Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

[Ballyhoo]

That was agreed with Jm and then directed to salt

 

[jm1212]

Dude, really? Its a mafia game, did you not read my post about the fact that i really like mafia movies, forgive a guy for trying to make things fun. Your takin this WAYYY to serioulsly. Oh, and btw, I found a great doctor who will look at your Seemy fingers for super cheap! he says he'll get you fixed up real quick. lmao

Did you read the rules? Im pretty sure this will be answeres by the most important rule in jpap's rules spread


If youre really getting that much of a kick out of it then you must not get out much...

 

[Salt4Sam]

Did you read the rules? Im pretty sure this will be answeres by the most important rule in jpap's rules spread


If youre really getting that much of a kick out of it then you must not get out much...

I get out plenty, do me a favor, Im gonna go to bed, i have work at 8. Pull the stick out, and try to have some fun tommorrow k? Night:thumbsup:

 

[jm1212]

I get out plenty, do me a favor, Im gonna go to bed, i have work at 8. Pull the stick out, and try to have some fun tommorrow k? Night:thumbsup:

Um, excuse me? I question you, and then you give vague answers and then make fun of my stupid technological errors and then you say that? I dont know what kind of games you read, but stuff like that isnt encouraged.

 

[jm1212]

Dude, really? Its a mafia game, did you not read my post about the fact that i really like mafia movies, forgive a guy for trying to make things fun. Your takin this WAYYY to serioulsly. Oh, and btw, I found a great doctor who will look at your Seemy fingers for super cheap! he says he'll get you fixed up real quick. lmao

Another question...how would you know what too seriously is? You seemed not to know what was good to post for the town earlier since its your 'first game' but now you seem to know enough as to what is being to serious or not. Enough with the going back and forth between the newbie face and the 'experienced' face

 

[Salt4Sam]

Um, excuse me? I question you, and then you give vague answers and then make fun of my stupid technological errors and then you say that? I dont know what kind of games you read, but stuff like that isnt encouraged.

PM'ed

 

[Ballyhoo]

Because I've read a couple games, means that i get the general concept of what goes on. I see how the game works. i watch as people point fingers and try to convince other people of this or the other thing. That does not however, negate the fact that this is the first game that i have PLAYED. Therefore, if you would like me, to try to help YOU with whatever it is that your trying to do, then feel free to once again, let me know. Either ask me to help, so i can, or tell me to buzz off, so we can get this useless babbling out of the way.

This is one of many quotes you've tossed out saying you have no problem answering any questions, I, and others, have asked you one and you wont answer it.

So i can put it all out there, and watch as the people in question either stop doing what i think, or continue it just to mess with the whole theory. Or, i can sit back, watch, figure out how this whole little game goes, and then if, or when im sure, i'll make sure everyone knows. Promise. Soon too.

Suspicion is not less an enemy to virtue than to happiness; he that is already corrupt is naturally suspicious, and he that becomes suspicious will quickly be corrupt. :uhoh:
-Joseph Addison

Just how suspicious are you Jm?

so you refuse to say your list because you are paranoid that when you finally reveal this so sought after holy grail of information that everyone involved will change their behavior. Wouldn't that be noticeable, and actually give a reason into looking into them?

I just find it interesting that you dog Jm ( I believe ) for being suspicious but you are being paranoid....correct me if i'm wrong but aren't those two things very similar?

 

[Kashta]

I'm not sure what you don't get? It was a statement because that was what we were talking about at that point, based on other hand-picked games pappy has run. As time went on though, it mad less sense to me that he would hand-pick the roles since most games are randomly assigned, and sloths ones I have played recently were.

I didn't get how your logic switched on that because it doesn't show anywhere in the thread and in the later post I quoted, you seemed to contradict what you had just posted less than a hour before-hand.

I was reading back in the thread when I noticed your statement, "I seriously doubt he hand-picked the roles..." My thought then was, hey wait a minute.... wasn't JM one of the folks real early in the game who supposed Pappy DID hand-pick the roles? But now he's saying he "seriously doubts" it?

I went back to re-read that section to find out what changed your mind. And I didn't find anything to explain that.... that's why I just asked you about this.

These posts (one after the other) were all made within minutes of each other.

How many scum should we predict are in this game. I want to say 5, there's 21 players and it's usually 25%, correct? Also, does that count the snitch? I think counting the snitch, we can figure there are 5-6 mafia.
Also, JPap, forgive me if I am skimming, but were the PR's and mafia random or did you hand pick?

I'd guess 5 scum. Jpap likes to handpick for PRs/scum.

i wonder if they were handpicked this round.

There you are posting along with 2 other players who also figured Pappy chose the roles.... not random.

Then approx. 45 min later you disagreed with your own previous comment, (and theirs) by saying you seriously don't think Pappy picked the roles. I just wondered what changed your mind about it.

JM, you also commented in this response to me (quoted above) that Pappy hand-picks roles in his games. But you still think he didn't this time? Why... what makes you think he wouldn't for this game when he has before so many times?

 

[Ballyhoo]

PM'ed

explain......

 

[Salt4Sam]

This is one of many quotes you've tossed out saying you have no problem answering any questions, I, and others, have asked you one and you wont answer it





so you refuse to say your list because you are paranoid that when you finally reveal this so sought after holy grail of information that everyone involved will change their behavior. Wouldn't that be noticeable, and actually give a reason into looking into them?

I just find it interesting that you dog Jm ( I believe ) for being suspicious but you are being paranoid....correct me if i'm wrong but aren't those two things very similar?

Nobody here said anything about it being a holy grail of information. I thought about a few people, so i looked into previous games to see how they played. The information, that i spent my time looking for is available to you, if you want it soo bad. Im not being paranoid about anything, you point at me and ill point back at you. thats how this game works. And for the record, between you and Jm you have no room to talk about "dogging" anybody.