Click to expand...

jm1212 said:
I k own vote on DD seems a little random, but her vote on Bally just seems like a wasted and safe vote since Bally hasn't caused any attention yet, especially with her 'case' agains other people. I'm not ready at this point to vote PP or UN. PP just seems like he's a bit lost, and I'm not seeing a case against UN right away like I did in 74
Click to expand...

ummmm... what case on Chill, jm?? and you agree with pap... ok... I thought paps vote was "for the simple fact that it was pap, and why not".... I do find it interesting of you trying to make something out of it though...

my vote on bally is because that is all I had, from what I have read, Bally had 1 vote on her already so wasted vote... no. More like putting her up there with the others that had 1 or 2 votes... so your logic is a bit flawed and reaching JM... care to elaborate in your own words? I mean something better than noting that I have 1 vote on me seeming random and then going in and voting for me for the very reason that you "suspect" me for... come on...
 
I meant - ice is the only one with no votes. I realize now that there are plenty of others that don't have any, they're just on the list because of the redacted vote. Doh!
 
user_name said:
Ok, so it seems that bunch of people jump onto pat, and then he shrugs it off with more of a non-sense post. That makes it sound to me like he is trying to go under the radar by not arguing or making a big case in his defense. IME when I'm innocent I ALWAYS try as hard as possible to prove so, (and when I'm guilty:silly: too but thats a different story entirely) Anyways, I find it strange that he has gotten so many votes so quickly. Would hate to see him turn innocent, but for lack of better suspects I vote to lynch pat
 If pat shows up tonight and makes a good case against some other players then he might prove himself innocent. Do you have anything to say for yourself pat?
Click to expand...
I find it strange that you call a lone vote (Dawg's) on PP to be "so many votes so quickly". I also find the post I pulled that from to be suspicious.

patrick.paul said:
Real quick to switch sides? First you defend me, then you suspect me :footinmouth:

...

For now on my list: Ballyhoo, jbradt, Lab_Rat, Razzlefish (no particular order).
Click to expand...

I never defended you, but yes, I suspect you. And that list is so full of OMGUS it makes me lol hard. :laugh:

rich311k said:
It is a little early for the death speech. Wait till about an hour before nightfall and then really sell it.

I vote to lynch UN. That last post was a classic defense post of his.
Click to expand...

I have to agree with that post being UN's sort of evil defense post.

user_name said:
pat is just digging himself a deeper and deeper grave in my book.
Could you please show us the posts you found instigating by LG?
(sorry to reitterate what you said razzle)

Oh and whats wrong rich, you don't like it when I mention your "different" play style?
Click to expand...

Please show how PP is digging himself deeper and deeper...I see a new player trying to get the hang of the game. I've seen stuff that could be scummy or could be noob, I'm haven't been able to decipher which it is yet.

The only thing I see different with Rich is he's posting a lot more, which imo is a good thing. Usually no matter what his role he's quiet.

patrick.paul said:
These were the posts happening shortly before my comment about her instigating. These posts started it all which is why I pointed my finger at her.
Click to expand...
I don't see anything instigating from LG in those posts.


IceH2O said:
I have a problem with UNs quote I put in red. Its strange that so many piled on but you vote him anyway? If you hadn't skimmed you'd see people only spoke of voting him. I don't think he actually has many votes. Unless I missed it Dawg was the only official vote.
Then you say you'd hate for him to show innocent but further down in the post you attack him by pulling posts of others questioning him. For someone you hate to have to vote for because you don't have other suspects you sure did try to build a case.

...

Day 1 sucks,well known that the odds of getting mafia are slim but it has happened.Most times we just lynch the most outspoken person of the day.
PP has seemed to slip, he did ignore questions, he then learned to multiquote. His list is those who questioned him.
To me that equates to new player no team IMO and my vote won't fall there.



I vote to lynch UN


His post is the most contradictory I've seen on Day 1 in a while.
Click to expand...

I have to say, I find myself agreeing with Ice. I haven't seen anything scummy enough to lynch any of the noobs on day 1, but UN seems to be playing his "evil" game. I vote to lynch UN.
 
jbradt said:
I'm flattered that you'd think of me, UN. Don't really know what you're looking for on day 1 though.

Bally, ALL of my posts thus far have been jokes! It's day 1. I haven't seen anything incredibly scummy, so I pop in with a quick, pithy quip; make myself giggle, and pop back out. You've entirely misread the "banter" between PP and myself. I'd say that was way more 1 sided than you're making it look like, but w/e.

I'd love to get all OMGUSSY and vote Bally, but I don't think that if she was evil she would choose me to go after; 'specially so ealy on d1. Patrick... I can see an evil newb being told to try to cozy up to an innocent vet. But I'm still going to give him the benefit of the doubt based on his newb card. UN... I'm not reading UN as scummy at this point.

I vote to lynch Maverick for an incredibly vague gut feeling I'm getting.
Click to expand...

Wow climbing way out on a limb with that vote JB.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom