Mafia #99: The ACville Files- Game Thread

[noodles62]

I think that scum would vote for anyone who wasn't scum. So yes, scum would vote for him. Scum would also vote for FF, or place a random vote on someone non-scum. I'm not sure what you're getting at with this question Dawg.

You seem to be saying that Scum would vote for non-scum. Why wouldn't they throw a random vote on one of their own? You've played here before right?

Did I say that they wouldn't throw a random vote on one of their own? Please show me where I said that.

It's not that you said it, but rather that what you said seemed to specifically exclude it. Did you slip up?

I find this exchange interesting. Labby, I know you tried to explain this but you said it pretty plainly - that scum would vote for non scum. That is ludicrous and so not true. Makes me think you are covering for someone/something. You have done alot of asking others for a list and calling people out for low posting, but there is not really much meat to your posts either.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I find this exchange interesting. Labby, I know you tried to explain this but you said it pretty plainly - that scum would vote for non scum. That is ludicrous and so not true. Makes me think you are covering for someone/something. You have done alot of asking others for a list and calling people out for low posting, but there is not really much meat to your posts either.

Did you not see my color coded list where I ranked everyone on scummyness by color?

 

[Lab_Rat]

And you're saying scum would not vote for non-scum? I find that to be ludicrous.

 

[noodles62]

And you're saying scum would not vote for non-scum? I find that to be ludicrous.

sorry - I did miss your list. I am not saying that scum would not vote for not scum, but you know that scum always votes for one of their own to throw off the scent. Kind of like you day one vote on Zaffy.

 

[Lab_Rat]

sorry - I did miss your list. I am not saying that scum would not vote for not scum, but you know that scum always votes for one of their own to throw off the scent. Kind of like you day one vote on Zaffy.

I see what you're trying to do there, but you're way off. Scum don't always do anything.

Now that you've seen my list and my thoughts on everyone, do you have any comments on it or anything you'd like to ask me about it?

 

[noodles62]

I'm going to go ahead and post my list so far:

Most scummy
Noods - Noods, where are you? Hasn't helped the town at all, laying low?
Dawg - don't like how hard he went at Kash, then suddenly backed down and wanted to be BFFs, I don't buy his explanation
DD - play feels scummy to me, posts haven't been pro-town from what I've seen
Dun - scummy reason for voting LG, gameplay has been erratic
AAF - not helping the town, not sure if he's even trying to
Zaffy - not getting a scummy read, seems to be working for the town
Kash - agree with a lot of what she has said, working hard
Wiz - seems to be pro-town and working hard
JB - haven't gotten a scum read from him yet, would like to see more, so far seems pro-town
Ice - headline implies he is innocent
Least scummy

I find it funny that I am at the top of your list because I was busy for a couple days. I have never layed low when scum, why would I start now?

 

[Lab_Rat]

I find it funny that I am at the top of your list because I was busy for a couple days. I have never layed low when scum, why would I start now?

Sure you have, I've seen you make non-committal posts and not do any real digging as scum. I've not seen much digging from you so far this game. It does make me feel a little better that you've shown up and started participating.

 

[noodles62]

Sure you have, I've seen you make non-committal posts and not do any real digging as scum. I've not seen much digging from you so far this game. It does make me feel a little better that you've shown up and started participating.

I still say that your posts have not really been of substance either this game. You usually kick the bushes pretty hard, but seem to be holding back this time around. Unfortunately I have never really been good kicking bushes but I do try to call out what I think is scummy.

 

[noodles62]

I am interested to know why you are leaning Wiz, JB and myself innocent.

not sure if I answered this or not - I am actually reconsidering my thoughts on you. JB seems to be working protown and Wiz does/did as well. I am not convinced, just what I think ATM.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I still say that your posts have not really been of substance either this game. You usually kick the bushes pretty hard, but seem to be holding back this time around. Unfortunately I have never really been good kicking bushes but I do try to call out what I think is scummy.

Earlier in the game I was super busy with work. This weekend I've been kicking bushes since I've had more time. I've put my thoughts out there, not holding anything back.

Who are your top 4 scum suspects Noods?