Mafia 93: Tank of Terror! Freshwater Version

[allaboutfish]

Explain? The rules have been there the whole time...

he didn't vote for me... :duh:

the tied lynch part wasnt though

 

[user_name]

User, technically he didn't use FF's pm. I could say FF sent me the same link, did he? No, but you can't prove that either way. However, I will admit that someone in the scum den could have just told him to post that link and play it off like FF did.

true. Even if FF did send it to him I don't think he should get punished for it, it's his first game...

 

[Lab_Rat]

I think you guys may have misinterpreted what I meant. I was saying that it seemed odd how even though Razz wasn't involved JM jumped right in to "protect" Razz. I thought JM was just being overprotective of razz, or he may have had that on his mind and posted wrong.

I could possibly see this scenario.

That screams scum to me, I would expect a newbie to come into the game and say something like that. Maybe he thought that the town already knew who the scum were? No matter what he was thinking, it still seems kinda scummy.



This post makes me want to think that he was actually joking, but it would also be a good cover-up for a mistake.



In this post he completely retracts, and says it was a joke. It's definitely possible that the scum den told him to go back and change his vote, as I don't seem him apologizing (giving the it was a joke excuse) twice for the same mistake.

Definitely not enough to vote him for, but that's all I got right now. I have some drip acclimation to do on some Pumpkinseeds I caught, so I'll be on and off for a bit.

The play from AAF screams total noob who didn't bother to read a game nor the rules before playing a game. Doesn't scream scum, though stuff later in the thread is pretty odd. I find UN jumping so fast all over AAF to be rather opportunistic play and just as suspicious as some of the stuff AAF says later.

I vote to lynch JM

His posts make me think the scum den was talking about razz and he had that on his mind.

I could see that having been a slip.

maybe i should read more mafia threads.

Yes, that was suggested before this game began. Also, actually reading the game and not just opening a thread and reading a post or two would help.

i still havent decided who i want to vote for but i guess ill just go with JM since it wont matter anyway

Votes always matter.

I dunno.... the posting of AAF is giving me the creeps big time, almost like hiding in the open kind of thing. I think all this questioning and teaching between Razz and AAF is very interesting. I know some folks are a little leary about voting a noob on day 1 but AAF's posts seem to be screaming obvious.

I vote to lynch AAF

I can see where you're coming from DD, and he could be scum hiding in the open. I don't like how opportunistic UN was in jumping all over him though for very noob posts.

i pride myself in getting votes...especially when im innocent. makes the game more exciting when you might die.

JM, this causes me great concern. If innocent, you shouldn't want to be distracting the town from finding scum.

I don't like the votes on AAF, as scummy as his posts looked, I think it was just a joke, or a newbie mistake.

Wow, that's a 180 there UN.

no one gets lynched

I had the same reaction to this as Rich and Razz.

opcorn:opcorn:opcorn:

Why so entertained Razz? Do you happen to know the roles of who is in the running for a lynch?

in past mafias that's what happened so i thought it'd be the same thing here.

Just in the last game iirc. In fact it's generally a coin flip in the event of a tie.

 

[Fishfriend1]

1Vote Count

Jm: 1 - Rich(21), UN(85), AAF(93), Zaffy(137)
GSM: 0 - Ninja(53)
DD: 1 - LG(78)
UN: 4 - Labby(128), Razzle(143). Ninja(157), AAF(177)
Ninja:1 - Rich(130)
AAF: 4 - DD(158), JM(160), UN(188), GSM(195)

Feeding Time/Nightfall in 1 hour aprox.. Yet to vote: None

 

[RazzleFish]

Vote Count

Jm: 1 - Rich(21), UN(85), AAF(93), Zaffy(137)
GSM: 0 - Ninja(53)
DD: 1 - LG(78)
UN: 4 - Labby(128), Razzle(143). Ninja(157), AAF(177)
Ninja:1 - Rich(130)
AAF: 4 - DD(158), JM(160), UN(188), GSM(195)

Feeding Time/Nightfall in 1 hour aprox.. Yet to vote: None

 

[jm1212]

I could possibly see this scenario.

The play from AAF screams total noob who didn't bother to read a game nor the rules before playing a game. Doesn't scream scum, though stuff later in the thread is pretty odd. I find UN jumping so fast all over AAF to be rather opportunistic play and just as suspicious as some of the stuff AAF says later.



I could see that having been a slip.


Yes, that was suggested before this game began. Also, actually reading the game and not just opening a thread and reading a post or two would help.


Votes always matter.


I can see where you're coming from DD, and he could be scum hiding in the open. I don't like how opportunistic UN was in jumping all over him though for very noob posts.



JM, this causes me great concern. If innocent, you shouldn't want to be distracting the town from finding scum.


Wow, that's a 180 there UN.


I had the same reaction to this as Rich and Razz.

Why so entertained Razz? Do you happen to know the roles of who is in the running for a lynch?

Just in the last game iirc. In fact it's generally a coin flip in the event of a tie.

Remember what happened last game, though? What i said that got me lynched exposed both Ice and DD. sometimes, you have to make people think. in this game, that often gets you lynched BUT can also reap pretty good rewards in terms of exposing scum. the town is a collective; people get too caught up in self-preservation. we learn alot with each lynch.

 

[ghostshrimpman]

Care to share any specifics?

It's more of what I saw as a whole from him. He seems to be in disguise in my eyes.

 

[Fishfriend1]

BEGONE HELPFUL ONE!

 

[Lab_Rat]

AAF read THESE rules next time...

What are you getting at here UN? Seems like you're trying to say AAF posted his role PM or something and I see nothing of the sort anywhere. AAF did you delete or edit any post?

 

[allaboutfish]

no