Mafia 88: Insane Asylum (Game Thread)

[[AC] Tiburon321]

Really...your sure of that, I doubt it. Has the thought of maybe they were BOTH evil?

Looking at the final vote tally, if they were both evil, and no other teammates were on either of them, then that would leave 3 scum votes out there. The three other scum could have easily moved in the chaos prior to nightfall and since a tie results in no lynch, both would have been saved. Though not impossible, I would say it's highly unlikely we had 2 scum up with the most/second most votes on night 1.

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

thanks don't know how i missed that


for the rest, yes i admitted to using to strong a word. i am just pointing out how i am looking at it, don't expect anyone to follow my thought. rather everyone searchs out their own suspects.

but a short suspect list from everyone wouldn't be a bad thing.

TBH, those with single votes obviously stand out. Can't say anything has happened to change my thoughts on Ricket or Nem at this point.

 

[[AC] Driver8]

Good job getting a scum guys. I do not think it is safe to assume that all the votes on HH were townies. Since he was lynched by a good margin it would be a good place for scum to stick a vote.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

thanks don't know how i missed that


for the rest, yes i admitted to using to strong a word. i am just pointing out how i am looking at it, don't expect anyone to follow my thought. rather everyone searchs out their own suspects.

but a short suspect list from everyone wouldn't be a bad thing.

We would have to make sure that shortened list included the bad guys. It would not help the town at all to give anyone a pass. That would only help the mafia

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

Looking at the final vote tally, if they were both evil, and no other teammates were on either of them, then that would leave 3 scum votes out there. The three other scum could have easily moved in the chaos prior to nightfall and since a tie results in no lynch, both would have been saved. Though not impossible, I would say it's highly unlikely we had 2 scum up with the most/second most votes on night 1.

Who's to say no other team mates where on them? If there would of been a tie, those that tied it up would of been on the chopping block

 

[[AC] Tiburon321]

but a short suspect list from everyone wouldn't be a bad thing.

I agree, a top 4 or so most likely scum list from everyone would be good to see. I'll put mine out tomorrow, my brain is about fried (still at work after 12+ hours, though this game may have something to do with that).

 

[[AC] narwhal]

First I think it would of been a pretty stupid move to align myself with a team mate this early in the game.
Second, can you show me where I played any part in the "PM" part of it?

You said you thought it was a proclamation of innocence which is what HH was also claiming. That's how I link you two.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

thanks don't know how i missed that


for the rest, yes i admitted to using to strong a word. i am just pointing out how i am looking at it, don't expect anyone to follow my thought. rather everyone searchs out their own suspects.

but a short suspect list from everyone wouldn't be a bad thing.

We would have to make sure that shortened list included the bad guys. It would not help the town at all to give anyone a pass. That would only help the mafia

Sorry misread this, thought you said a short list for eveyone not from everyone. I thought you were trying to give some people a free pass by making a list.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Awesome getting one of them the first night. I didn't see it with HH. Too bad we lost one.

lost one what? one of your mafia buddies?

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

You said you thought it was a proclamation of innocence which is what HH was also claiming. That's how I link you two.

Yep, I saw it and still do see it as one. You said I played part in the PM part of it though, which is not true and misleading.