Mafia 9: The Bloody Coup

[Lady G]

OMG!! What a night, I come home to check out rebel hit and WTF...the BG took out CS (Oh charlie I will miss your crazy avatars, and your post..btw I did not think you were rebel!) not only did we loose CS we also lost Mad:thud: So again we lost 2 CCs!!! At least the town got a rebel, crap if MM had ended up CC that would of REALLY hurt us!!! I'm not sure how good looking into who voted MM would be since the WHOLE town basicly voted for her, but I am going to see who were the "late" train jumpers also who was on Mad, & CS and look into their posts to see what they had to say, I'll be back...we HAVE to get another rebel tonight!!!

 

[Rbishop]

Well, another day dawns. Mad's lost is big time for us. I'll only have a few hours to review everything and work up new suspects before night falls on this shortened day. But tit should be enough, since their hasn't been much discussion of issues this game.

For now, I vote to lynch Ogre, the reasons have already been stated.

 

[Lady G]

Ice, for the record, I did switch my vote to mee-mee after charlie was killed.

OK, I get to travel to another school an hour away after driving a half hour to my school. So I may not make the deadline tomorrow.

It seems everyone on my list was a CC. So I am totally ignoring that list from now on. Here's my concerns and things for people to look at:

Hooked newbie - was the fight with mee-mee contrived... maybe not as it's been going on even before mee-mee got most of the votes... leaning CC.

Lady G and Cory Lover have been all over me... is there a reason or am I just a target of opportunity?

I vote to lynch Dangerdoll. This is for the sole reason that I suck at figuring people out (much too trusting and wishy washy) and she's someone I wouldn't otherwise pick.

I'll be honest, I don't have the time to spend on this. I will read the posts and if anything jumps out at me, I will mention it. I'm not out... just busy.

Thank you. We return you to your regularly scheduled beheading.

Ogre, CL and I were NOT the only ones talking about you lets see you were on many list's: MAD, DD, CHARLIE, Bkw, HN, JL, DC, RB. So there are AT LEAST 2 known CC's 3 including myself on that list we know for sure..You DID vote Jo (a CC) last minute.

In fact MAD was "ALL" over you:

According to Z's list, Ogre cast the deciding vote (post 412)...you followed on post 420. Am I missing something?

Okay, Ogre. I am posting abnormally? Please explain further. Have any of my posts seemed illogical, or not in the citizens' best interest? Or is it just post count that has your undies in a bunch? If my post count isn't cutting it, I'll add this one just for you...

Shortly after switching votes to Joander, you posted this.
Well, Citizen Joander wasn't a rebel, and you cast the vote that broke his back, so how about you do a little 'splaining now?



First of all, how about a reason for the late vote switch to Jo? You claimed to have given a reason, but this is the only one I could find. Not very specific, is it?


Then there's this post (I think a response to Z, maybe)

Okay, let's see.... Ogre says 'Hmm, several of my suspects are voting for Joander.' Later on says to Z, 'Yeah, I'm concerned that the Jo thing might be a train started by the rebels. But, I WANT TO LEARN!' Well, it's a good thing you didn't let your brain get the better of you there, before you pulled the pin on ol' Jo.


To top it all off, Day 2 opens with this quote... Not a 'Woops, sorry guys.' Just a 'RB is a rebel!' post.... Why? Because he didn't vote for Jo?


So now that brings me back to your most recent list of scum (RB?, Chas, me, JL66)
You claimed to have suspects who voted for AND lynched a citizen (Dangerdoll, DeputyChief, KOTD, Ogre, BKW, Mee-mee). How come none of these guys made your current list? Apparently you were suspicious of some of them before you voted for Jo. Now that you know he's a citizen, I would think you'd really be interested in going after some of these guys...

So you've got all this going on, and you can say that I look scummy? C'mon, at least act like you're really looking.

Just relax Ogre... I'm jumping on you (as you put it), because you jumped on me (and again and again and again). Apparently if Jo were a rebel, I'd have some explaining to do. Now that we know he's not, in your mind, I still have explaining to do. It never ends.

I know that you chose to vote for Joander so as not to cast a singleton vote. But why did you choose Jo over Mee-mee? IMO Jo didn't do anything that suspicious. Mee-mee did. You also said that several of your suspects were already voting for Jo, and mentioned that you thought it could be a rebel train. So why jump on board? What did you learn? Apparently not much, as you've kind of just moved on to other people not even involved in the Jo lynching.

I seriously would like to know what you think of Mee-mee's late post where she claims to 'now understand that the score is 10 v. 10 and that citizens have a 50/50 shot of hitting a rebel.' Is mee-mee registering at all on your rebel-meter? You've got to admit that the post seems pretty odd.

I don't know maybe it is just me but all this seems suspecious IMO?

I am looking into a few others also, you are NOT the only one on my list so my vote IS subject to change after reviewing more but at this time and unless I come across something I feel more strongly about:
I VOTE TO LYNCH OGRE

 

[Lady G]

yeah..because starting a school year and being at home with an infant really gives you free time to waste posting here..

and no im not defending him..i just hate when these types of posts pop up when it is already clear why the person can not post ALL the time, like i've said earlier..lack of posting does not always mean you are a bad guy..we should all know that by now..i DO NOT think lynching ogre simply because he has been busy is a smart move at all, i have yet to see one good case against him..someone convince me that he is a rebel and i will vote for him..but if there is nothing but the fact that he has not been posting like a madman..i'll pass

with that

i vote to lynch deputy he seems to slip under the radar quite a bit, his posts have also been pretty much non-existant..and there are a few good cases against him..

unless something else pops up with ogre, or anyone else..this vote stays

KOTD...you seem to follow many posts with "reasons" for Ogre not to be on. I agree having a baby and working make it hard, the hurrican issue was definatly a big one but.....even before this I believe you still "popped" up saying you didn't think him to be rebel. I am not voting for him for lack of posts and he wasn't on mads list for that reason either..I don't see how you can say he doesn't look rebel AT ALL to you, are you really reading the reasons ppl are voting him or just picking the "lame" ones to look at?

