I didn't know that but figured that by including the abbreviation of the state it would be evident of what I meant.
Mafia 80: Ghost Hunters
- Thread starter Lady G
- Start date
I didn't know that but figured that by including the abbreviation of the state it would be evident of what I meant.
OK whether the turn was prevented by protection or reversed by vial was less important then determining the turn was not aimed at Kash. The only reason to not take out Kash was if they perceived someone else to be the bigger threat.
How does one lead to the other. I tend to believe them both. I am just curious how your trend of thought went.
Kash is the DR. She can protect people they would want her gone plus if they managed to turn her they get the vial. She had all ready protected herself and couldn't do so again, Strong incentive to target her. To not do so indicates there was someone they wanted gone more. The only person I see posing a more immediate threat would be a known GH.
So IF you didn't suspect Bally enough to vote before nightfall then why are we debating why you didn't switch beforehand? Oh, because you did in fact want to vote Bally but "couldn't."
Yopu do? wow! No one is ever able to read Pappy let alone claim him as total innocnet! You must be a born natural
No, I do not think he would pick his brother. Why? Do they appear to be really close to you? Piggy is also is the one that told everyone FF was lying about the weather and got him lynched.
More twisting Pappy - I did not say his chances were higher then anyone else, just that it is possible that he could have been randomly selected. Are you saying it is impossible that he got the role?
I do not have "evidnece" he is the murderer. So I am not allowed to have a suspect and vote for him?
I beleive I answered Pap's question with my post just prior to this one...
Noods...I wanted to know why would you say that it is "highly possible" that NPR is the murderer of all roles. You stated no reason for believing that at the time other than thinking that he would choose Lab. That doesn't back up the statement since anyone could have chosen Lab. Also some stuff about people ignoring him for being new...again, doesn't exactly explain why he is your choice for murderer.
As Kash said earlier I could easily see the scum going for a known GH and hoping the town would turn on Kash. That way they do not have to waste the hit on her or the GH, depending on who they want out of the way first.
Yes I can see them going for a known GH but not anything less. Leaving Kash to the lynch was a 50% chance if their turn/kill turned up kill then Kash would not get lynched by the town. You also have to factor in the chance to get the vial and the risk Kash was protecting their victim. The only person I can see them passing on Kash for was UN.
Excuse my ignorance - I was thinking of the witch hunt games we have had since most of the references in mafia games are to other/post games....Wouldn't a witch hunt indicate a posse of people going after someone? I might need to lose some weight but I still think I count as only one person.
:silly:
It sure has been quiet over night. more so then usual. not too many votes yet either. Today should be interesting to say the least....
After much review, and the interactions on the thread last night, I studied the vote counts before starting this post.
The bickering between Bally and Hay has been going on continually. But, and this is the interesting part, Hay's final vote has never been on Bally.
Hay's votes on the final counts were, FF, UN, and Razz. Why is that?
Hay gave answers to why he never changed his vote to Bally as much as he says he wanted to. However, his reasoning seemed to change as time went on.
He stated that when he wasn't in danger of dieing he couldn't have known that the other votes wouldn't have fallen on him. That is a weak excuse to NOT vote your top suspect. As I pointed out, he had no reason to know that those who had yet to vote would vote as they did. Or that UN would switch his vote. He still had time to change his vote if he needed to to save himself. Others had suspect Bally off and on through out the game.
What the scum really need and their goal all along was to turn a GH or two. According to the rules, they would then have someone that could communicate in both boards, but would be working for the scum.
With the murderer alive, the hit is 50/50 turn/kill. With the murderer gone the hit is 50/50 kill/nothing. It isn't as big a loss to lose someone that was turned as it is to lose the murderer.
It was safe for Bally to leave her vot on Hay on D1 as FF had posted in such a way that it didn't take much for him to get pushed over the edge. Noods says NP called FF out to get him lynched, Bally used the fact that JB posted the weather map to cover her backside on voting him. However, her story changed a couple of times and the final excuse was that UN said that JB was not a GH.
When the heat came down, she disappeared for a while. Then came back on to state that she was doing more harm than good to the town. Waaaah! and BOO Hoo it worked. Her statements got many of us to look in other directions for awhile.
Then she comes back on and bickers with hay again. Bally IMO is very important to the scum team. Without her, all they can do is hopefully kill a gh instead of the chance to get them working for her.
Yes, as I see it, Bally is the murderer.
I vote to take the soul of Bally.
The bickering between Bally and Hay has been going on continually. But, and this is the interesting part, Hay's final vote has never been on Bally.
Hay's votes on the final counts were, FF, UN, and Razz. Why is that?
Hay gave answers to why he never changed his vote to Bally as much as he says he wanted to. However, his reasoning seemed to change as time went on.
He stated that when he wasn't in danger of dieing he couldn't have known that the other votes wouldn't have fallen on him. That is a weak excuse to NOT vote your top suspect. As I pointed out, he had no reason to know that those who had yet to vote would vote as they did. Or that UN would switch his vote. He still had time to change his vote if he needed to to save himself. Others had suspect Bally off and on through out the game.
What the scum really need and their goal all along was to turn a GH or two. According to the rules, they would then have someone that could communicate in both boards, but would be working for the scum.
With the murderer alive, the hit is 50/50 turn/kill. With the murderer gone the hit is 50/50 kill/nothing. It isn't as big a loss to lose someone that was turned as it is to lose the murderer.
It was safe for Bally to leave her vot on Hay on D1 as FF had posted in such a way that it didn't take much for him to get pushed over the edge. Noods says NP called FF out to get him lynched, Bally used the fact that JB posted the weather map to cover her backside on voting him. However, her story changed a couple of times and the final excuse was that UN said that JB was not a GH.
When the heat came down, she disappeared for a while. Then came back on to state that she was doing more harm than good to the town. Waaaah! and BOO Hoo it worked. Her statements got many of us to look in other directions for awhile.
Then she comes back on and bickers with hay again. Bally IMO is very important to the scum team. Without her, all they can do is hopefully kill a gh instead of the chance to get them working for her.
Yes, as I see it, Bally is the murderer.
I vote to take the soul of Bally.
