Mafia 80: Ghost Hunters

[jpappy789]

Wiz, the problem with what you are saying is that the GH turn came AFTER the scum hit/turn last night.


Here the doc protects whatever was supposed to happen:

Making their way way back to their rooms, as one turns down the hall they feel a push from behind, as they fall over the banister looking up they recognize the face that has pushed them over. Screaming as they fall they see the person’s form turn into an orb flying off, then they feel arms wrap around them. Looking up as a smile spreads across the face of the one holding them....you are safe for tonight I have protected you

Then the GH vials someone:

The night is not over yet, as a ghost hunter feels they know an evil, making their way to the persons room, they slowly open the door to find them laying in their bed...hearing their door open the person turns their head “what are you doing in here”? “Do not worry, for I am a Ghost Hunter, this will only take a moment, and only hurt for a second” The Ghost Hunter pulls out a vial of Holey Water and pours it over he persons body, as they try to sit up, not quite sure what has happened they feel a change come over them, the Ghost Hunter turns and leaves the room, hoping they have made the right choice tonight.

 

[the wizard]

Wiz, the problem with what you are saying is that the GH turn came AFTER the scum hit/turn last night.


Here the doc protects whatever was supposed to happen:



Then the GH vials someone:

And the problem is? Noods could not post during night fall. After night fall she appeared to be working for the town.

 

[jpappy789]

And no, I did not suspect Noods before D2 and I'm pretty sure you can see that in my posts...I cannot suspect everyone equally and I was certainly focused on who I thought was most likely scum, and still am. I am not convinced at all that Noods is or was the murderer. As much as I would like to believe that Kash's scumspiracy is correct I cannot get over some of the jumps to conclusions that she makes. I'm not supposed to look into what LG says exactly about the protection because it would ruin the game but it can go against the scum? Heck, I have a hard time making sense of LG's posts as an innocent (no offense) let alone taking stock into what see is saying in her write ups. And I don't see the huge change in posting that you do. Sorry, but I just don't.

 

[the wizard]

The logic is there JP, why are you trying to discredit it?

 

[jpappy789]

And the problem is? Noods could not post during night fall. After night fall she appeared to be working for the town.

You said that they could only hit because the murderer was turned. The problem is that no one was turned N2 until AFTER the scum went after their target.

 

[jpappy789]

The logic is there JP, why are you trying to discredit it?

I don't count the mod's posts as logic. I've seen mods flat out give away info to the town "hidden" in their write ups and seen others work around it and confuse the town. Too much of this case is based off of what LG has said and since she apparently screwed up the rules in the first place who knows what is actually going behind the scenes and what was supposed to happen. I know I have withheld info from the the general public before revealing at the end of the game just so that it could continue.

 

[the wizard]

And no, I did not suspect Noods before D2 and I'm pretty sure you can see that in my posts...I cannot suspect everyone equally and I was certainly focused on who I thought was most likely scum, and still am. I am not convinced at all that Noods is or was the murderer. As much as I would like to believe that Kash's scumspiracy is correct I cannot get over some of the jumps to conclusions that she makes. I'm not supposed to look into what LG says exactly about the protection because it would ruin the game but it can go against the scum? Heck, I have a hard time making sense of LG's posts as an innocent (no offense) let alone taking stock into what see is saying in her write ups. And I don't see the huge change in posting that you do. Sorry, but I just don't.

Before I made that post, I spent an hour going through her posts.

One thing to note is this "sigh".

It appeared at the beginning in two of her posts.

First in response to LG writing up about LR getting vialed. Second in Response to JB's post. After she would have gotten the PM about the vial on her.

Now I am not positive because I have been pulling my hair out over this game everyday, but, wasn't she turned back to back in the last GH game?

If so I can understand the sigh in her posts when the vials were used.

 

[RazzleFish]

Oh wow, I have a lot to catch up on...

Sorry I haven't been around I had a very busy weekend and probably will not be around for nightfall.

Time to get reading........

 

[the wizard]

You said that they could only hit because the murderer was turned. The problem is that no one was turned N2 until AFTER the scum went after their target.

That is a good point but, remember, only the first 2 turns are guaranteed. After that it is 50/50 chance. Therefore, the attempt on Kashta was left to chance if it would have been a turn attempt or a hit attempt.

 

[the wizard]

The logic is in Noods posts. There is a change in them I really don't see why you cannot see it unless you choose not to.