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

KOTD...you seem to follow many posts with "reasons" for Ogre not to be on. I agree having a baby and working make it hard, the hurrican issue was definatly a big one but.....even before this I believe you still "popped" up saying you didn't think him to be rebel. I am not voting for him for lack of posts and he wasn't on mads list for that reason either..I don't see how you can say he doesn't look rebel AT ALL to you, are you really reading the reasons ppl are voting him or just picking the "lame" ones to look at?

like i said..i dont like posts where people know why someone cant be posting all the time..and they call that person out for "not posting enough", if this was happening with anyone else i'd say the same thing..its not just because it's ogre..it gets me mad when people think you need to be posting here every second, especially when you have a fairly good reason/s not to

and no i did not "pop" up saying he wasn't a rebel "before" i mentioned something yesterday about it, that was the first time..AND..i never said he wasn't a rebel..i dont know what he is..but the only reason people seem to be voting for him is lack of posting if there is a better reason i would love to read it...if he is lynched and found to be a rebel..GREAT!, but i need something better to go on other than lack of posts before i vote for him.

the whole point is, i do not think we should be so quick to lynch someone because s/he has not been posting much, we've been doing that a lot lately especially in these last two games, i was lynched last game because i was not posting much due to my grandparents needing me, and charlie this game..he wasnt posting like crazy and he was taken out and found to be a CC.

if we are going to lynch someone we need a good reason, we need to be confident that that person may be a rebel..especially now that there are only 6 of us left..

and yes i know my name will now be tied to him if he turns out to be a rebel, but like i said..you all will know what i am sooner or later.

here's my list as of right now

deputy - stated my reasons in an above post
CL - slips under the radar, seems to only post after a lynching..
rb - unsure if him yet, but something about him isn't sitting right with me
ogre - ogre is named here because of whats going on right now, he is somewhat suspicious, but so is everyone else..there is a 50/50 chance he is a rebel, and if someone can convince me that he is, he'll move up.

 

[jpappy789]

Aaack. Mad's gone and so is Charlie. But we got mee-mee. Nice find Hn. I am glad that you see what is so suspcious about DC as well. With that being said...

I vote to lynch DeputyCheif

I believe that there has been enough said to prove that he is a rebel.

 

[jpappy789]

Wow. Hn, I really like your list, similar to mine, no particular order:

DC
Cl
Ogre
Charlie
Zsand
DD
jl

I won't even bother putting mee-mee on that list. I never really stated my suspicions of her though she made her rebelliousness pretty obvious.

Once again DC will be my target tomorrow and I will keep pushing it until his identity is revealed.

I shall revise my list based on recent game activity. Again no order.

DC- go to post 151, also mad's post 637

sploke- very few game related posts

Cl- I know they'll splaz on me for saying this but vibes and gut-feelings do not help. And stating that you do it every game does not automatically make you a CC.

Ogre- mad, again, had a great analysis (which is posted above by lady G) switch to mee-mee was odd...c_s was killed but why even vote mee-mee when it was so obvious that she would be lynched? I don't think the vote had anything with his suspicions and more with him trying to take suspicions off himself.

Z- alot of short, few sentence posts. Usually very helpful analysis

 

[ZSandmann]

Day 3: 11/14 HAVE VOTED ---- NIGHT FALL IS TUESDAY 10 PM EST
HAVE NOT VOTED: Sovran, Sploke, bkw1982
1-DangerDoll: Ogre (732)
3-DeputyChief: Hooked Newbie (733) KOTD (740) jpappy (746)
1-Sploke: ZSandmann (734)
6-Ogre: Corey Lover (735) DangerDoll (736) DeputyChief (738) johnlarson66 (739) rbishop (742) Lady G (743)

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

Aaack. Mad's gone and so is Charlie. But we got mee-mee. Nice find Hn. I am glad that you see what is so suspcious about DC as well. With that being said...

I vote to lynch DeputyCheif

I believe that there has been enough said to prove that he is a rebel.

not to nit pick, but i believe i was the first person to suspect mee-mee..unless i missed another post where someone named her

this was my first post

same here :eek3:



i'm here, just woke up..fell asleep during "pathfinder" lol

after reading all the posts so far, i'd have to say Jo is my biggest suspect with that super early vote for jpappy..has anyone ever voted that early in any of the games? there is also something about mee-mee that doesnt sit well with me i'll have to look into that.

 

[ZSandmann]

Z- alot of short, few sentence posts. Usually very helpful analysis

I've seen several people post this same statement a few times now and I have to say I disagree. I made a strong case for Mee-Mee and I was also the first vote for Mee-Mee on Day 2. Also, I've built a weak case but a case none the less against Sovran (based on Sov's actual posts not their absence) and a case on Sploke which no one even responded to. Yes, I am busy but I feel I'm putting forth a fair effort in my allotted time. Hopefully you can go back and look more closely at my posts and agree with me on this.

The Ogre train has me a bit concerned. On one hand Ogre has been going down my list with each post towards the Rebel side but I don't like all the votes that fell quickly and consequentially on him after I built a case for Sploke and no one even acknowledged it. It's either a case of a few Innocents getting railroaded by the Rebels or else it is a genuine CC train with a few Rebels mixed in to hide.