Mafia #98: The Grinch Returns -- The Play

I think you're forgetting about the fact that scum can communicate OUTSIDE the thread. What's the point of doing it within the game thread?
i'm not forgetting anything. once again... it's easy to play it off if nobody would suspect it. also much easier for 2 people to grill a "suspect" and make a case to the townies under these conditions. as far as i'm concerned you're doing a great job. keep up the good work!

but how about answering my question?
 
i'm leaning bally innocent due to pap continuous persistence.

FF- scum
pap- scum
LG- tough to tell if she's scum playing a role with pap to oust someone (me at this point, but irrelevant IMO)
others... tougher to read... i'd need a list to place an order... which would be mucho guessing anyway

AAF... pretty absent... maybe a PR?
 
i'm not forgetting anything. once again... it's easy to play it off if nobody would suspect it. also much easier for 2 people to grill a "suspect" and make a case to the townies under these conditions. as far as i'm concerned you're doing a great job. keep up the good work!

but how about answering my question?

Which question?

I don't understand how you could think scum would try to talk to each other in this thread. Regardless of getting away with it or not there's a perfectly secret thread for them to communicate in outside of here...
 
Which question?

I don't understand how you could think scum would try to talk to each other in this thread. Regardless of getting away with it or not there's a perfectly secret thread for them to communicate in outside of here...
i can read the rules, pap. thanks anyway.
 
I am more then a little nervous about the pile on with Dun. I believe he has 6 votes with the runner up (Bally) having 3. It's just something I'm a little apprehensive about. As for Bally not figuring out from the get go who thought what about the hit last night... well, it seems as bad as my theory on dun. And thus, perfectly viable, considering we've got nothing to go off of.
As for the "pile on" Dun, yeah it makes me nervous also when several just jump on someone..but his posts have pretty much sealed it for me now his "your going to be sorry" posts, just makes me even more confident IME most the time when someone starts posting stuff like that...they are scum. As for Bally, I agree that isn't a big reason to go after her...and can see where she may easily of just been mistaken and when drilled over and over on the same question anyone is likely to waiver or mix up their wording. I'm not in any way saying I think she is innocent, just think I'll wait for other things to come up before deciding on her,.
 
AAF... you should probably go in "secret mode" so folks can't see you watching for hours on end before you post why you couldn't post again. ;)
 
And I'm questioning those observations.

Your first post regarding all of this (#178) singles out Rich for knowing it was a scum hit. You also say that everyone else was confused.

Now you've gone to stating that you were confused and just assumed everyone else didn't know the order of the events, etc. etc.

I saw Rich's post first, then shortly after that there was the whole assumption business.
assume = the lack of knowledge one way or another = confusion IMO


maybe if i type it backwards it will make more sense.....
I was s'hciR tosp tsrit, neht yltorhs retfa taht ereht saw eht elow noitpmussa....
 
As for the "pile on" Dun, yeah it makes me nervous also when several just jump on someone..but his posts have pretty much sealed it for me now his "your going to be sorry" posts, just makes me even more confident IME most the time when someone starts posting stuff like that...they are scum. As for Bally, I agree that isn't a big reason to go after her...and can see where she may easily of just been mistaken and when drilled over and over on the same question anyone is likely to waiver or mix up their wording. I'm not in any way saying I think she is innocent, just think I'll wait for other things to come up before deciding on her,.
hopefully you'll get to know my game play better as time goes on.
 
Current vote count:
UN (0)- Ice (#162)
Dun (6)- FF (#176), Ice (#238), UN (#280), LG (#300), Dawg (#304), Pappy (#321)
FF (0) - Dun (#223)
Bally (3) - Wiz (#232), Rich (#240), AAF (#243)
Pap (1) - Dun (#285)

No vote: Kash, Bally

PMs as needed. Nightfall in 1 hour and 16 minutes.
 
AquariaCentral.com