Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

Before you take your shot I would at least throw some of your feelings on the matter out on the table. I know for one that I would appreciate any information possible if I happened to become the next slinger. I'm sure there are others that would agree. If you are extremely confident in your shot and are willing to take that chance to keep things to yourself, then go for it. I just hope you're right.

I agree. If you happen to shoot me I would like some info for whom to hit myself.
 
and the flip side is if my shot is flawed then the rest of my thoughts may be equally flawed

True. I do not envy your position, Chill. Maybe just give the reason for your shot and don't weigh in on anyone else?
 
Go with your instinct again, with evidence as course. Goodluck!!
 
Ok, I'm out for the day, back tonight before you shoot, I hope!
 
Rich
LG
JB
FF

I know Chill said to name 4 names just off the top of your head but I'm curious as to whether you think these are the four remaining mafia or if it's just a list.

I've been playing my cards pretty close to my chest because I can guage people's recations better when they don't know what to say to agree with me. I'm not sure how I will continue to play this. If I take the shot and I miss I'm not leaviing much for the next slinger, but if I put all my thoughts out there it takes away my edge if my shot is true and I'm still the slinger tomorrow. Thoughts?

I can't say for sure which way would be better. As you said sharing your thoughts that may be flawed wouldn't help much but I think a different perspective would still be appreciated. Tough call...
 
I think they are the remaining mafia
 
Just pulled this one out. LG is referring to JS saying rich is all over scum. Two things I found interesting is:
1) immediately after LG questioned him he backpedaled and almost said he didn't suspect rich anymore. Scared much?
2) The fact that LG stood up quite sternly for rich. Why would she try protect him if she doesn't know his identity.

Just a thought and something to think about chill.
That was defending Rich? Hows that Hay?

Chill, I really can't tell you what to do. Yes, your input would be nice...but really you don't want the mafia to know what you are thinking. Maybe just before you shoot you could put your thoughts out there...but then if you are correct and keep the gun, they will know your line of thought. Really, it is up to you...you play it the way you see best.
 
As I'm trying to read the thread, I'm noticing that I just don't have the focus to defend myself from all the attacks properly. There's too much to respond to, and I need to be able to express myself clearly to make it understandable. A couple thoughts though.

Tay has mentioned a couple times that I was "cozying up to her"... look at who actually started the casual parts of the conversations... wasn't me. Also, I agreed with her once... the other time our posts were like a minute apart. If you really think that that's enough time for me to read her posts, then write my own you're giving me too much credit as a typist. As for forgetting about things... comes with the territory. I don't keep notes, and my game largely relies on the fact that I can usually keep a silly amount of stuff in my head. With RL stuff going on this time, I just don't have the capacity I usually do. Yes, I hadn't thought about that when I was posting.

As far as the Pappy-Tay connection... someone asked who really set it up, saying I said it was Tay then said it was Pappy. I think it was both. I think Pappy thought of it, but knew he would get called out on it if he put it out there, so Tay did.

I may not have mentioned my "on the fenceness" about Kash in the thread. There's lots of times that I don't mention things I'm not sure about.

I'll try to get on tomorrow again and have more details, etc... after being in the car and chasing around a 7 year old most of the day; I just don't have it right now.
My problem with the Tay thing is, she was one going hard after Kash. Yes, I know there are times team mates will go after each other to look good and try to gain the trust of the town. BUT, had Chill shot an innocent the game would of ended...why would she go after her team mate that hard if they were so close to winning?
 
AquariaCentral.com