Mafia #99: The ACville Files- Game Thread

[dirtydawg10]

So since it didn't go as planned, do you still think Kash is scum?

No, I voted for her because I think she is innocent

If it works with everyone I will freeze votes and other actions at 10pm Eastern tonight and ask that people do not reveal anything before I can run the nightfall events. I should hopefully be back within a couple hours and that way I'm not cutting into time that people would normally post. I shouldn't need to have the thread locked or anything like that but please remember that nothing you say will change the outcomes if it is after 10.

Again, I apologize for this and it hopefully will be just this one occurrence.

That is fine with me I wasn't going to make the 8PM nightfall anyway. I may be able to make the 10PM.

I'm still not sure where to place my vote. The Dawg/Kash thing really bothers me, but I can kind of see what Dawg was getting at. I can see how Kash may have been waiting to see others reactions before putting her vote on him.

So you did read my post. This answers your first question to me in this post.

 

[noodles62]

i agree i think whatever one is the other is the opposite.

Ewww!

And I agree that I doubt they're two innocents going at each other. I just can't decide which is scum. I know Kash was way lower on my list before than Dawg, but I've got this gut feeling that she played that interaction. I can see Dawg being aggressive like that as an innocent, thinking he was on to something, then digging his own hole. I've btdt before. That is why I'm so torn.

These are my thoughts too. That is why I do not want to vote for either one tonight. It would just be a guess at which one is scum and I am not very good at guessing correctly.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I'm out...hopefully I'll be on before nightfall.

 

[Lab_Rat]

No, I voted for her because I think she is innocent


That is fine with me I wasn't going to make the 8PM nightfall anyway. I may be able to make the 10PM.


So you did read my post. This answers your first question to me in this post.

Yes, I did read your post. I read all the posts in these games. And I can see where you're coming from and what you did, but I can also see how it could have been a scum move. I also find it odd that after Kash got some support against you, she voted for you then kinda disappeared. That also really bugs me.

 

[Kashta]

Just got home. Today wasn't a holiday for us at work but I left early for a change.

Back after I catch up in the thread.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Hahaha, that timing is priceless.

 

[Kashta]

I'm still not sure where to place my vote. The Dawg/Kash thing really bothers me, but I can kind of see what Dawg was getting at. I can see how Kash may have been waiting to see others reactions before putting her vote on him.

The reason I delayed my vote was to observe and participate interactively first with whomever else was going to post on Sunday when I could be here. (Most of the time I've had to vote and just leave because of my schedule.) I've learned I can find out a lot more posting live interactively that reading a whole day's events at night, after the fact.

I was hoping DD and others like Noods, and so on would come along. Dun too. As it was... both Zaffy and Wizard were there so it gave me a chance to see if or how they might relate to each other and to me. And to see what if anything they would say about Dawg before I voted him.

If you're trying to detect connections between possible scummates, it's a real good time to do that when all three of your current suspects are online posting at the same time.

Had I voted Dawg when he tried to provoke me, that might've squelched the discussions we had.

As a result, I still suspect Zaffy just as much. Also downgraded Wizard on my suspect list because of how he responded (and rereading his prior posts).

Now, for Dawg to put a scummy spin on the timing of my vote or simply for voting whenever I choose is also consistent with someone in a scummy role. We already had different points of disagreement that got hashed out in the thread. An innocent Dawg could have left this at that without trying so hard to make me look scummy.

 

[Kashta]

No, I voted for her because I think she is innocent

Yep. I believe that's true. Disguised as a joke, of course.

 

[Lab_Rat]

So who are your top 4 most likely scum at this point Kash?

 

[Kashta]

These are my thoughts too. That is why I do not want to vote for either one tonight. It would just be a guess at which one is scum and I am not very good at guessing correctly.

This doesn't make sense, Noods. If you truly believe one is scum and the other is innocent you should at least vote one or the other. Reveal one role gives you insight on the other, plain and simple. Now, if you believed we're both innocents butting heads, THAT's a reason to not vote either of us. But according to this post that isn't what you believe is true.

This posts suggests Noods may know which one of us is scum but instead of putting her name on a vote against me... she dodged it so no one would come back to her to explain herself for that vote later on. It also gives an excuse to NOT vote her teammate. And it contributes to the level of general confusion over this for the town.

Scummy strategy there, Noods.