Mafia #99: The ACville Files- Game Thread

[dirtydawg10]

Ice, I have to ask, what was going through your head when you decided to vote me for something said in another thread entirely? What does it have to do with being scummy?



And Dawg, did this really just feel right enough to put me in a tie with LG, or did you have any specific reason for tying it up?

Yes it felt right. LG ended up being innocent and we're still not sure if my vote was on scum or not. Did you want me to let LG go to the looney bin without a coin toss? Not really sure what your point is FF. My reason was I thought you were scum. You may still be scum for all I know.

 

[dundadundun]

And you put LG in the lead, until I was tied with her. Was this solely because of what she did last game? If so, then it just seems like a bit of a bad reason to vote someone. JMO.

yup... is that a problem for a N1 vote? she showed up innocent, which is horrible for us with rich getting hit too, but she was not only innocent, but the most important innocent PR in the last game and look how well that went.

now let's talk about bad reasons, shall we? i hope for your sake you have an air tight reason for voting UN N1 again.

I vote to send UN to the loony bin because it seems voting him is pretty good luck for me, considering my team won last game

let me guess... your rabbits foot ran out?

if you're not scum, don't set yourself up. if you are scum, thanks for putting yourself out there. i'm sure the town appreciates it.

 

[allaboutfish]

its mighty quiet. scum must be hiding like the roaches they are.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice, I have to ask, what was going through your head when you decided to vote me for something said in another thread entirely? What does it have to do with being scummy?

Well my vote on Noods was a joke vote, I didn't like what you said in the other thread and I saw LG and Rich in the lead for lynching. None of the reasons were good ones,day 1 BS, so I figured I'd rather see you go then either of them. The other thread just helped the decision along.

As for todays vote, I did think you slipped. And I did add the personal part sort of as a test to see who would defend you. I figure no matter your role you'd be defended but the way of the defense could be telling. I'll have to go back and study each defense before I decide who is what.

I'm not sure that you're innocent either so my vote is staying on you. That and I think you're punk *** ***** commie wannabe that makes opinions even though you haven't lived in the real world yet and I hope to make you cry before games end....

 

[IceH2O]

That seems like an awfully bold (and unneccessarily so) post, Dawg. Why so strong on FF? Why do you feel the need to vote so early, and with so much conviction?

seems like a normal question...

I see the point I guess with FF but I am having a hard time because Dawg and Ice are so quick to vote. FF is notorious for not making sense and seeming to make major slip ups and a lot of times is innocent. I feel like this early in the game, you guys are taking advantage of it... I am willing to vote for FF if more people see it but it just bothers me to see votes coming out of the gate like that.

I mean, if it were anyone else, I might be as gung ho as you guys too..... but this is FF....

I always get a vibe when someone says I'd vote but......if you think they might be scum then what difference does it make who or how the votes fell...

Well, we are off to the same sucky start we usually have. Two innocents down and not a lot to go on. I do admit that FF's post sends off bells and whistles. I am however leary to vote so quick after night fall. I too must ask why so sure Dawg? Same question to Ice as well.

I am not opposed to voting FF but with the limited time I have had to play lately, I am not as thorough or accurate as I once was.

Same here as DD

DD, I must say that this almost seems as though you are defending FF.

Would you care to comment or explain in greater detail?

I don't see any difference in yours or DDs post...they both say I'd vote FF BUT.....

I agree FF clearly slipped up with his comment. What he actually posted wasn't a true statement. But what does his slip tell us... that he's on the scum team?

To be honest, my interpretation of his goof says more about him having screwed up priorities in mafia games. His "win" comment suggests that he considers a game "won" if he somehow manages to stay alive. The simple fact that his team actually lost and he did almost nothing to help his team along the way doesn't seem to matter to him nearly as much as it should.

Glad you were able to post FFs explanation for him.....How scary is it when you look into his mind?

yes i randoomly accidentally tied it up.

i dont see the case on FF, it makes no sense to vote someone bc of another thread, so far the second day hasnt given us much but crickets chirping.

Yeah maybe less skimming more reading......

So far I'd have to say I don't know yet......if FF is scum or innocent..........but I think DD Wiz and Kash could be scum,at least that is the way I'm judging their responses....

 

[Lab_Rat]

FF, thanks for clarifying your statement. Also, with as spread out as the votes were, and going into nightfall with a tie, if FF was scum I don't see his teammates not moving to save him. There was plenty of time to do so in a subtle way.

 

[jpappy789]

Let's please keep the personal attacks to a minimum. Thanks.

 

[IceH2O]

FF, thanks for clarifying your statement. Also, with as spread out as the votes were, and going into nightfall with a tie, if FF was scum I don't see his teammates not moving to save him. There was plenty of time to do so in a subtle way.

How so Labby? What reason would they give for moving to LG? She got voted off for joke votes....

 

[IceH2O]

Let's please keep the personal attacks to a minimum. Thanks.

Believe me that was minimum.....but I apologize.....

 

[user_name]

How so Labby? What reason would they give for moving to LG? She got voted off for joke votes....

I could be completely wrong here, but it sounds like you're throwing the people who voted LG under the bus here. I'm not trying to condone voting for no reason here, but at least we did get SOME info out of that, I'd be more prone to think that scum were hiding out as singleton votes, it's awfully easy to blend in that way. But then again, that doesn't seem like a great indicator that they're scum either.

To be honest there's very little to work with/off of at this point, beside whatever personnel things people have apparently.