My thoughts exactly.
Bally's on the chopping block. Noods comes out with a nonsense theory about NPR being the murderer. Bally suddenly is concerned about him but still thinks he's innocent...
Huh...
Mafia 80: Ghost Hunters
- Thread starter Lady G
- Start date
My thoughts exactly.
Bally's on the chopping block. Noods comes out with a nonsense theory about NPR being the murderer. Bally suddenly is concerned about him but still thinks he's innocent...
Huh...
Ok if there was there murders "cold chill" that meant someone was changed, how do we know it wasn't her and she still has the vial and is now working for the trouble souls.
this one's pretty obvious.
But in relation to the other posts....
she says she wasn't turned and didn't use the vial. There was nothing in last nightfall that says she did use the vial so I can believe she didn't. But there was a turn, and the turn didn't mention anyone dying so someone is now evil. and the vial is still in play.
I don't see what has been good work. All we've lynched are innocents, thats not good for the town at all.
Bally, the nightfall write up explicitly states that the person targeted "[feels] normal again" ie. they were turned back to what the originally were... presumably innocent.
You've subtly been pushing doubt onto Kash since nightfall. Now, I was suspect at first but since I think the order of what happened has become clearer I am inclined to believe her for the time being.
You've subtly been pushing doubt onto Kash since nightfall. Now, I was suspect at first but since I think the order of what happened has become clearer I am inclined to believe her for the time being.
Yes, I asked...and I quote..."Bally, unless I missed it can you say who you suspect other than Hay?"
Your reply....
"I'm having a hard time with those who RC'd.
Kash - said we can't trust her after last nightfall and that she will lie. The night fall events don't say that anyone was switched and unless I missed something it was never stated that someone was. Therefor I have a hard time believing when Kash says she wasn't switched. Also, she didn't use the vial, which she said she would. The fact that she said she protected UN is also kinda hinky to me. There is no proof she protected him and he came out and RC'd which makes it easy to say he was the one she protected. She used knowledge from the thread that everyone knew. It is possible to believe his RC and it is safe to say she protected him. It's safe because most people believe at least 80% that his RC was true and he is still here.
Piggy is starting to worry me, he has been flying fairly low lately. Yes his internet cuts off at a certain time but while he is here he doesn't have much to say."
You explicitly list Kash and NPR...yet more recently you believe him to be innocent.
So either you didn't answer the question or just changed thoughts because peopled questioned the original idea that NPR was one of your suspects. Which is it?
Wonder who told him to shut up. -- Hmmm. His mum, perhaps? You should vote piglet's mom. She... "could be the murderer just as well as anyone else could be."
Oh wait. I don't remember her on the sign up list. On the other hand, she hasn't posted much either, so...... :huh:
Hay, Noods... what about Hay? -- Of course, you still could vote me. I told you that before.
Just sayin.... :lipssealedsmilie:
What appears to be inconsistency is often a misunderstanding based on distortion or perspective. Compare the progress of my thoughts to a ship sailing against the wind: In order to make headway, the ship must tack, or move in a zigzag line that eventually leads to an identifiable end. In the same way, an individual's apparently contradictory acts or decisions show consistency when a person is examined in its entirety and not in haphazard segments. It is necessary to "scorn appearances" and do what is right or necessary, regardless of others' opinions or criticisms.
I'll be back later off to a Lit test and a full day of classes.
:clap: :thm: :lol:
Are you trying to distort my perspective Bally? :rofl:
This has to be one of the best explanations EVER posted in a mafia game. Thanks for at least making it fun Bally.
You are so funny Kash!!! :rofl: You sure have gotten sassy lately!
You know Kash, you could always vote me if I am so far out there on my thoughts.....Just sayin! :raspberry:
It's funny how you all (Wiz, Pap & Kash) seem to only focus on one of the things that I stated about Piggy, not the whole picture. Convenient. IMO, when considered all together, the case is not as weak as you are trying to imply. Ya'll seem to be convinced of Piggy's innocence but yet "distancing" between others is a tell tale sign of scum, right? Riiiight! Gotcha!
Chill, sorry I left you off the list.....BTW, LOVE the Floyd clip you posted yesterday.....
The whole picture? LMAO. Sorry Noods, but unlike you we don't know what is going on behind the scenes in the scum den
I never said I am convinced of Pig being innocent although I do have him leaning innocent since I do think I hit the trifecta of evil (you, Bally, Hay) or am close to it. So maybe I am really looking at the whole picture...
Plus, your lame excuse of him being murderer because he could is telling, I believe. That is what you said when you voted. If you hadn't been questioned would you have expanded your thoughts? Maybe, but I don't think you would have. You pulled posts because Wiz and I badgered you about your reasoning and I still don't see any strong connection to Lab that indicates he is the murderer of all roles. Lab's a great player and her being chosen as a turn could point to anyone who has ever played with her before.
I never said I am convinced of Pig being innocent although I do have him leaning innocent since I do think I hit the trifecta of evil (you, Bally, Hay) or am close to it. So maybe I am really looking at the whole picture...
Plus, your lame excuse of him being murderer because he could is telling, I believe. That is what you said when you voted. If you hadn't been questioned would you have expanded your thoughts? Maybe, but I don't think you would have. You pulled posts because Wiz and I badgered you about your reasoning and I still don't see any strong connection to Lab that indicates he is the murderer of all roles. Lab's a great player and her being chosen as a turn could point to anyone who has ever played with her before.
