Mafia #98: The Grinch Returns -- The Play

[Zaffy]

opcorn:

 

[IceH2O]

Glad the scum killed their own. I'm going to have to go back and see if she said something to make them think she was worth killing.

Sorry 2H but I didn't have anything better at the time until UN posted about roles and it wouldn't have made a difference to vote him.

Why did you vote dd?

Not sure why it matters, she voted a NC evil elf. Better then most of us did.Can you explain you clarify your reasoning for the question?

I don't really buy the communicating scum role you said you meant. I think because you're scum you forgot the innocent elves all have minor roles

I vote to lynch UN

 

[IceH2O]

There is absolutely nothing in DDs post that would tip scum off that she was anything important.

 

[jpappy789]

I said why. It was weak, (at the time) but the only thing that had stood out to me (that I had seen), I will not be able to catch up much tonight either have quite a bit more I have to get done, but I want to see why everyone who voted 2H voted him.

I already explained my reason when I voted.

Why so? She mentioned two different snowball games, I voted her because of it...it was random and the best "reason" I had to go with at the time.

It's almost like you are trying to justify your vote despite saying it was just a weak one (which it was).

The fact that you grabbed THAT out of everything seemed weird to me. Why not just say it was random?

 

[jpappy789]

"a dangerous snowball" i assume that means only one. or am i missing something? that and the "evil lurking" definitely suggests a great present to the townies from the evil elves. i'll take what we can get, though.

From running this setup in the past it should be only one shot for Frosty.

 

[dundadundun]

From running this setup in the past it should be only one shot for Frosty.

thanks for clarifying, pap. that's what i thought, but don't want to assume.

 

[Lady G]

I already explained my reason when I voted.



It's almost like you are trying to justify your vote despite saying it was just a weak one (which it was).

The fact that you grabbed THAT out of everything seemed weird to me. Why not just say it was random?

I don't really see why you are having such a hard time with my vote Pap...at least she DID end up being evil. Do you want me to go through my whole thought process with you as to why my vote was her and not Rich? It may be a bit confusing and make no since to you, but I can if you want. Yes, it was random...in the since I really had nothing it was just a goofy thought in my mind, and I'm glad actually I went with it. If your not...I'm sorry

 

[jpappy789]

No surprise, but there's nothing more go on after rereading the posts. The roles being random doesn't help either. Scum could be anywhere.

From the singletons, I would question Rich and 2H for offering up good players at random this early on. That could hurt us if they're not evil. Between the current tying votes on UN, Dun, and 2H... nothing strikes me as particularly sinister in the votes.

Less than 2 hrs... I could add FF, Pappy, Rich, DD, or LG to the tie. FF is too easy and not around to post. And Pappy, Rich, DD, and LG are too valuable to lose for no reason, if it's a mistake.

Or vote UN, Dun, or 2H to break the tie with lots of time to gauge responses. Or add someone new to the running.

For now, I vote to lynch UN as a random pick to break the tie. And to see what happens, if anything, as a result.

Kash, I do have to question why you picked UN over the others at the time. Random or not...

Now obviously picking 2H would have been a mistake. That being said you did not comment on his very questionable vote for Rich...other than the fact that it was for a "good player"

Same goes for Dun's comments on FF when he voted UN, which have stirred up a bit of discussion.

You brush off those votes as "nothing sinister"...why is that? Do you still believe that way?

 

[jpappy789]

I don't really see why you are having such a hard time with my vote Pap...at least she DID end up being evil. Do you want me to go through my whole thought process with you as to why my vote was her and not Rich? It may be a bit confusing and make no since to you, but I can if you want. Yes, it was random...in the since I really had nothing it was just a goofy thought in my mind, and I'm glad actually I went with it. If your not...I'm sorry

I never questioned why you picked DD over Rich. Just seems odd to me that you didn't just say it was random and leave it at that...

Voting DD has no effect on what I will think about your role as she was the only one who knew she was scum.

 

[Lady G]

I never questioned why you picked DD over Rich. Just seems odd to me that you didn't just say it was random and leave it at that...

Voting DD has no effect on what I will think about your role as she was the only one who knew she was scum.

Seriously, Pap...why is it bugging you so much that I added a reason with my vote?