Mafia 88: Insane Asylum (Game Thread)

[[AC] Tiburon321]

Mael has posted a whole bunch of not much either. Mael, I know you just said you're busy with work, but a most likely scum list from you would be nice. Haven't seen you really digging either.

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

I have found through my digging too many suspects and not enough innocents. Rick has been non existent lately. Seems he disappeared right after some started agreeing that he could be suspect.

Haven't seen Mael or Gold. (sidenote if Gold's issue is still a problem we may not see him hope that is not the case.)

Gun has been absent since being looked into as well.

Rick is still my top suspect. But with the vote count the way it is, it would be too easy for the scum to maneuver it to a tie resulting in no lynch but they woulod still get their hit.

I have considered all the input from everyone and I do have to agree. D1 and D2, Gun would be around and make little comments here and there. In the midst of what got stirred up by HH, he went pretty much unnoticed. Did a good job of flying under the radar.

However. with all the digging I have done this weekend, I have to say that I did not see where Gun actually really questioned anyone. He may have asked questions but didn't really kick any bushes as far as I can tell. For that reason,

I VOTE TO LYNCH GUNSLINGER

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

I am going to shut down and let my laptop cool off so I can be here for nightfall.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

I have not had the time to really go through the thread and read anything that in depth. work and family are keeping petty tied up and stressing a little from work. I wanted to look into a few more players from what I got from the quick reads i have been able to make. Unfortunately most of what I have seen has been points made by other people due to not have time to sit down and really read. Does it help the town to put a list out there with the little info I have and all I point to is what others have said. I really have nothing new I wish I did. Do I vote on what others have brought up and trust my gut. I know it has brought me some heat but from my stand point me staying in the game is the only thing I can do to help the town. :headshake2:

I vote to lynch nobody.

 

[[AC] wing nut]

another no vote? jeez just vote your gut, this no vote crap is getting old.

should we consider a 2nd person to vote for in case gun doesn't show? he is an automatic kill due to UD and if the voters on him move to another player they can agree on be it rickets or BH we can get 2 for 1.

 

[[AC] wing nut]

don't switch yet, gun still has time to show, do it a couple of minutes before night fall, but make sure you all decide on where you are moving to

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

It's getting real close to night and 2 people haven't voted yet. UD's would not be good for us right now. Unless of course they are scum but that is usually not the case with UD's.

 

[[AC] narwhal]

Tib, that video made me laugh so hard I forgot what I was going to look for. lmao.

Before I get too involved looking through old posts, I want to get this out. I already knew what the nightfall results revealed when I read the game thread. On Day 1 the scum hit Star Crossed and on Day 2 they killed CNote. I wondered if I could find something that tells us why they chose who they did.

Star Crossed made good posts from the start. Didn't see any one thing that I thought would make them a target, but they were quite sharp and actively questioning many details the whole day. I did find one post made by CNote which may have drawn their hit.





CNote let it be known that they knew Gunslinger's real identity. That post basically says, "Haha, I know who you are and I'm not going to leave it alone." Even if this was an empty threat, that's a very dangerous thing to say to someone who might be evil.

If Gun is scum - that post gave the mafia good reason to kill CNote over anyone else at random or if their invest result was a regular townie. Gun would feel exposed, vulnerable. They might naturally wonder if CNote could read Gun well enough to tell he was scum.

If Gun is innocent - this exchange had nothing to do with CNote's hit. In that case, I wouldn't see this as strong enough for the mafia to use this as a setup to make us think Gun (if innocent) was evil.

This isn't conclusive proof of anything, of course, but I agree with the questions being raised about Gunslinger. In that regard, I felt it worth mentioning.

*groans* I hate mafia... "sleep" i tell myself "take it easy, watch tv" i tell myself "you need some rest" i tell myself. then i think "hmm... wonder how the games going?" and now i can curse myself for asking... well, i'm going to try to answer your questions and read you posts a little better. ate dinner, still feel like crap, but now i feel like better crap...



funny enough, i did...

besides that, i wasn't making cases insomuch as i was thinking out loud to see what others thought about it. and i admit, my post was, essentially, crap. i was firing on about half a piston, now i think i'm on 2, maybe. due to my brain not working, i guess i wasn't really doing to good at making connections... or making bad ones. well, anyway, i can see how stupid i made myself look in that post, please ignore the entire thing, if you can.



those "cases" were crap. i honestly don't know what i was thinking when i posted them and i doubt i ever will... lol, "what's going though BH's head? the world may never know..."



i was not intentionally twisting them out of context, sorry. my bad, i shouldn't have posted at the time, it only served to make me look like an idiot



again, the fluff was my half-a-piston brain not thinking strait. sorry. the no-vote was so i wouldn't ud, but i couldn't actually think of anything to vote someone for, again, half-a-piston. i made myself look like a scumbag, i'm sorry, feel free to vote me for it, only the town will suffer from that though.

now, as for who i think is evil... no lists for me, i go by posting only. so, i retract my vote on no one and vote to lynch gunslinger i agree with the case on him in post 898. i also find it a little unnerving that he hasn't posted yet today. what's he saving up for?

now, i need to go and force myself to stop thinking, it's giving me a headache...

I quoted Chupacabra so your reasoning for your vote would be in the same place as your vote. To be clear, you believe C note was hit because the scum team knew its/his/her identity?

If you don't mind also clearing up, what gender was C-note? I hate using the his/its/hers junk.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

don't switch yet, gun still has time to show, do it a couple of minutes before night fall, but make sure you all decide on where you are moving to

Seems a bit risky especially if we are telling scum where our votes may go. It could be an easy way for them to try and tie things up if they are up for the lynch and to avoid suspicion. I agree voting for a possible UD is a waste but a switch close to night could get ugly.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

I'm not saying not to move I'm just saying it may be better to give people time to react. If Gun shows up make sure you are around to move your vote back to Gun.