Mafia 95 - "Mayor's Mansion" (The Play)

[Lab_Rat]

It's not the DD thing that's so holey LG, it's the part where you thought I told MC to put his random vote on me but at the same time you thought he was detective. There is absolutely no way you could have legitimately thought I told MC to put his random vote on me AND legitimately thought MC was the detective. Can't have your cake and eat it too.

As was pointed out earlier (can't remember who, maybe Pappy or JB), an innocent would not immediately think that MC was detective and investigated scum when he posted his vote about 20 minutes after night 1 ended. That is something that scum would think. They'd be trying to identify the townie PRs. You claimed you thought MC was detective when he quickly voted after night 1. If you're a townie, why didn't you try to protect the detective somehow? You were in the very spot to give him at least a 50/50 chance, yet you wasted your vote on me. All you had to do to possibly save the player you claim you thought was the detective was to vote Chill or Wiz instead of voting for me.

 

[Kashta]

Day 3 - Vote Count

1 DD - UN (1127) LG (1142) Dawg (1195)
2 UN - Zaffy (1147) DD (1167)
4 LG - Jpappy (1255) User (1282) Lab (1364) Wizard (1365)

 

[the wizard]

Let the "excuses" begin
Yes, I believe he invested Doll. I also explained SEVERAL times why I said that in my vote...you and Pap both seem to not want to accept that fact. I am saying Pap is playing scummy yes...do you think he only has one play style, seriously who are YOU trying to fool? My story hasn't changed..no floundering over here.

MC said HIMSELF he changed his mind because of Pap..are you seriously suggesting I should of taken it upon myself to "out" MC, I obviously wasn't sure until after nightfall, yes I suspect as much but to say I knew 100% nope not at all.

Excuses? This in response to my stating that everyone up for the lynch so far has been there from their own posting?

Have you found the mayor's stash of hillbilly bootleg?

Show me where FF's posting is not the reason he was up. As well as Spence, Chill, MC or myself. Show me where outside influences got us up there. I have spent so much time on the game my eyes are crossing. I have yet to see one instance where someone else got any of us up for the lynch. I saw questions asked but answers were unsatisfactory. I freely admit that I was up last night due to my own posting D1. I knew in advance I would be but felt I should take the chance anyway.

I suppose that you don't feel any responsibility for the votes on you. It is easier to blame others isn't it?

 

[Lady G]

Well I DID ask for those posts of Lab's but you keep holding out on me...

If you can't tell from her most recent posts...I don't know what to tell you. As I said in my vote, there was nothing big and there wasn't. I didn't like the way she threw her thought as to why MC voted her randomly, I didn't like her saying she thought Wizard was innocent. That's pretty much it. Now, that MC did show as Detective I am pretty positive she is scum, and her posts since have enforced that thought for me.

 

[Chill]

Chill bust open another liquor cabinet and selects a couple of very fine bottles of scotch. He tips the first to his lips as he heads for the goose down.

 

[rich311k]

Well I am home, only been awake since 3 so I am a wee bit weary. I can see the case on G, she is all over the place. Chill defending her like he is makes me wonder if she is the boss. I am willing to vote, UN or G. I will wait and see what happens.

 

[the wizard]

There you go Wizard, MC's words not mine right there. Now tell me Pap did NOT badger him into submission

I see that MC admitted that his logic was flawed I see nothing about being badgered into submission as you so eloquently put it. Your choice of words is impressive I must say. "badgered into submission" makes one sound more evil than "convinced me I was wrong"

 

[Lab_Rat]

It's more a read then anything specific. Although I did point out somethings as we went. I don't like how he went from attacking FF to being so sure of FF's innocence he was willing to offer himself up for the lynch. Beyond that in the previous games I've played with Wiz I could feel his frustration and while he voiced frustration this game I didn't feel it. His day one play was over the top and I can't buy it.

See, I got the opposite read on Wiz. I think he was even more aggressive than usual day 1, most likely because this is Kash's game. I had the same uneasy feeling going into night 1, but I wasn't willing to move of the player I thought was scummiest. His frustration late in day 1 I feel was true frustration, not an act. Again, I attribute this to the fact that this is Kash's game so he's likely to be more hyped no matter what his role. Tell me, now that we know for a fact that the two up for the lynch on day 1 were both innocent, why in the world would Wiz try to pull votes off them if he was scum? Wouldn't it be much easier and safer to stay quiet and let it ride, knowing no scum is in danger?

 

[jbradt]

If you can't tell from her most recent posts...I don't know what to tell you. As I said in my vote, there was nothing big and there wasn't. I didn't like the way she threw her thought as to why MC voted her randomly, I didn't like her saying she thought Wizard was innocent. That's pretty much it. Now, that MC did show as Detective I am pretty positive she is scum, and her posts since have enforced that thought for me.

Which posts in particular, G?

 

[Lady G]

Excuses? This in response to my stating that everyone up for the lynch so far has been there from their own posting?

Have you found the mayor's stash of hillbilly bootleg?

Show me where FF's posting is not the reason he was up. As well as Spence, Chill, MC or myself. Show me where outside influences got us up there. I have spent so much time on the game my eyes are crossing. I have yet to see one instance where someone else got any of us up for the lynch. I saw questions asked but answers were unsatisfactory. I freely admit that I was up last night due to my own posting D1. I knew in advance I would be but felt I should take the chance anyway.

I suppose that you don't feel any responsibility for the votes on you. It is easier to blame others isn't it?

Not saying that at all, but it has turned into a pretty "easy" excuse for scum when the innocents are lynched,. I don't think MC would of been lynched had Pap not hounded him like he did. I also am not so sure I would be in this position if he hadn't tried to make it look like I didn't answer him when I did. He accomplished exactly what he wanted with his non stop, nonacceptance of anyones answer that has been innocent so far.