Mafia 88: Insane Asylum (Game Thread)

[[AC] narwhal]

I would hope that this forum makes it a safe and understanding place for anyone to come out

:lol:

 

[[AC] BadHaggis]

I was just commenting on your quintuple posts, no bigs, I don't actually mind it.

The safe option is allowing the Mafia more power in the votes, if I followed it correctly three people placed no votes, so you gave the Mafia more swing in which way the lynch went. That is my biggest problem with it. Every single person playing this game has probably helped lynch an innocent, it happens, it doesn't make anyone automatically scum. However, by not voting we can't say "oh, well X voted for 2 innocent and 2 mafia, Y voted for 4 innocents, therefore Y is more likely to be scum than X." Instead we have "X voted for 2 innocents and 2 mafia, and Y voted for one innocent and didn't vote three times." What does that tell us about X vs Y? Nothing.

Well, to defend myself with the no vote thing, i will again say that I though it the safest option at the time. Whether it was or not is a moot point, I know what I thought, and you have only my word on that. So, it comes down to "Do you trust me" and I doubt greatly that you do.

From what I've seen so far from BH is him leaning me (leaning might not be the strong enough word here) innocent, and then pointing out numerous times how Wing kept trying to get me lynched. (Theres a better word to be used there, I can't really think of it. Wing wasn't pushing too too hard IMO, but BH pointed it out as if he was) I don't like the contradiction between those two posts, IMO it looks like he's subtley trying to make a case against me. By calling me out after Wing's death and wings cases against me, he makes me look like scum. Then he goes and adds in a bunch of "insight" to how I've been playing, and leans me wicked innocent. (Not sure if he said that, but read the post "#997" and you'll see what I mean.

Still rereading, but what I've seen so far solidifies my vote on BH.

I have never once said I thought you were innocent, Scoop, only that I voted with you. There is a difference. I also never said I though for sure you were evil, in fact if my memory serves I had you leaning innocent, but not quite there.

That is a big, steaming load of BS. Your trying to hard to appear to be helping the town out, and it's not adding anything to the game while upping your post count and appearing helpful. Rickets should know that he has to pitch in more than yesterday, it's pretty obvious.

I really don't see any of the cases against Driver, but I guess I have to look back into it again.

I won't be here all day tommorow, as I'm going to a basketball game afterschool and won't be back until at least 8:30-9 EST. I have a ton of homework to do tonight, and I need to do some tank maintence too. I should be back on later tonight though...

Well, if you had bothered to read the earlier posts you would have seen my help, as best as I can offer it. If you don't like that help, so be it, that's your opinion. I will not stop posting what I truly beleive, regardless of whether you actually vote me or not. As for that post stating the obvious, that's the argument against Driver. He went around telling everyone else to pos, then made no helpful posts himself. I, on the other hand, made several helpful posts, and will continue to do so tomorrow, when I can post again.

Now, I have to do the dishes, then it's off to bed for me, so Good Night Everyone! Oh, and good luck in you basketball game scoop!

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

Please explain how I am assuming Nem is innocent?

I really don't follow how my vote on HH is a scummy vote?

You tied the vote, a tie benefits the scum, because no one dies. We know HH was scum, we do not know Nems role. Your tie vote, at the time, saved HH.

You want the Det to come out...




And you know the rules...

I want the Detective to come out if they have scum, not just for giggles. If the block has been used have you considered the Detective will know that because they would not have gotten their investigation back one night...

When you say Tree and Mael seal the deal, actually it was Nem who sealed it. He was the vote that got HH the "win." My vote actually gave HH a tie (from behind, as did Nem. Tree and Mael added nothing other than extra numbers. To me, that makes Mael the most suspect by pure voting pattern. HIs vote meant the least, it's the easiest "hiding" vote. Tree could have gone towards Nem instead, but causing a tie so close to nightfall is dangerous. So, I think Tree is suspect as well. I don't mind you suspecting me, but think about what your facts point to.

This reads to me like you are assuming Nem is innocent and voted HH because they thought they were scum. That isn't going to be the case, the fact is Nem voted for HH to save themselves.

 

[[AC] narwhal]

You tied the vote, a tie benefits the scum, because no one dies. We know HH was scum, we do not know Nems role. Your tie vote, at the time, saved HH.

I want the Detective to come out if they have scum, not just for giggles. If the block has been used have you considered the Detective will know that because they would not have gotten their investigation back one night...
This reads to me like you are assuming Nem is innocent and voted HH because they thought they were scum. That isn't going to be the case, the fact is Nem voted for HH to save themselves.

There was no danger that the tie I set up would last through nightfall. In fact, it only lasted 38 posts, less than 1 hour.

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

sorry I UDed but i was stuck in bed because I was puking my brains out. I don't own a laptop and my itouch was forgotten at my aunts house. again very sorry for this wish i could of gotten on. PS, I was NPR

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

There was no danger that the tie I set up would last through nightfall. In fact, it only lasted 38 posts, less than 1 hour.

There is no way you could predict how the vote would go either.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

Had a very busy day at work today but I won't bore you all with the details. I was expecting to have a lot more catching up to do but not many posts since I last posted. It seems like the people that are posting are at least trying to help the Town. I wonder if the scum think they have this thing wrapped up and are staying more quiet. We shall see. At least re-reading today's posts won't be that bad.

 

[[AC] narwhal]

There is no way you could predict how the vote would go either.

I'm a super hero, that's my super power.

Also, there was a decent amount of activity at the time, and still votes that hadn't been cast at the time.

I'm keeping my vote on BH at this time. BH is the one who switched votes to Nem when people were arguing over HH and his PM slip.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Attention!

Due to a family emergency, the person playing as Nemesis requested to leave the game. As they notified me early enough, I was able to find a replacement to fill the role.

The part of Nemesis is now being played by a different player.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Vote Count (thru post 1029)

Driver (2) - O3T 988, BH 1000
BH (2) - nar 979, scoop 1011

Nightfall in slightly less than 24 hours (Tuesday, 8 pm CST).