Mafia 88: Insane Asylum (Game Thread)

[[AC] scoop411]

Ok, so no votes on Tib yet and I post this on page 66, post number #658

Originally Posted by [AC] Tiburon321
Why bring it up at all? As I said, I've done that exact thing when scum and we all know how hive minded the town can be. It struck me as odd, and the more I thought about it, the more scummy it's rubbed me. If I were to revise my list right now, you'd go from orange to red.

Does anyone else find me pointing out Scoop's reaction post nightfall and noting that it is a tactic I've used myself when scum to be scummy?
Tib, you keep bringing up the fact that used this tactic before, and it doesn't stick right with me. You keep bringing this up, even though it's not really relevant to my gameplay. Sure I could be trying something similar, but there isn't a need to keep repeating that fact over and over again. IMO it looks like I made a good post responding to your question, and couldn't find anything wrong with it, so you went back to talking about how YOU used a hit to your advantage as scum. Not about my gameplay, just about the hit. (Yes, you did mention me being up for the lynch early, but I've already said my thoughts about that)

So, you make a case against me and then place an early vote on me. IMO it looks like you were determined to use that hit to your advantage, and try and lynch me off of it, even though I already said "I can feel a set-up coming" taking away your chance to frame me. Despite that, you still tried to get a vote on me for the lynch.

Now you can see that nobody has followed Tib onto me, and he quickly cut his losses and moved on. There weren't any "Wheres scoop?" or "Scoops been quiet" posts, even though I'm sure my post count is low. Then he posts this:

Originally Posted by [AC] Tiburon321
I really don't like this whole tie vote equals no lynch. I'd like to move to Doom seeing as my lone vote on Scoop does nothing

g/o I've been fighting a bad migraine all day, I will try to be around near nightfall to move my vote if needed but I can't guarantee it. g/o
Now that you haven't got any else to vote me, you decide to cut your losses and jump into getting another vote out there. If you really thought I was scum, then you would've kept up your argument, not moved on to a train on doom.

Then you conviently join in with the excuses for not being at nightfall. IMO it looks like "monkey see, monkey do", as you post this excuse to leave after severeal others do. It looks to me like your trying to sneak away from having to deal with posts at nightfall, and blend in to the background.

I vote to lynch tib

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

Almost of all of that was ASSUMING you were evil, I'm trying to figure out if your RC was legit or not. Your posting inclines me to think it's BS, although I could very easily be overthinking everything.

Tib will throw a vote on me next, and theres two of your remaining 3 scum ladies and gents.

You are doing it again here. You say in all caps you are ASSUMING I am scum, then you say you are overthinking things, then you say when Tibs votes for you that we are two of the last three scum. That's a definitive, not an assumption. That switching back and forth which I don't even think you realize you are doing is why I think you are scum.

gracias, and that makes me feel a lot better about you. I thought you were infering to something that was indisputable, not a possibility like you describe as your reasoning for Rickets being innocent.

you, also known as Tib

I'm more aggressive because I was trying to survive a possible hit last nightfall, that way I could get BH killed and then worry about my suspicions of you and Rickets. Thankfully you guys have done my dirty work for me, and come right out of the nightfall looking for a lynch.

When I said that right after I RCed I was ridiculed for it. Let's see how it works for you. Also, here again you are talking about me and Tib like we ARE scum, again definitive not assumption.

Way to jump on me when you were sure I couldn't respond Tib, that was pretty classy.

sorry for the double post, and sorry about any confusion that I cause by faking going to bed. Am quoting posts now.

You faked being sick and going to sleep to see who would talk about you? Wow.

 

[[AC] scoop411]

that didn't come out the way I wanted it to look, hold on while I mess around quotes and such. I'm getting pissed off with having to do this right now, I need to go to bed soon

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

I suspect you because your reasoning for voting me is BS. You acted just like this the first time I accused you, you took my posts and turned it into looking like my post was just OMGUS with no thought into it.

It's convient that you group me in with BH's vote on you D2. I posted my theory on you, and put a legitimate effort into trying to figure out your role. Then BH jumped right on, and I IMMEDIATELY questioned him for doing so.

