Mafia 96 Who Are You? Game Thread

I think by now everyone should have some type of list. With all that has happened over night have any been revised and lets show them.

I don't even care for reasons at this point, just who you think is scum.

Mine is

LG
JB
Dun
Chill
DD

More then likely the order I'd vote them also but willing to vote any of them.
 
Dangerdoll said:
this group of posts has me wondering what you guys are talking about. I lost cable last night for a while so wasn't really able to keep an eye on the game until late. By that time, I was pretty tired eyed to watch. When I started reading today though, I saw these posts and they have me thinking... what are you guys talking about. How do you guys come to the conclusion that the scum(s) want(s) him dead? I am not seeing it.


you say here that Dag went pretty hard after Ice. I see G going hard after Ice, however both of those thoughts in mind and Dag being killed and innocent, what do you think about G?

is this conclusion as big as the one below?
Click to expand...
The cases built on Ice seemed very weak. Then a bunch jumped on. Those jumpers on I'm pretty sure are scum.

Dag was being narrow-minded and inflexible. He can be that way irl. I would have thought him scum, save for the fact he jumped to UN so quick after UN's uber scummy move. I said that earlier in the thread, guess you skimmed over it. I think LG is scum. I think LG could possibly be the don. Maybe she is not, if she's not I'd put Chill as the don.

I'm pretty sure JB is scum. He's playing like scum. He slipped up and I caught it. Funny how I posted that 4 min after his post, yet he's not responded. I'm sure he'll say he hasn't had a chance to be on whenever he does show up.
 
I have to go with who I trust the most.

I retract my vote on LG and vote to lynch JB
 
I am trying to think of who would be most likely to be investigated and brought on to the scummy team.

There is a lot of back and forth between Ice and G. I am back and forth between them but I think one or the other is scum but I can't put my finger on one of the two. I don't think they both are but if they are, they are doing a bang up job of distancing themselves from each other. Going over it in my head, if I was scum, Ice would be the first one I would investigate. From what I understand of the rule, if Ice was investigated first and found scummy, he would be taken on the team. That would be a bonus. On the other hand, if he was found innocent, I would want him gone due to his clever play and attention to details on catching slips. He is a hard innocent to fight.

The next person I would investigate would be JB. I am not too familiar with JB's game play though I have played with him before. He is another I would have investigated though.

The next would be Labby. She's pretty vocal in the game and I surely would want to know what her role is. Her calling out JB and making such a statement that he is scum boggles me. It's a strong statement but I would think she would be on the investigate list too.

All this said, I know there haven't been that many investigations going on yet. I am going with my first hunch though. In my order, the first ones to be investgated are Ice, JB, Labby.

I vote to lynch Ice
 
Dangerdoll said:
I am trying to think of who would be most likely to be investigated and brought on to the scummy team.

There is a lot of back and forth between Ice and G. I am back and forth between them but I think one or the other is scum but I can't put my finger on one of the two. I don't think they both are but if they are, they are doing a bang up job of distancing themselves from each other. Going over it in my head, if I was scum, Ice would be the first one I would investigate. From what I understand of the rule, if Ice was investigated first and found scummy, he would be taken on the team. That would be a bonus. On the other hand, if he was found innocent, I would want him gone due to his clever play and attention to details on catching slips. He is a hard innocent to fight.

The next person I would investigate would be JB. I am not too familiar with JB's game play though I have played with him before. He is another I would have investigated though.

The next would be Labby. She's pretty vocal in the game and I surely would want to know what her role is. Her calling out JB and making such a statement that he is scum boggles me. It's a strong statement but I would think she would be on the investigate list too.

All this said, I know there haven't been that many investigations going on yet. I am going with my first hunch though. In my order, the first ones to be investgated are Ice, JB, Labby.

I vote to lynch Ice
Click to expand...

I agree that Ice would be my first invest as well. I cant believe he is still alive to be honest with you, but I do not see how that leads to him being scum.
 
VOTE COUNT

0) LG – Ice(1102),
1) LR – Dun(1125),
2) Ice – LG(1127), DD(1164),
2) JB – LR(1147), Ice(1163),

[FONT=&quot]NO VOTES – JP, ZAFFY, RICH, JB, CHILL

Night fall in 24 1/2 hours PM's as required.
[/FONT]
 
rich311k said:
I agree that Ice would be my first invest as well. I cant believe he is still alive to be honest with you, but I do not see how that leads to him being scum.
Click to expand...
Now, I am trying to think of who would be chosen for the scum side. I think it's easier to use that kind of thinking than to make sense of everyone when we really don't know who is blowing smoke. A lot of what everyone says makes sense but only if you see it from their point of view.
 
to add to that, when I read someone who's posted something, I think... that makes sense and then I see a rebuttal and think that makes sense too. Who can you really believe though so instead of trying to make sense of that, I thought.... well, if I was scum, who would be my first choice... and that would be Ice. As the game progresses, my list expanded.
 
Dangerdoll said:
to add to that, when I read someone who's posted something, I think... that makes sense and then I see a rebuttal and think that makes sense too. Who can you really believe though so instead of trying to make sense of that, I thought.... well, if I was scum, who would be my first choice... and that would be Ice. As the game progresses, my list expanded.
Click to expand...


So it wouldn't make sense that the innocent team would investigate me 1st?
 
IceH2O said:
So it wouldn't make sense that the innocent team would investigate me 1st?
Click to expand...
no... cause they're looking for teammates. :rofl:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom