Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

[the wizard]

What about her posts makes you think so?

I have not seen much to change my mind about things. I wish I had found even a small revelation in today's posting, but not so far.

I still would not shoot Ice. I am rethinking my pick of LG though. I have to digest all of this a bit.

Would a mafia member be out there throwing around ideas or just grunting that makes sense or some such not committal post.

You tell me Rich, you have played far mor games than I have and been scum more times than I have.

 

[rich311k]

You tell me Rich, you have played far mor games than I have and been scum more times than I have.

I tend to be quiet no matter what I am. I am working on that though. Not talking does not really help anyone.

I guess it would depend on who is scum, a new player might not want to make a mistake an old veteran would find it hard to resist not posting and creating a little havoc.

 

[Jspigs]

What about her posts makes you think so?

I have not seen much to change my mind about things. I wish I had found even a small revelation in today's posting, but not so far.

I still would not shoot Ice. I am rethinking my pick of LG though. I have to digest all of this a bit.

Would a mafia member be out there throwing around ideas or just grunting that makes sense or some such not committal post.

She makes a lot of good points such as Chill changing the questions he asks without any known reason. Also Kashta noticed he said he "misunderstood the play" without him giving any indication as to what that meant. In that same post he changed his question.

 

[Dagamoth]

What about her posts makes you think so?

I have not seen much to change my mind about things. I wish I had found even a small revelation in today's posting, but not so far.

I still would not shoot Ice. I am rethinking my pick of LG though. I have to digest all of this a bit.

Would a mafia member be out there throwing around ideas or just grunting that makes sense or some such not committal post.

I think that the mafia would want to be steering the game flow as best they can. When you only really need to convince 1 person for who gets shot there is no reason for mafia scum to hold back.

 

[Lady G]

*facepalm*

I'm not quite sure why you felt the need to put someone on a SUSPECT list when you had no reason to suspect them at all.

Backpedaling when under pressure always makes me go hmmmm



Agreed, intentionally looking scummy just confuses and hurts the town. Not to mention we are up against more scum in terms of % than normal. We can't afford to just lose innocents because someone wants to be the slinger.



Can we all please agree to call Jspigs Js or something that isn't JP? You're confusing me here...



I can't speak for JB and how he views me but as I mentioned I had that post written up earlier and decided to wait before posting it to see if Js keep trying to follow.

Yes, Pap...I didn't mean to and didn't even think about it until I was re-reading things and it hit me several players call you JP. ....sorry

Well after reading what I had missed since yesterday afternoon there seemed to be alot between just a few people. Namely, Ice, Jb, JS, Rich, LG and Chill. Now out of those 6 I believe there is a minimum of 2 scum but more likely I think there are 3. However since you are my top suspect that "are you looking at the big picture" was really meant for the rest of the town and more so Wiz, I know you're looking at the big picture of staying alive. Of that list the person I suspect second most would be Rich. The numerous times of "shoot LG, it wouldn't be such a bad thing if shes innocent" is not sitting well with me at all. From my past experiences with the WeatherLadyG I don't believe she could be as successful as others if she is in fact innocent.

Thanks for adding some input. Yes, I realize it is the weekend..but at the same time we all knew the game would be starting.
Anyway, yes the Rich thing seemed very odd to me also. I realize he was being nice to me...but at the same time, well I'm sorry but the only ones I can see wanting me to have the gun would be the mafia.

After reading Kashta's posts about Chill, I have decided I agree with her about Chill.

Really...you sure?
I will say that yes, she made some very good points and I tend to lean more to agreeing with her. Chill is someone that is hard for me to grasp at times, but I will say many of his posts have made me uneasy.

 

[Lady G]

So Wiz are there people you are good at reading that you think would want you out of the way sooner rather than later.

Okay I misunderstood the play. So now it makes more sense to me the question really should be is there anyone he has a good track record of reading?

Just wanted to add to Kash's thought. It wasn't so much the fact he changed the question to me (yes, that does add some interest to it)...it was more the fact he asked it. Not sure if he really wanted Wizard to answer, or just think about it...but if he was asking Wizard to actually answer the question THAT seems a scummy move. I do not personally think the Slinger should ever answer who they are thinking about...as this would give the mafia a good idea of who to "target" or how they should react to his posts. Yes, we as a town should discuss it, but the slinger...no.

 

[Lady G]

I think that the mafia would want to be steering the game flow as best they can. When you only really need to convince 1 person for who gets shot there is no reason for mafia scum to hold back.

I think it depends one who the mafia are, there are several that would sit back and say nothing...or just add a few comments here and there, trying not to draw much attention to them. Then there are those that would be out there trying to sway others thoughts.

 

[IceH2O]

Well Wiz if you do shoot me make it closer to 8 so I know I have 48 hrs, if you do it to soon I maybe forced to only get 24 hrs because work has kept me out late some days.

 

[Jspigs]

I think it depends one who the mafia are, there are several that would sit back and say nothing...or just add a few comments here and there, trying not to draw much attention to them. Then there are those that would be out there trying to sway others thoughts.

It seems to me that you are stating what I bolded as though you know who all of the mafia are. I think this because of your use of "there are", you are stating it like it is a fact. How would you know it is a fact unless you know exactly who all of the mafia are? And how would you know exactly who all of the mafia are unless you are a member of the mafia?

 

[IceH2O]

I started to go through and pull everyones list but its a pain.

I think everyone should repost at least their top 3 suspects if not 5 for Wiz and any future slinger to be able to go back and look at.


Mine is no order

JB
Chill
Tay
Jpap
LG