Mafia #99: The ACville Files- Game Thread

[Kashta]

So let's just say for the sake of argument that Ice is innocent and the current interpretation of the paper is correct. LR, AAF and Dun voted for Ice last night. Don't you think if Ice is innocent that scum would vote for him?

Kash...why the singleton vote on DD? I get that you think she is scum but if you know your vote won't matter why not move it to where it might make a difference? Similar question to JB. Ice explained why he was gone at nightfall.

DD was the only suspect I had before nightfall. I could still see both possibilities for all the other players so I stuck with my best choice instead of voting someone else who was undecided.

Besides, if I'd been killed tonight by the scum hit or the votes shifted at the last minute (as I had 2 votes going into nightfall), leaving my singleton vote behind on the one/only person I was most certain about was the best clue I could leave for the town to look at later...... long after I'm gone, but along with a lot more information than we have today. Sometimes a little thing like that makes a difference. Usually it doesn't but it's still the best we can do in the early days when there's little to go on.

Have to go again but wanted to answer this. Be back soon.

 

[Zaffy]

kash i think she is most likely pro town
wiz not enough to go on really
and im sorry if im not the best at this game.

It's ok to not be the best at the game. It seems like you're either squirming because you're scum, or you're not trying which is just as bad for the town.

 

[IceH2O]

Not saying that this is the scum team, but looking at the voting record we have four players that voted for now known innocents D1 and D2

AAF- voted LG and ICE

Zaff- voted Rich and FF

Dun- voted LG and Ice

and Noods- voted Rich and FF.

I just thought I would put this out there for consideration.

Have to admit that Zaffy has intrigued me by tying up the vote between me and FF, didn't need to be a kill vote as they had 2 innocents up for the lynch.

 

[Zaffy]

most likely but i dont think just bc hes turned innocent that it automatically means that scum were on him.

I can agree with that, it's not 100%. Thanks for the answer.

 

[allaboutfish]

It's ok to not be the best at the game. It seems like you're either squirming because you're scum, or you're not trying which is just as bad for the town.

well whats it seems to be is not always what it is.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I explained why I placed my vote where I did. Thanks for pointing out all the possibilities though. I never said I "knew" anything. I said I wasn't ready to vote for either of them. In retrospect, I'm pleased with that judgment. Riddle me this. If Dun is institutionalized and after many, many rounds of ECT nilly he admits to being scum... will you still be chiding me for my singleton vote?

lol...no

i dont have much of a scum list yet but i guess here it is.
dirtydawg- i dont like how he decided that just bc someone voted an innocent that theyre scum. there could be someone on ice, but just bc we're almost sure that he's innocent doesnt mean that you knew that before nightfall. i also dont like the FF vote right after nightfall.
ice- thought you were scum but after tonight, your most likely innocent.
dun- seems pretty pro town to me.

Why is Ice on your scum list but "most likely innocent"?

you left off Wiz and Kash

But it looks to me like Dawg is your only suspect so I guess you should vote him.

Haha...agreed!

 

[allaboutfish]

lol...no


Why is Ice on your scum list but "most likely innocent"?


Haha...agreed!

it wasnt really a scum list just an everyone list.

 

[dirtydawg10]

DD was the only suspect I had before nightfall. I could still see both possibilities for all the other players so I stuck with my best choice instead of voting someone else who was undecided.

Besides, if I'd been killed tonight by the scum hit or the votes shifted at the last minute (as I had 2 votes going into nightfall), leaving my singleton vote behind on the one/only person I was most certain about was the best clue I could leave for the town to look at later...... long after I'm gone, but along with a lot more information than we have today. Sometimes a little thing like that makes a difference. Usually it doesn't but it's still the best we can do in the early days when there's little to go on.

Have to go again but wanted to answer this. Be back soon.

I'm liking your posts as of late...so for now...I retract my vote for Kash and vote to send Dun to the looney bin

 

[dundadundun]

Zaffy- Lab 43
Noods- Ice 46
LG- Rich 59, AAF 78, Dun 82
Lab- Wiz 61
DD- Dawg 62
Wiz- LG 63
UN- FF 64
FF- JB 67, Ice 85, Dawg 88
JB- Kash 68
AAF- Bally 70
Rich- Zaffy 72, Noods 73
Dun- UN 75
Kash- DD 81

Everyone has voted.

Nightfall is in 30 minutes. PMs as required!

Final Votes:

FF- Dawg 101, Ice 103, Noods 170, Wiz 208, Zaffy 223
Wiz- Ice 154
Dun- JB 155
Kash- Dawg 160, DD 172
Ice- Lab 166, AAF 169, Dun 181
DD- Kash 186

No votes from FF, Bally, UN

Dun another question....I know Day 1 is a crapshoot and most of the votes are jokes unless something serious arises, but what made you put a joke vote on LG to push her into the lead?

As for Day 2 I will reread tomorrow when my brain will let me multitask.

it's a competitive game. i'm a guy with a competitive nature. she and JP pushed until i was railroaded last game... and i was innocent. it wasn't a joke. didn't turn out well, though, but how was i to know?

actually, now that i think about it, i'm not sure i've voted once in any of the games i've played unless it was to put someone in the lead. whatever that's worth...

i'm sorry i haven't been much help. i knew i was voting LG before the game started, so i slacked off for the first nightfall. that was kind of scummy looking, i guess. after that, it's been a hectic couple days. unfortunately, due to stress sleeping last night wasn't useful at all so i'm pushing delirious ATM and i have to be up and chasing kids soon. i dunno how much i'll be on today, either. i'm exhausted. due to my inactivity, i couldn't blame you guys for lynching me tonight if you felt the need. i guess them's the breaks. i just hope the town survives to see another day. last game didn't go so well.

hopefully i get some mental clarity enough to read through later and help out a little.

i'm rambling and can't pay attention right now. hope this makes sense. hopefully i can get a few winks before the kiddos start going nutty. luckily they're not up yet. thank goodness for spell check. goodnight, folks. again...

 

[noodles62]

ok, it is early, still sipping my first cup of coffee after a night of beer and football - I get the Ice reference in the headline, but why would invest results be published in the headlines? That is not making sense to me.