How was I stuck on BH after Ricket's RC? If I was scum and wanted to lynch Rickets I could've said "your obviously lying about your RC" and thrown together a case against him. (I did question his RC, but believe in it enough to not justify a vote against him at that time)

So now you believed my RC enough to not lynch me? But just a few posts up you said Tibs and I are scum team mates. Which is it?

 

[[AC] Tiburon321]

I suspect you because your reasoning for voting me is BS. You acted just like this the first time I accused you, you took my posts and turned it into looking like my post was just OMGUS with no thought into it.

It's convient that you group me in with BH's vote on you D2. I posted my theory on you, and put a legitimate effort into trying to figure out your role. Then BH jumped right on, and I IMMEDIATELY questioned him for doing so.

How was I stuck on BH after Ricket's RC? If I was scum and wanted to lynch Rickets I could've said "your obviously lying about your RC" and thrown together a case against him. (I did question his RC, but believe in it enough to not justify a vote against him at that time)

A little ahead of yourself there Scoop? I haven't voted yet...

Convenient that I grouped you two together? You and Haggis both voted the same way. Yeah, you questioned him on it, probably right after (or maybe before) chewing him out in the scum den for his timing. It was a nice CYA attempt, and I did back off of my suspicions about you for a while.

You were stuck because you placed the vote on Haggis early, most likely thinking Rickets would get the lynch pretty solidly. Rickets ruined your plan with the RC and you would have exposed yourself to move off of Haggis and onto Rickets, so you were stuck riding it out. At least you could say you helped vote scum off, right?

Scoop, what is funniest about this whole situation is you have dug your own grave as far as I'm concerned. I put my thoughts out there on votes that concerned me, that I wanted to look more into. You and Nar were low on that list, since you did vote scum. Your reaction to me putting your name out there has revealed you as scum imo. While I haven't voted yet, if I had to vote now it would be for you. Most likely, unless something insanely crazy happens, like one of your teammates comes out and says "I am scum, vote for me", I'll be voting for you. Even if they do that, I'll still probably vote for you, because I'd think they had a big reason to save you.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

Unfortunately I couldn't make it on before nightfall...but it appears you didn't need any help from me. Great job finding the scum!!

Frack it, I have to go and may not make it back before nightfall. I am the Tracker...

N1: Tracked Old3toes, no movement
N2: Tracked Tiburon, no movement
N3: ROLE BLOCKED....

I would like to suggest everyone find another lynchee. If the Doctor believes me, protection would be nice.

Also, just a personal note, Tracker is kind of a useless PR in this format.

This post explains almost all of what I was going after you for. One thing I don't see is why you wanted to know Nem's role so bad. Now that you know the role what does it tell you? Unless I missed it I don't think you mentioned that. I tend to believe your claim based on taking BH out and also we haven't seen a counter claim from anyone. I'm sure if you got any more useful info from last night you would share it with us but obviously it is not a good idea to help the scum narrow down who the PR's might be.

 

[[AC] Tiburon321]

From what I can see 3toes got on me and stayed out of it. Great place to hide, many of you suspect me and he is safe from any pressure about moving his vote.

Yes, that is why O3T is in my top scum list, with you and Scoop.

 

[[AC] scoop411]

ok, I still need to get more from night 3 when I voted and grilled BH more.... Looking back me and C-Notes exchange looks scummy as all heck. Posting the first half of pics now, second half will go up tommorow when i go to school

 

[[AC] Tiburon321]

I do not see how Tib could be scum, he put the kill vote on Haggis and has been gung ho this whole game.

I see Tib's arguments on Scoop and I may go that way. What bothers me is he is the second vote on Haggis. That is a risky move when there were plenty of better targets to go on, like me for instance, that would not have raised an eyebrow and could easily have gotten me voted off. Of course it would be a great cover.

I think the candidates lurk on those who were on the others not on the top two.

Risky for Scoop to put a pretty early vote on Haggis, yes. But I highly doubt they thought they'd be stuck on Haggis voting them out. As you said as well, a great cover in the worst case scenario that Scoop did end up having to vote a teammate out.

 

[[AC] Tiburon321]

ok, I still need to get more from night 3 when I voted and grilled BH more.... Looking back me and C-Notes exchange looks scummy as all heck. Posting the first half of pics now, second half will go up tommorow when i go to school

Pics?

And do you believe Rickets or not?