Mafia 95 - "Mayor's Mansion" (The Play)

[jpappy789]

LOL, me and my scum mates...you have yet to find scum even though you continue to jam your "it doesn't add up's" down everyone's throats. You go right ahead and lynch me if you really think you have scum Pap.

I don't cop out on votes. :thumbsup:

 

[jpappy789]

Dawg, where in here does DD say that she thought MC investigated her? Everything I see has to do with the vote specifically.

the thing is, there was only 1 nightfall prior to his investigation.... or did you forget that.... or are you trying to throw up blinders.





all fine and well, UN but the problem with this is that I did not have a vote on MC. I said I found him suspicious but I voted for Chill. You're panicking. Take time to read things through before making such statements.







my thoughts on him coming out of the gate and voting me are because he did so (as he has done before in previous games) with thinking ahead. If he came right out and named a mafia, it would have been obvious that he was the detective and he would have been done for sure. At least this way that he did it, he wasn't suspected and knew he couldn't be taken out with a mafia hit.

His last vote before night call says it for me. I vote to lynch UN

no panicking at all, UN.... I just didn't think the post was worth giving all my attention to. I guess I missed the parenthesis.

what is it you are looking for besides what my thought was before, UN. I posted my thoughts on it.



I didn't mean his last vote, I meant the last thing he said before nightfall.

my knowledge of your role is based on MC's last post before the nightcall.

I believe it was because he wanted to appear obviously NOT the detective... but just wishy washy... he was being careful so as not to be suspected as detective which in the end screwed himself because he not only convinced the mafia of not being the detective, he also convinced those who voted that he was not a townie either.

 

[dirtydawg10]

OK, thank you Dawg. I understand how you can see that, you have to understand how I see it different. After all we all have our own opinions right? (I don't mean that to be snide, so please do not take it as that)

I can understand what you see because I thought the same thing for a bit. The part I have a problem with is that people are focusing on one option when there are 3 possibilities for MC's invest. I can see all 3 being viable which is why I can't put as much weight on any one of them being the absolute truth. There are also those that accuse me of being scum for focusing on only 2 options when they are focusing on only one option. I have revised my thinking after Chill's post to include the 3rd possibility and have made that very clear IMO. I will be basing my vote on more than just a 1/3 possibility...I'm looking for more evidence.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Dawg, where in here does DD say that she thought MC investigated her? Everything I see has to do with the vote specifically.

I guess it was implied. DD thinks MC voted for her because she was innocent. How could he KNOW she was innocent unless he investigated her?

 

[Chill]

Really? Chill this is a very thin attempt at best. One time, and I repeat one time I stated I didn't have my SHARP WIT not sharpness. and that was yesterday morning because I was running behind and posted before coffee.

I am liking you for scum the more you post.

What exactly to you think I was attempting.

 

[Chill]

So Pap, as you can see..I wasn't for any of the top three that were in the running. At the time of my vote for Labby Yes I said that, her and her "theory" of how he chose her didn't sit right with me and looked like a evil Labby...adding MC in there, was just a way to make it look like I didn't see that he "may" be detective. Maybe it was not the best way to go about it, but it is what I did.


Well, I know of at least TWO of em you got wrong

Funny I know she was wrong about two as well. Wish I was sure on the third cause if I'm wrong about you again I'm changing my User Title to "G's Sap"

 

[jpappy789]

I guess it was implied. DD thinks MC voted for her because she was innocent. How could he KNOW she was innocent unless he investigated her?

Everyone who posts does so with the implication they are innocent.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Everyone who posts does so with the implication they are innocent.

I agree. Let me explain it this way...

my thoughts on him coming out of the gate and voting me are because he did so (as he has done before in previous games) with thinking ahead. If he came right out and named a mafia, it would have been obvious that he was the detective and he would have been done for sure. At least this way that he did it, he wasn't suspected and knew he couldn't be taken out with a mafia hit.

DD thinks he didn't want to come right out and vote a Mafia so he placed his vote on her. This implies that she thought he knew she was innocent. Not Mafia = Innocent

 

[jpappy789]

I agree. Let me explain it this way...


DD thinks he didn't want to come right out and vote a Mafia so he placed his vote on her. This implies that she thought he knew she was innocent. Not Mafia = Innocent

Ok, I guess I see what you are saying...

 

[Chill]

Ok, I have very little time right now and I am going to use it to explain my thoughts. I may or may not have time later to go and pull posts but right now I am using what time I have to say what I see.....

I do believe MC investigated Doll, MC is old school mafia and hasn't played in quite a while...in the older games it was not unusual in any way for the detective to jump out of the box right after nightfall and vote who they found to be mafia. Then try and build a case on that person. Someone questioned me about her playing more this game (or something on those lines) that is not what I said or meant, I said when she is innocent she is more spuratic meaning she gets frazzled more easily and mixes her words up more making it easier for a "case" to be built on her. When she is mafia she seems to be more calm in her responses they are more thought out. I see that in this game.
Yes, I questioned MC..of course I did, it would of been stupid not too, I didn't know his role and yes he was making posts that drew attention to him, although with people pounding in his head that he was being illogical I'm sure he was frustrated..to the point of just giving up the fight. I didn't want anyone to pick up on the fact I thought he was detective, and hoped others saw that (obviously) they didn't (well at least the innocents didn't) and I believe the scum tried the hardest to get him lynched so they could get 2, fortunately the DR. made the right choice last night (THANK YOU DOC).
My vote to Labby..yes it stood out and I knew it would, but I was NOT going to vote MC, and even though I could see thoughts behind Wizard and Chill, I didn't feel it for either of them..I wasn't going to vote there either. Was I afraid to be the kill vote, or tie vote, some have asked, I sure didn't want to be in that spot NO of course not because I didn't think any were the scummiest. Did I not want to lynch a "team mate" some have asked...nope I sure didn't the town needs all the innocents we can keep.
Now, Pap and obviously Labby have a HUGE problem with my vote to Lab and my vote to Doll...why is that exactly? Both were very quick to jump on me for my vote to Doll after nightfall, neither could or acted like they could fathom the thought that he had investigated Doll...why is that such a hard thing to put your head around?
At this point I have Doll, Labby, Pap...possibly Zaff as my tops.
Yes, of course I can see the case for UN but I really think he made that post out of frustration. I don't think it is a case of either UN or Doll is mafia they both very well may be, but he could of only had one invest and even though it was brought up about the "something tells me" Pap is innocent, I really do not see any other reason he would of jumped right in with a vote to Doll if he hadn't investigated her...he had to of known that move would draw alot of attention to him, he's not stupid and I'm sure he thought he would be able to convince others before nightfall, or at least get others to look more at her, but instead he was attacked and attacked pretty hard and non stop by others, he had to go on the defense and that never turns out good for anyone. So IMO the ones saying he did it to himself really need to go back and see what really went on.
My vote stays and unless something more convensing comes up it will.

Such an un LG like post it isn't funny. You may not have the time later to pull posts, but you have time now. Yet there are no posts. You quote some things as "some have said" when I was the only one that said it. Not like you at all G. This post convinces me that you are in the scumden when not on the game thread. You can deny it all you want but until your role is revealed I won't believe you.

Because of that I am more convinced DD is innocent because of your push to look at her right after night fall.

Having trouble distinguishing between yourself and your teammate?

Really? Afraid to make a kill vote or tie something up?