Mafia 88: Insane Asylum (Game Thread)

[[AC] narwhal]

Nar, any comments on Tree? I haven't seen you mention them.

Based on night 1 vote, I've got tree as possible scum.

On other nights tree has voted under the radar imo, and I've felt like trees contribution to the town has been lackluster.

 

[[AC] narwhal]

I know this is going to sound like echoing but we all seem to be concerned with the same things.

Mael has been hit or miss with showing up.

Nar has not been a vast sea of original ideas. But I can't condemn her for that. I know we have many players that won't or don't dig and not knowing true ID Nar could be one of them. Can't really read a person like that.

Driver has been showing up but not really helping a whole lot. On a side note here when we got the new Nem, he started digging. I think he may have been on to something as he was the hit that night. He did say that he was going to be looking in to Driver before he got hit.

Rick has been the scummiest one here. But due to recent events he has dropped down considerably on the scum-o-meter.

Tib has I believe been doing his best to help the town. I don't think I found anything questionable about him, except his choice of food.

O3T I haven't seen much from him so can't really read him.

Chup hasn't posted a lot but there was good content in the posts we did see.

Tree looks to be trying. But to be honest I don't recall much about his posts. I don't know if it is his posting style or my own fuzziness.

Crap, I can't remember who is left. Did I cover everybody?

I've got one original idea, but it's out in left field and I've been mulling it over.

Chupacabra hasn't posted since Rickets claimed tracker. Chupacabras 2nd to last post said that he/it/she wouldn't be around for a while.

What if the scum team snooped chupacabra and found it/her/him to be the tracker. This puts rickets and tib (who instantly screamed his praises) in as nearly confirmed innocents.

But, the reason I haven't posted it until now is that I can't reconcile it with that action getting BH lynched, and if chupacabra comes out or is killed it puts them in the firing line.

So, for all my thinking I feel like I'm spinning my wheels.

 

[[AC] narwhal]

even if chupa came out as tracker at this point, I doubt I'd believe my scenario, it just doesn't add up.

 

[[AC] Tiburon321]

Based on night 1 vote, I've got tree as possible scum.

On other nights tree has voted under the radar imo, and I've felt like trees contribution to the town has been lackluster.

If you've got Tree as possible scum, why gloss over them two separate times when giving a run down of your thoughts on people?

 

[[AC] narwhal]

If you've got Tree as possible scum, why gloss over them two separate times when giving a run down of your thoughts on people?

I honestly thought I had included them.

at work today I had a post written up that I lost, so I think I mentally thought I included tree. Apparently I didn't.

 

[[AC] Tiburon321]

I've got one original idea, but it's out in left field and I've been mulling it over.

Chupacabra hasn't posted since Rickets claimed tracker. Chupacabras 2nd to last post said that he/it/she wouldn't be around for a while.

What if the scum team snooped chupacabra and found it/her/him to be the tracker. This puts rickets and tib (who instantly screamed his praises) in as nearly confirmed innocents.

But, the reason I haven't posted it until now is that I can't reconcile it with that action getting BH lynched, and if chupacabra comes out or is killed it puts them in the firing line.

So, for all my thinking I feel like I'm spinning my wheels.

It's definitely creative, but I don't think it's very plausible. There is no telling when someone says they'll be gone for a while if they really will be gone or how long that while will be. Look at Scoop last night, faking going to bed. Not to mention, Haggis was scum and a big part of them getting lynched was the RC.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Vote Count (thru post 1292)

scoop (6) - RICK 1209, Tib 1244, O3T 1261, Tree 1272, UhOh 1279, nar 1285
Tib (1) - scoop 1241

No vote: chup, Driver, mael

Nightfall in 21 hours (Thursday, 8 pm CST). PMs as required, please.

 

[[AC] narwhal]

It's definitely creative, but I don't think it's very plausible. There is no telling when someone says they'll be gone for a while if they really will be gone or how long that while will be. Look at Scoop last night, faking going to bed. Not to mention, Haggis was scum and a big part of them getting lynched was the RC.

That's exactly why I'm sticking with the idea that you guys are sincere. Too many holes.

 

[[AC] Tiburon321]

Ok, I'm out for the night. Later.

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

I did some checking and post number 1052 Nem went into greatdepth on Driver.

Then post number 1058 was on BH

Even if/when BH flips scum, Driver is likely going to be my next suspect...

Nem was on Driver pretty hard. I think this may be why he got hit. HH self destructed on D1. BH was going last night and Nem was going after Driver next. The New Nem had proven himself to be dangerous to the scum team.