Mafia 84: Prison Nightmare Game-Play

[Piranha86]

Night one vote count..something else just seems to throw Rich, Ninja and UN into a "common thought" kinda thing here for me.

We have Ninja first voting Rich, pulls off about a half hour before nightfall taking him out of the tie and voting FF someone who had no threat of going at that point landing him in a "safe" spot.
Rich voting Chill for being to quiet...problem with that is Chill normally is pretty quiet on day 1 and never posts much on the weekends, he has played enough games with Chill to know this.
UN tried to come off Chill (to save himself), which can be a valid reason I know not everyone plays the same but personally I would not pull myself out of a tie and try to vote someone else unless I really felt they were evil. He tried to move to 2H (a now known innocent). Funny though how he was voting with Rich at the time and the fact Chill was taken out by the hit man.

I don't know, maybe I am just seeing to much into things but there seem to be many things that put Rich, UN and Ninja together.

First of all, IMO last night's vote was a complete crap-shoot. The way the random generator decided to kill 2H, an innocent, and that's just sucky luck. Here are my opinions on your opinions :


NPR: Can't decide who, but it does seem that there is a more experienced player coaching NPR. Which could be FF, UN, Rich, you, or Pir of course (I'm awfully sure though that Pir isn't scum though :silly

Rich: I wouldn't call Rich scum just yet and I'll explain why. I think it's pretty agreeable (no offense to anyone else) that you and Rich are the 2 most experienced players left in the game. I have trouble with the idea that he would vote for his hit-ee. I'm kind of toying with the idea that they did a simple framing. Rich voted Chill relatively early (2nd to vote), which this theoretical scum team (not including rich) picked up on. For whatever reason, that sounds a bit FF-y or UN-ish. Not saying Rich is/isn't scum, but I don't think you should grill him for his vote.

UN: UN, maybe, but he claims that he was trying to save himself. I'd buy that. A self-preservation vote isn't such a bad thing. OMGUS votes, worse, but not terrile. His was in between those, so I think his vote was not a terrible one, at least for D1. Same with Rich, not saying he's scum or not, but I don't think he should be criticized for his vote.

 

[Piranha86]

Pretty much summing up my last few posts:

After reading through the game once more, I feel that Ninja is acting a little more scummy than anyone else. I think, well know, that we need to vote carefully. It would definitely be better to vote off the guiding player in the scum team, if we can figure out who they are. But I think our best shot, for now at least, is to vote Ninja off. IMO, he is the scummiest acting, and I think we should vote off a pretty-definite scum instead of a not-so-definite scum. Assuming there is 3 mafia, if there were 2 left, we would have at least one more nightfall to weed out scum. But if we vote out an innocent tonight trying to get the bigger threat, assuming there's 3 mafia, they win.

 

[user_name]

I just have this gut feeling that tank is evil. I don't know why but I don't think anyone suspects him because he is new so him and his teammates are banking on that.I was a PR my first game and evil the next 2 and no one suspected me because I was new. I just have a feeling he is evil.

gut feeling.... right.

could just be gas?:rofl:

+1

still rereading, kinda skimming through....

 

[Lady G]

First of all, IMO last night's vote was a complete crap-shoot. The way the random generator decided to kill 2H, an innocent, and that's just sucky luck. Here are my opinions on your opinions :


NPR: Can't decide who, but it does seem that there is a more experienced player coaching NPR. Which could be FF, UN, Rich, you, or Pir of course (I'm awfully sure though that Pir isn't scum though :silly

Rich: I wouldn't call Rich scum just yet and I'll explain why. I think it's pretty agreeable (no offense to anyone else) that you and Rich are the 2 most experienced players left in the game. I have trouble with the idea that he would vote for his hit-ee. I'm kind of toying with the idea that they did a simple framing. Rich voted Chill relatively early (2nd to vote), which this theoretical scum team (not including rich) picked up on. For whatever reason, that sounds a bit FF-y or UN-ish. Not saying Rich is/isn't scum, but I don't think you should grill him for his vote.

UN: UN, maybe, but he claims that he was trying to save himself. I'd buy that. A self-preservation vote isn't such a bad thing. OMGUS votes, worse, but not terrile. His was in between those, so I think his vote was not a terrible one, at least for D1. Same with Rich, not saying he's scum or not, but I don't think he should be criticized for his vote.

Not saying I can't be wrong...just the way I am reading things at this point in the game. I really am not "grilling" anyone right now, not about votes but when you look at all things involved, it all just seem pretty questionable to me and I am not one to not point out things that just seem so odd. Sometimes someone else may comment their thoughts on it and I will realize I read it wrong, but in this case so far it all still seems pretty off to me.

I am not looking at any of them just because of the votes, it just add's in with everything else. If you go back a bit, you can see I have other reasons for all of them.

Yes, I believe Rich and I are the two left that have played the longest. I don't see why it would be so unbelievable for him to vote the "hit". It is a great place to "hide" if scum.

 

[Lady G]

Pretty much summing up my last few posts:

After reading through the game once more, I feel that Ninja is acting a little more scummy than anyone else. I think, well know, that we need to vote carefully. It would definitely be better to vote off the guiding player in the scum team, if we can figure out who they are. But I think our best shot, for now at least, is to vote Ninja off. IMO, he is the scummiest acting, and I think we should vote off a pretty-definite scum instead of a not-so-definite scum. Assuming there is 3 mafia, if there were 2 left, we would have at least one more nightfall to weed out scum. But if we vote out an innocent tonight trying to get the bigger threat, assuming there's 3 mafia, they win.

I agree, we need to "unite" and come together on the vote we really need to get an evil tonight.
I could see a run off between UN and Ninja at this point. My vote is most likely going to one of them as I feel the strongest there. Rich has made me wonder quite a bit though, and I just can't help the feeling I am getting about him.

 

[Lady G]

gut feeling.... right.


+1

still rereading, kinda skimming through....

SKIMMER!!!! :silly:

 

[user_name]

Pir, I have to say Ninja actually plays a good game for the most part between all his continuous bantering with FF. From game one he has done a good job if you took out all the non relevant, spammy posts.

He's defintely gotten better, but his play seems... different. Could just be gas like TH said, but I've got a feeling.

Night one vote count..something else just seems to throw Rich, Ninja and UN into a "common thought" kinda thing here for me.

UN tried to come off Chill (to save himself), which can be a valid reason I know not everyone plays the same but personally I would not pull myself out of a tie and try to vote someone else unless I really felt they were evil. He tried to move to 2H (a now known innocent). Funny though how he was voting with Rich at the time and the fact Chill was taken out by the hit man.

Your saying that you would let yourself be lynched, when you could save yourself? I KNOW that i'm an innocent, so why would I let a known innocent get the lynch, even if there was only a small probability of the other being scum. A small chance is better than no chance at getting scum.

I don't see a coincidence there, except for that me and Rich voted together. That could show teammates, but I would be more convinced that I was scum and would show my team-mates if people switched to save me.

 

[user_name]

SKIMMER!!!! :silly:

:Angel:

 

[Piranha86]

]Not saying I can't be wrong...[/B]just the way I am reading things at this point in the game. I really am not "grilling" anyone right now, not about votes but when you look at all things involved, it all just seem pretty questionable to me and I am not one to not point out things that just seem so odd. Sometimes someone else may comment their thoughts on it and I will realize I read it wrong, but in this case so far it all still seems pretty off to me.

I am not looking at any of them just because of the votes, it just add's in with everything else. If you go back a bit, you can see I have other reasons for all of them.

Yes, I believe Rich and I are the two left that have played the longest. I don't see why it would be so unbelievable for him to vote the "hit". It is a great place to "hide" if scum.

Probably misused that word, suggesting would be a better one.
We could keep doing reverse-reverse-reverse-etc. psychology (Rich voted his hit-ee, but the town knew that would be stupid, but maybe that's what he was trying to pull, and the town realizes that, but he wouldn't go that far etc.) I really don't think he's scummy.

 

[user_name]

NPR: Can't decide who, but it does seem that there is a more experienced player coaching NPR. Which could be FF, UN, Rich, you, or Pir of course (I'm awfully sure though that Pir isn't scum though :silly

if your going tocopy my theories, then you need to pay royalties. I accept RCS, plants, and cash.

NPR + FF are my two candidates for scum, rich I have no clue about like ussual, LG is still 50/50 IMO, I'm leaning TH innocent, and I would say that pir would seem like the third scum, although I have a feeling a vet is on the scum team.