Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

Nice shot, Chill!

Just a quick note before heading out to dinner... if being honest about indecision is scummy, then I'm the king of the mafia. Shoot me now. I do remember what Tay is talking about from the WW game, and I agree it could be Kash keeping a tight reign on FF.

I'll have to take some time to go through the thread in light of Kash's role, but I agree with Jpap's assertion that there's a chance she was going too hard after a couple of people. I think Kash is the type that could do that to try and help a teammate.

I won't be back until late, but I'll go back through the thread then and see what I can see.
 
I think I'm ready to revise my list in light of Kash's death and recent posts.

JB's non committal sketchy answer when I asked him what he though of Kash stands out as being something he didn't want to touch. Did you not want to add fuel to the fire over Kash in hopes that Chill would take a shot at someone else?

I'm also noting how JB has kind of cozied up to me over the game and then happened to forget about it and named me suspect. Did you ever have a solid reason to suspect me? The fact that's it's only you and Kash that brought up my "attitude" as a reason to peg me scummy makes me wonder.

I'm not sure if Kash and possibly JB have been distancing from Rich or not. The more I think about Rich the more innocent I think he may be. I think maybe Kash's post on him was to try and sway Chill in that direction and away from her to win the game. That along with her spat with me.

I may be wrong, of course, but I have the feeling that an innocent Dag would be doing more to target scum. As I mentioned before it's like Dag is riding the waves of the game and just throwing in a post here or there to stay active and appear to be helpful. Just not too helpful.

I have to go buy an avocado now for supper. We're having tacos. I'll finish my list after that. Sorry!
 
Dagamoth said:
So after reading that I assume that you believe Kashta was going for the win with the last shot even though Chill had said a couple of times that he was most likely going to shoot Kashta? I think it is much more likely that Kashta was setting her team up for the win. However I think that you are correct when you said that Kashta probably threw at least one teammate on her list, which would have to be either JS or FF.
Click to expand...


Yes I think she was going for the win, and what Tay just said about Rich makes even more sense. If Kash got Rich hit then its game over. Since Rich is more likely innocent I'd say FF should take his place since you named him and the scum went after JS harder then they did FF. I still think you're scum since Kash named you in the 1st quoted post as distancing and because there are 5 scum and everyone else is accounted as most probable innocent. If not you then Jpap but hopefully we get an invest before we need to decide on that.
 
Ok, back from the store.

I know my suspicions on Dag don't come with a strong case at all but there isn't a whole lot to work with from him.

I do think that FF has been reeled in this game and that alone is of high suspicion. I didn't think a whole lot about it until finding out that school for him hasn't started yet. Wasn't he very eager to get this game started? We should know by now that a eager FF is not a quiet FF. Has the scum been throwing his name out there as a suspect because they are weighing in the thought that the town doesn't really want to risk putting the gun in his hands? Sorry FF, but we all have our playstyles and your loveable wackiness is something we are all accustomed to.

My last scum pick is a toss up between Jspigs and Haydn. It's easy to hide as scum when a new player. Neither have been very clear with their posts and Jspigs never knew what his opinion actually was at times. By the time Haydn gets time to post there is normally a lot that's been said, and though I know it can be overwhelming, he never has a whole lot to comment.

For now I am going to trust in Ice and not that it clears Pappy, but I also have a gut feeling he is innocent. LG hasn't struck me as scummy either.

So that brings my short list to:

JB
Dag
FF
Jspigs/Haydn

If I missed anyone to comment on, please let me know.
 
rich311k said:
I hate when Ice makes sense. I do see the merits in it. So who do you shoot first Ice?
Click to expand...

If I had to shoot ASAP I'd shoot JB. But its not me and Chill has till 530 on Thursday to figure it out.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom