Mafia 86: The Wolfman Game Thread

[Lady G]

You mean Lynch, Turn/Kill, Ud right? Because if the evils get to turn/kill before nightfall they can never lose.



He was hit not turned. Seems obvious to me.

Sorry to see you go Pir, I'll miss you!

Now, to go back and see who voted for Pir and why. This puts one hell of a blight on Piglet for voting without a reason, but also on Pappy, for initiating the whole thing, and LG for voting him first. (unless the sugar crash is making me stupid and i got someones name wrong)

Ahhhh, had to go back over the rules...not sure why I was thinking that if they didn't get the turn, their victim survived. I guess there was so much back and forth about the bite being on the CI and the CI dying if chosen, I just got it in my head if a non CI was bit and the turn didn't go threw they would not die????

As for my vote on Pir...well you may of thought he seemed helpful, but to me his post's just did not seem helpful and seemed deceptive. It looked more like someone who was throwing bit's out there for others to bite on and build a case. Not actually backing up his thoughts, and just saying them and seeing if anyone would comment and "agree" with him. Obviously, I was wrong.

 

[Lady G]

Wow that's a hard nightfall I guess I was right about pir. JP and ninja, I would like to hear your explanation for the vote on pir.

Yes, you were right about Pir. Although...you were wrong about 2H. I can't fault you for your vote, as there really wasn't much to go on. What is bothering me though is how you stated you thought Pir was innocent, you said you thought Pap was protecting 2H, and you voted 2H. Pir had said if Pap was WW he thought Pap would pick 2H and myself as his turn. Kinda strange to me 2H was the bite pick, am I next?

If you knew Pir was innocent, the bite on 2H would be a great way to make others look at Pap and/or me, your vote on 2H would take eyes off you a bit, because why would you vote for your own bite victim.

I could be way off on this, but right now you are not looking so good to me

 

[Lady G]

Guys, I messed up the order of nightfall tonight sorry if that messed anyone up. It will be Turn/kill, lynch, UD from now on. Sorry guys!

I agree with FF and hope you mean lynch first...they can't get their bite first, then they could possibly turn their lynch vote, making it look as though they voted off a WW

 

[Lady G]

Wow, 8 hours and no posts at all?

Well, after thinking more about things and getting some sleep...I have to say, my "theory" is a bit out there. Not saying I now feel Hay is innocent, just after that nightfall and loosing 3 my head was spinning and any time anyone says they think someone is innocent (especially on day one), it makes me stop and think "why do they think that", and when reading back through everything...it just seemed like alot of coincidences there with Hay.

Now having said that...Hay and FF both have my attention more then any, mainly for the fact they did both state they believed Pir was innocent, and unless you have info others don't I don't see how on day 1 you can get a "innocent" feel for anyone. Had Pir ended up being a CI..yeah I could give a little leeway because at least one other person would have to know he was innocent besides the WW. He wasn't though so I would like to know what about Pir made you guys think he was innocent?

Ninja...although your vote was in the same spot as mine, did you have a actual reason for thinking Pir was WW or did you just skim through and see who had the most votes and go with that?

I have to start getting ready for work, but will get back on before I leave...I will have to put my vote out before I take off in case I am not able to get back on before night fall. As of right now my vote will be going to Hay, FF or Ninja.

 

[user_name]

I agree with FF and hope you mean lynch first...they can't get their bite first, then they could possibly turn their lynch vote, making it look as though they voted off a WW

Nope, from now on it is turn/kill, lynch, UD

 

[Lady G]

Nope, from now on it is turn/kill, lynch, UD

UN...that makes no sense? It's your game by all means do what you feel is best...but I don't see how that works?

Well, I have to get my vote in b/c I need to leave, Hope to be back before nightfall!

I vote to lynch Ninja

He is my best call at this time, his change in posting right after "the turn", added with his hit and run vote!

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Wow that's a hard nightfall I guess I was right about pir. JP and ninja, I would like to hear your explanation for the vote on pir.

1.I had as much to go on pir then on anyone else. i was here till Sunday mourning and no later so i only had the info that was available to me at that time. I didnt see him as much of a helper, he would just through stuff out there for people to stir in their brains and then think that he was innocent. I wasn't buying it but apparently i was wrong sorry.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

Nope, from now on it is turn/kill, lynch, UD

I have to agree with FF and LG on this one, that doesnt make much sense.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Wow, 8 hours and no posts at all?

Well, after thinking more about things and getting some sleep...I have to say, my "theory" is a bit out there. Not saying I now feel Hay is innocent, just after that nightfall and loosing 3 my head was spinning and any time anyone says they think someone is innocent (especially on day one), it makes me stop and think "why do they think that", and when reading back through everything...it just seemed like alot of coincidences there with Hay.

Now having said that...Hay and FF both have my attention more then any, mainly for the fact they did both state they believed Pir was innocent, and unless you have info others don't I don't see how on day 1 you can get a "innocent" feel for anyone. Had Pir ended up being a CI..yeah I could give a little leeway because at least one other person would have to know he was innocent besides the WW. He wasn't though so I would like to know what about Pir made you guys think he was innocent?

Ninja...although your vote was in the same spot as mine, did you have a actual reason for thinking Pir was WW or did you just skim through and see who had the most votes and go with that?

I have to start getting ready for work, but will get back on before I leave...I will have to put my vote out before I take off in case I am not able to get back on before night fall. As of right now my vote will be going to Hay, FF or Ninja.

Well, of course i didn't KNOW he was innocent, but I had the feeling he was. I trusted my gut, and my gut was right. I think ima trust my gut on Piglet too, he seemed like he was distracted, not evil.

Nope, from now on it is turn/kill, lynch, UD

So basically, we can't win. Lovely. If we vote off the last wolf but he gets the turn first, then the wolves still keep playing, there was an issue wih this in one of my games, I gave piglet his turn before the lynch (which was him) and that allowed the game to continue. Everyone jumped on me for it, and I ended up ending the game with Piglet's death having won it for the town. IDK what game it was though... But still.

UN...that makes no sense? It's your game by all means do what you feel is best...but I don't see how that works?

Well, I have to get my vote in b/c I need to leave, Hope to be back before nightfall!

I vote to lynch Ninja

He is my best call at this time, his change in posting right after "the turn", added with his hit and run vote!

Yes, he does make himself seem evil doesn't he. A little sad, IMO.

Right now, my gut says that Haydn's evil. I need more time to think on it though, so I'l be back later.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

yes, everyone vote for AA...then what tomorrow?

How is it piggybacking when I questioned you first? Just because LG voted before me doesn't mean I am following. All that points too is that she got online before I did...

Voting for a UD is a cop out. Always has been and always will be in my mind. What can we possibly learn from that? D2 becomes D1 all over again.

Okay jpap, jsut saying but maybe you are scum there for you knew AA was innocent. Therefor when pir suggested me vote for AA because he was oing to UD you being scum didnt like this because it hurts the scum team. So, you decided to try to get everyone to not like this idea and continue there vote on pir, and since you are scum in this theory you knew he was a innocent. Therefor you could get 3 instead of 2.