You are correct JP, I remember now when the dead innocents chat was posted. Hay showed an uncanny grasp on who was who in the game.
Mafia 80: Ghost Hunters
- Thread starter Lady G
- Start date
You are correct JP, I remember now when the dead innocents chat was posted. Hay showed an uncanny grasp on who was who in the game.
Hit post too soon. carrying on with my last post, while the games may get confused when trying to remember other player's roles in past games, I find it unlikely that you would forget if you were evil or not in your first one.
Even I can remember my role and first two invests in my first game.
Even I can remember my role and first two invests in my first game.
I think it might help the town if we put out our updated thoughts on players.
I know it is a crap shoot with the turns in this game but from what I see posted in the game,
Razz- I am not liking his absense. I also doubt his ability to get a read on Rich which he hasn't even bothered to replay to in two days.
Might as well go with Rich next. Due to my stand on Razz, and the fact that Rich seems to be his only suspect, I am going to lean Rich as innocent.
UN, tough to call, not sure I am ready to say he was lying. Kashta coming out makes sense as to why they didn't turn him. The scum would automatically assume Dr had protected him last night.
Hay- I was concerned with the way he was posting and suspected him D1 only switched back to FF because of pride, I could not let go of the mistake I made in GS game. Leaning Hay to the scum side even though some of his posts do appear helpful.
NP (piglet)- I don't see him as scum at this point. I think he just needs direction and time to understand the inner workings of the game. Look at the effort he put in when I asked him a question directly.
Chill- I am not sure. I will leave him as neutral for now.
Bally- As I posted, I will give her the benefit of the doubt at this point and lean her just innocent of neutral.
Kashta - As it stands right now I am going to believe her RC.
JP - His posts are helpful and it looks like he is kicking bushes. Have him as innocent.
Noods - Not posting a lot. I was concerned D1 about her alignment, but the posts she has made recently do appear to be trying. I am having trouble remembering how she plays it has been awhile. I will therefore, as with Bally give her the benefit of the doubt for now.
That just leaves the Wizard, salt of the earth. The kind of guy you wish your daughter would bring home instead of the losers she is hanging out with. Should be voted Mayor of ACville. :grinyes:
I know it is a crap shoot with the turns in this game but from what I see posted in the game,
Razz- I am not liking his absense. I also doubt his ability to get a read on Rich which he hasn't even bothered to replay to in two days.
Might as well go with Rich next. Due to my stand on Razz, and the fact that Rich seems to be his only suspect, I am going to lean Rich as innocent.
UN, tough to call, not sure I am ready to say he was lying. Kashta coming out makes sense as to why they didn't turn him. The scum would automatically assume Dr had protected him last night.
Hay- I was concerned with the way he was posting and suspected him D1 only switched back to FF because of pride, I could not let go of the mistake I made in GS game. Leaning Hay to the scum side even though some of his posts do appear helpful.
NP (piglet)- I don't see him as scum at this point. I think he just needs direction and time to understand the inner workings of the game. Look at the effort he put in when I asked him a question directly.
Chill- I am not sure. I will leave him as neutral for now.
Bally- As I posted, I will give her the benefit of the doubt at this point and lean her just innocent of neutral.
Kashta - As it stands right now I am going to believe her RC.
JP - His posts are helpful and it looks like he is kicking bushes. Have him as innocent.
Noods - Not posting a lot. I was concerned D1 about her alignment, but the posts she has made recently do appear to be trying. I am having trouble remembering how she plays it has been awhile. I will therefore, as with Bally give her the benefit of the doubt for now.
That just leaves the Wizard, salt of the earth. The kind of guy you wish your daughter would bring home instead of the losers she is hanging out with. Should be voted Mayor of ACville. :grinyes:
Razz- My vote is there with reasons. Also would like to add in the thing Wiz said about him suspecting only Rich out of left field. Seems more OMGUS than anything.
Chill- Hard to say. Seems to be helpful and asking questions.
Rich- Never can get a read on him
Bally- I'm still bothered by her play
UN- 80% innocent
Wizard- Like Chill he seems to be trying to help out the town at the very least.
Kash- 80% innocent
Hay- Going back and forth between scum and unsure. Some things that I've pointed out make me question but he seems to be picking up his play
Noods- sometimes I forget she is playing. Not much digging from her.
Ninja- posting mainly nonsense and chatter. Can't say either way but at least he is posting.
Chill- Hard to say. Seems to be helpful and asking questions.
Rich- Never can get a read on him
Bally- I'm still bothered by her play
UN- 80% innocent
Wizard- Like Chill he seems to be trying to help out the town at the very least.
Kash- 80% innocent
Hay- Going back and forth between scum and unsure. Some things that I've pointed out make me question but he seems to be picking up his play
Noods- sometimes I forget she is playing. Not much digging from her.
Ninja- posting mainly nonsense and chatter. Can't say either way but at least he is posting.
Hay was definitely an innocent, wasn't that the game pir role claimed as an innocent?
Hey NPR this is NOT A CHATROOM. There is no need to post random thoughts at once, I reccomend that you write them down in microsoft word, and then base your posts off of your thoughts at that time. I
i'm still rereading, kinda skimming through.
i'm still rereading, kinda skimming through.
