I retract my vote to lynch Kashta and vote to lynch Piranha.
I can't imagine why any scum team would waste an ability like that on day 1. I think you're trying to make us question wether or not they will still have it on future nights.
As far as Ice vs Labrat vs salt.
I think that salt got caught up in a little role-play and that he's likely just a regular townie.
I find it highly questionable that Ice would go out naming PRs at any time, much less day 1. part of me fears that he might be trying to control the invests away from himself. He knows that he would be a high priority mark.
Lab_rat, I haven't really read into as much as I should have, I think her case against Dawg is ridiculous though. the fact that pappy has done something similar to that in the past is the only reason I didn't vote her.
I think a tie between these two is perfectly ok in my book. They are both scummy on their own merits.