Mafia 92: Night of the living Mafia... the play

Madcrawdad said:
Zombies don't win outright...they win along with the winning team, if it's their kill that makes the difference. I can't see too many innocents hunting mafia for several days only to willingly try to help the mafia win after being accidentally lynched.

IMO zombies would have the town's best interest at heart.
Click to expand...

Ah, I see now. I didn't read the part in the parentheses.
 
Madcrawdad said:
Mafia is a game of wits. Any townie/zombie who would roll over and help the mafia win, after being lynched, can't have much faith in their own scum hunting ability... It would be a pretty hollow victory for a zombie if they helped the mafia win (willingly or accidentally). Definitely nothing to brag or high-five about.
Click to expand...

Very true. Just looking at the different possible scenarios.
 
Madcrawdad said:
Zombies don't win outright...they win along with the winning team, if it's their kill that makes the difference. I can't see too many innocents hunting mafia for several days only to willingly try to help the mafia win after being accidentally lynched.

IMO zombies would have the town's best interest at heart.
Click to expand...
This is incorrect. If the zombies win, then the zombies win, not the town or mafia. Hence, they have no allegiance except to the zombie team. Also, if the zombies win, they win as a team, not the one who casts the final hit winning alone.

IceH2O said:
This I agree with. The Vig should hold their shot as long as they are in the clear.

I took it as you wanting any early lynches to not take their hit.

JB is it a 24 hour window or a night fall window for the Zombie hit.

In either case the zombies shouldn't rush their shot so that I agree with also.
Click to expand...
The hit will be due the next nightfall.... not 24 hours. Also, the vig role was cut from the game. Not sure if I screwed that up in the rules in this thread or not. The townie PRs consist only of the doc and detective.

Hope that helps clear things up.
 
jbradt said:
This is incorrect. If the zombies win, then the zombies win, not the town or mafia. Hence, they have no allegiance except to the zombie team. Also, if the zombies win, they win as a team, not the one who casts the final hit winning alone.

The hit will be due the next nightfall.... not 24 hours. Also, the vig role was cut from the game. Not sure if I screwed that up in the rules in this thread or not. The townie PRs consist only of the doc and detective.

Hope that helps clear things up.
Click to expand...

eggonface.jpeg

eggonface.jpeg
 
jbradt said:
This is incorrect. If the zombies win, then the zombies win, not the town or mafia. Hence, they have no allegiance except to the zombie team. Also, if the zombies win, they win as a team, not the one who casts the final hit winning alone.
Click to expand...

That is what I meant about them possibly being opportunistic. But without them communicating it could be utter chaos for them to try to coordinate for the win. sounds like they just play a game of chance. :huh:
 
IceH2O said:
I agree and disagree, yes there won't be much info and without info the hit would probably be misplaced but at the same time how many times have you had a gut feeling about someone but had no way to prove it and were right. I'd hate to be lynched and not be able to take a shot especially if it turns out I was right about who I wanted to hit. I guess what I'm saying is just use your own judgement.

On that note I do think I'll watch you 3, doubt all 3 are mafia as the posting is to close but I could see Mad being mafia and thinking up the idea or Rich or Doom being mafia latching onto an innocent Mad idea.
Click to expand...

Ice, don't you think its kinda early to already be "watching" 3 other people?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom