First impression: Wiz and Pappy seem to be sharing a wavelength. Next impression: But both make perfectly valid points.
You also have thrown out there the names of UN, Spencer, NPR, Rich, Bally(Noods)...and then Pir. That is my point. A couple of those you've already made "cases" for.
Do you really need me to go back and pull that?
"Well... the only scummy person I can think of is Spencer.... and Ninja of course, for being my brother and for not posting enough."
You said something along the lines of having something against Bally(Noods) because she(she) voted for you. That is a purely OMGUS statement and you've already admitted to screwing up your own schedule. I don't understand how you can then hold that against someone.
Lastly, maybe you should be double checking bits of info so important as names before going out on a limb like that...
So I'm evil for throwing names around in my head? Are you saying I shouldn't be looking at all possible angles?
Okay, so I did post that bit about NPR. Well, it was a small bit, I'm not surprised I forgot it. Well, I do think on all things. At this point it is definitly because of his dads house, and he almost certainly will UD. Thursday he should have had acess, IDK why he didn't. Friday, same thing. So both my statements are true, he may not have internet and he isn't posting enough.
I never said I would hold it against them, I just noted it. There is nothing wrong with noting votes on me, as I am an easy target for, well, anyone. She didn't really post a good reason at the time, I don't think, so that is most likely why I commented on it.
I never said I don't know your names, and I always check player lists before starting a game. What I said was that I get people mixed up. Similar names and playing styles always get me confused, I'm not good at names. Takes me several weeks to learn someone's name without risk of forgetting, and even then I can occasionally come up blank.
Again going back to your vote post.
I always thought that the object was to vote the one you thought most likely scum. Have I been playing incorrectly all along?
You have since noted that by the end of this post you thought Pir to be scummier. Please explain on what basis. From what I read in your post I don't see anything to base a vote on.
While it is true, that Pir said he didn't see anything to comment on, that could be due to not being able to see the questionable posting in banter. It also could be due to not actually reading the posts and just skimming the thread.
I don't know, but I don't believe it is a vote worthy offense at this point. I have seen you state bigger offenses as not being vote worthy.
As it stands right now it looks like you are the runaway favorite for the lynch. If you are innocent, you have just under 8 hours to correct your game and show why we shouldn't be lynching you.
While it is true that we have more players this go round, if Kashta based the number of scum on percentage of players then we still cannot really afford to lynch an innocent on D1.
The clock is ticking FF.
I think that Pir is most likely scum. Thusly, I am voting Pir. Opinions on people can change, as I have said before. When looking into Pir, I saw his posting as more scummy then Spencers, so I voted him. Now, while I did say (in the beginning of my post) that Spencer seemed to be the only scummy one, my thoughts and opinions changed over the course of that post. Now, can you explain to me what is so difficult about understanding what I just said?
I think Pir is scummy because he hasn't added anything to the game whatsoever, because he is hiding out of view with his small number of posts, because he isn't revealing any of his intentions at all, because he slipped that bit about me into his post while STILL saying nothing (which is a great scum tactic). Those are my reasons for voting Pir.
So messing up my scedual is bigger then skimming the thread? Messing up my scedual is now bigger and more important then not adding to the game? Messing up my scedual is bigger then hiding? Messing up my scedual is bigger then slipping in suspisions of me and then saying I could be good or evil (which is the same as saying nothing)? You, Wizard, need to take your own advice before giving it to others.
If my memory serves, I have come out clean. I admit I screwed up my scedual. I openly admit I mixed Noods and ballyhoo up. I have explained why I voted Pir in multiple posts. I have explained my reasoning and done the best I can to defend myself. If that isn't enough for you to beleive me, then I will be lynched and that is that. I cannot defend myself unless you are willing to listen, which you obviously aren't.
)
