Mafia 93: Tank of Terror! Freshwater Version

Just thinking out loud here but let's say GSman is scum. Therefor the other mafia members would of played before because the two noobs roles are known in this theory. If I were mafia member I would be telling GSman to stay hidden and not to draw to much attention to himself. Because no one is going to vote the other newb now that the 1st noob flip town. So maybe a vet in the scum den is telling GSman to stay quite so no one will notice him and have no reason to vote him. And any dirt on him could be excused as noob mistake plus the already lynch innocent noob I mean he has so many shells of defence he mite as well just stay hidden and rarley come out so the town will never find him or suspect him to be scum. not that he has done anything scummy yet besides liking the cowboys and not talking or helping much. This is all thinking out loud I not saying any of it is true I'm just trying to get a guess at what the scum may be scheming. Any thoughts on the possible theory, again I have no real reason to suspect scum of GSman just saying it's seems like what a vet would do if a boob was on their team in this situation.
 
Labby has a good point about DD voting out a newbie. It seems a veteran like her should've known that AAF was simply a newbie like Labby said. Then again aaf really came across as scum to me, so I see how she could have gotten confused.
 
Lab_Rat said:
Not defending Zaffy but finding myself having very similar thoughts as him. Maybe that is appearing defensive to you?
Click to expand...
Could be Lab, I dunno :)
 
Reds are the retractions, blues are known innocents.

Fishfriend1 said:
Final Vote Count

Jm: 1 - Rich(21), UN(85), AAF(93), Zaffy(137)
GSM: 0 - Ninja(53)
DD: 1 - LG(78)
UN: 4 - Labby(128), Razzle(143). Ninja(157), AAF(177)
Ninja:1 - Rich(130)
AAF: 4 - DD(158), JM(160), UN(188), GSM(195)

UDs: None (YAY!)

The tank has chosen... two people. Who will win, who will die?

Heads, UN lives. Tails, AAF lives. Simple as that.
Click to expand...
We know that an innocent was up for the tie and there were no late moves to break the tie. With all that went on prior to nightfall, there were many easy reasons that scum could have used to break the tie and make sure AAF got the lynch and keep UN safe. Therefore, at this point I think it is likely that UN is not scum. I don't see scum taking the chance on a coin flip when it would be easy to save him without drawing any attention to themselves.

Do we know how many scum there are? I don't see any mention of it and in the rules, "Texas cichlids" is plural. That leads me to believe there are likely 4 scum, even though that is greater than the usual 25% scum in a game. Just counting the numbers, that means we have to lynch scum tonight or it's game over. I didn't realize it was that bad until now. Not sure where my vote will fall yet.
 
Lab_Rat said:
Reds are the retractions, blues are known innocents.


We know that an innocent was up for the tie and there were no late moves to break the tie. With all that went on prior to nightfall, there were many easy reasons that scum could have used to break the tie and make sure AAF got the lynch and keep UN safe. Therefore, at this point I think it is likely that UN is not scum. I don't see scum taking the chance on a coin flip when it would be easy to save him without drawing any attention to themselves.

Do we know how many scum there are? I don't see any mention of it and in the rules, "Texas cichlids" is plural. That leads me to believe there are likely 4 scum, even though that is greater than the usual 25% scum in a game. Just counting the numbers, that means we have to lynch scum tonight or it's game over. I didn't realize it was that bad until now. Not sure where my vote will fall yet.
Click to expand...

I agree with you that UN doesn't seem as likely to be scum after that but that does not excuse his scummy posts. The mafia being willing to take that big of a risk on Day 1 does sound unlikely though.

We also have to take into account that the scum team still has one more hit that they now get to use on whoever they want. The rules are the same as when they were posted in the signup so there may only be 3 members of the mafia team which makes more sense to me. If there are 4 people on the mafia team, odds that the town would win were never good to begin with.
 
ghostshrimpman said:
Hey AAF, hope you don't get discouraged and play again soon.
Click to expand...

ghostshrimpman said:
Yes, this is my first mafia game.
Click to expand...

ghostshrimpman said:
Labby has a good point about DD voting out a newbie. It seems a veteran like her should've known that AAF was simply a newbie like Labby said. Then again aaf really came across as scum to me, so I see how she could have gotten confused.
Click to expand...

This strikes me as odd. It makes me feel like you've got some understanding from another source rather than just this thread. First off, I applaud the sportsmanship, however that way you address AAF seems strange for one newbie to another. I feel like the way you said it seems more like it would come from a vet. Again, you analysis of DD feels like it comes from a vets perspective.

It seems to me like you may have some coaching.
 
My gut says Lab_rat.

I vote to lynch Lab_rat

Subject to change of course.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom