Mafia Game 2

Coler is a darn good player, MVP two consecutive rounds.
Great work by the townies, I think playing with more people allowed a greater depth than last game, you didn't let the wool be pulled over your eyes.
Thanks for running this round to Ogre
:clap: :clap: :clap:
 
NeonJulie said:
I so want to play during the next game!!! Except I don't think people should be allowed to roleplay for others, as if it's them talking...
Click to expand...

IMO the game got better when folks quit role playing altogether... while the role playing was amusing in the beginning, no real info came out of it
 
Madcrawdad said:
you sure did a good job of hiding it then...:) I thought for sure that you were mafia creating a smoke screen for Coler.... Detective JRR said "Coler is Mafia" and you kept saying 'I'm not so sure...' After that, other folks started saying 'yeah, I'm not so sure...' I even PMed JRR after he got whacked and told him I thought he made a mistake in declaring you an innocent in one of his posts.

Thank goodness Dwarf Puffer kept his wits about him, even though it almost got him lynched. In the end the town prevailed.... good job nailing GuppyGuppyFish....I had no idea she was mafia.
Click to expand...

LOL it's funny really, at first, I was sure Coler was the Mafia becaause I simply misread one of his posts. I was so sure.... but then I went back an re read the post and was lie waaaaait a minute, and that's what finished my thoughts on him.

*GASP* I could never be someone so sinister as the Mafia :evil_lol:
 
J double R said:
agreed.




and btw, for everyone who played after i died, i couldnt believe that Coler had you guys going for so long! Coler, good on you for playing a good role.. you managed to make it to the last night, even though i TOLD everyone that i found you out AND i was the proven detective.. good playing man!

can't wait for the next game... *sinister laugh* :headbang2:
Click to expand...


i couldn't believe it either..i thought about it a few times..but i stayed quiet so i wasn't killed by mafia during the night..i figured out his game at the end though..although..i knew it all along..er..from the time you said he was mafia..
 
YUP...Coler had the wool pulled over my eyes for a time being....and then DP brought up some very interesting points about Coler....this game WAS more fun than the first...I definitely want to play again....and if KOTD wants to be Moderator or Coler...then LET'S GET IT ON...and try and get 16 people again....count me in...I surely thought I was going to be lynched also in the first and second...but the Townies sure held their ground this time....and let's give Ogre a chance to play since he did such a good job on Moderating the last 2....I will bet more people will sign up this time....LET'S GIT ER DUN... and yeah no role playing it was kinda hard...:)
 
Madcrawdad said:
IMO the game got better when folks quit role playing altogether... while the role playing was amusing in the beginning, no real info came out of it
Click to expand...

I think the reason for the role playing was so the Innocents could establish who the real innocents were...at least that is what I got from most of it...and DD your secret will still go with me to my grave....:lipssealedsmilie: (the wedding dress)....:headbang2:
 
i'll gladly moderate it, just need all the rules and time sequences from ogre
 
I enjoyed some of the RPG element it had, it didn't add anything to the deducing of innocents or mafia but it made it a little bit more enjoyable, for what it was worth.

I don't think we would have been able to keep it up for an entire game though...
 
the main thing the role playing was for..was just to get everyone established, and to get the game going..it was fun..but of court se it wasn't going to last the whole game...or else we'd still be playing, lol

now go sign up for game 3!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom