Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

[Lab_Rat]

what happened to not discussing PR's? did the whole town bump it's head?

I just wanted to put my thoughts out there on who might be scum. Didn't want to bring up theories on who could be townie PRs.

Go out for a day and you miss quite a bit. Not sure what to make of salt. He may be over roll playing like PP did which amounted to nothing.

I cant decide whose theory is more iffy, Ice's or LR's, at least Ice did not vote based on his.

Do you have a better suggestion on where I should place my vote? As I've said before, I realize it's a stretch. If there were more to go on then I wouldn't have put my vote on Dawg, but so far there is not much that I've seen.

Just checking in...I need to go back and do some catching up. There are a lot of posts already. This one just happened to catch my eye...



...lol...I love this theory LR . As you have said I've had that title for a long time. I must have been the Don for a lot of games if this theory is correct. It is day one so I can't blame you for trying to come up with something even though it is extremely far fetched.

Glad you like the theory Dawg. I'm really hoping you like it because it's correct.

I think delving into Paps mind could be painful. I also think he could have picked based on some off the wall scheme.

It is painful, trying to think what would jpap do...but like I said, his reasoning from the Christmas game for who got what role has really stuck with me. I'm not going to ignore something like that since it could be a huge help to the town if true.

 

[Salt4Sam]

so... for the past couple hours or so, i have been taking notes on a couple of previous games, and comparing them to my notes on this game. Im watching a few people now, and their patterns on how much, and who they speak with, and how they go about saying things... Im beginning to see some strangely familiar patterns. I think my vote is slowly beginning to narrow down.

 

[Lab_Rat]

so... for the past couple hours or so, i have been taking notes on a couple of previous games, and comparing them to my notes on this game. Im watching a few people now, and their patterns on how much, and who they speak with, and how they go about saying things... Im beginning to see some strangely familiar patterns. I think my vote is slowly beginning to narrow down.

Care to share your observations with the town?

 

[Ballyhoo]

I'd like to hear this list

 

[Salt4Sam]

Not quite yet. Thats like publishing an unfinished hypothesis to a bunch of speculative scientists. I wanna see how everything works out. Im trying to see if i can figure a couple of people out so i'll have a cheat sheet for the future. I could have my figures all wrong, you never know :footinmouth::huh:

 

[Lab_Rat]

Yes, but not sharing info and theories does not benefit the town. I mean, I could have kept my theory about jpap picking Dawg to myself, but then if I'm hit or lynched and it turns out to be correct then I would never have put that idea out there.

 

[Ballyhoo]

If you read so many other games you would know that it is important to post your suspects and reasons why.

 

[rich311k]

Maybe part of the analysis is to see how we react to his not sharing.

 

[IceH2O]

Not quite yet. Thats like publishing an unfinished hypothesis to a bunch of speculative scientists. I wanna see how everything works out. Im trying to see if i can figure a couple of people out so i'll have a cheat sheet for the future. I could have my figures all wrong, you never know :footinmouth::huh:

But it also helps us see certain things too. Sometimes we get blinded to certain aspects purely because we got played by that player the past games or think we can pick out a tell thats not really there.

 

[Salt4Sam]

So i can put it all out there, and watch as the people in question either stop doing what i think, or continue it just to mess with the whole theory. Or, i can sit back, watch, figure out how this whole little game goes, and then if, or when im sure, i'll make sure everyone knows. Promise. Soon too.