Mafia Game 3

NeonJulie said:
We need to identify Ogre. I think it's important by the end of the night, to have either him or I identified. If he's lynched, and he's mafia, then I'm right. If I'm lynched and shown to be innocent, then I'm still right, and he's wrong. Then he'd have to dig himself out of his hole and explain why he was so positive, and how he got so many to stick to their vote for me......(snip)

But I seriously hope once I'm proved innocent, you guys go after JRR. He started it, again unprovoked. He's had a such a limited participation, and hardly says anything, just lynches people. Not really people. Just me. That guy has not devated the whole time.

I might change to Ogre if I think it'll make a difference and there are folks behind it. He hasn't proved his identity. I think he makes a great mafia, as far as strategy. But he does have my heartstrings: he sounds innocent, and I want to believe him. But at this point, we can't both be right.

There's also a very distinct possibility as Madcrawdad pointed out, that I might not live the night out regardless of what the vote is.

By the way, if Ogre and me are both innocent, definite definitely look at Madcrawdad!
Click to expand...

here's the thing, NJ.....as I said earlier, I'm leaning toward Ogre being an innocent based on the reasons I already stated. Now based on this post from you, I'm leaning that way for you too. The reason being is that it doesn't make sense for a mafia member who is about to be lynched to start naming folks to investigate after they're gone. The reason being, that once that mafia member is lynched, any person mentioned as 'someone to be investigated' would be pretty much cleared when the lynchee's mafia ties are revealed.....therefore, it's a pretty bad strategy for the mafia.

Of course that could change in the future now that I've mentioned this, but I think it rings true in your case....

At any rate, I'm starting to think you may be an innocent....

Therefore....I'm asking you to join in voting for Sovran. Ogre, I'm asking you as well, as I hope you'll find my reasoning to be sound here. Jessicar, you said that you thought I was onto something please join also, and we can make this happen.
 
4 Votes are still not enough. As altruistic as I'd like to be here, I don't see the value in throwing my life away, so unfortunately I might have to fall that way. I am undecided about her just like I'm undecided about everyone. But 4 votes are still not 6.

Even if you do call me innocent, you have to imagine it's AWFULLY hard for me to trust you and follow you're lead. All you've done all day is bag me for trying to come to an agreement with you!

For instance, some how we pull off this miracle, and I survive tomorrow... then I have to account for my actions all over again and eventually, people will stop caring and just vote me off. How will switching my vote to Sovran make me look I wonder? You definitely have a bee in your bonnit about her. I'm undecided. I can understand her confusion - even now this game is a tremendous challenge. Voting out someone for revealing that they are unsure how to play the game might cause other people who have never played before, not want to play.
 
I change my vote...

I vote for Sovran...:)

I believed long ago that Jules is an Innocent......
 
madcrawdad
neonjulie
ogre

you guys all just spiked my Mafia meter with that last post

the other 2 would be hmmm....maybe
plantling and coler
 
NeonJulie said:
4 Votes are still not enough. As altruistic as I'd like to be here, I don't see the value in throwing my life away, so unfortunately I might have to fall that way. I am undecided about her just like I'm undecided about everyone. But 4 votes are still not 6.

Even if you do call me innocent, you have to imagine it's AWFULLY hard for me to trust you and follow you're lead. All you've done all day is bag me for trying to come to an agreement with you!
Click to expand...

no...there's 2 for Sovran....w/ you, Ogre, and Jessica that would be 5....Ogre and Jessica would also take 2 away from you...

As far as not trusting me....what have you got to lose? You're already in real danger anyway, right?
 
Dwarf Puffers said:
Dwarf Puffers said:
Votes (sorry Rbishop for screwing it up AGAIN by not typing John Larson's vote):

1 Madcrawdad - Sovran

1 "13" - Mee-mee

1 IceH20 - "13"

6 NeonJulie: CC, Ogre, Jdub, Fish Lady, Coler, Jessica

2 Jdub - Cory Lover, Neon Julie

1 Ogre - John Larson

1 Cory Lover - DangerDoll

3 Sovran - Madcrawdad, Jensons, IceH20

Players yet to vote:

Plantling
bkw1982

Night will begin in 9 hours. KotD is looking even worse. Let's all cross our fingers that this heroic leader will live the night. Indeed, this night is foreboding and ominous, as the Mafia stir about, preparing to slay yet another innocent who attempts to shed the light upon them...


And how am I doing this ?
Click to expand...

Doing good thanks for getting my vote right after three tries.
Click to expand...
 
Well there's no way Ogre would change. His whole strategy at this point is getting me up that tree because I'm big ol bad mafia.

I don't have much to lose - but if I lynch an innocent you can bet sulfur's gonna rain down on me... then again, it'd be something just to say I survived this day.

I would not feel comfortable lynching an innocent to save myself. But I also want to stick around to try and help the innocents win.
 
NeonJulie said:
Well there's no way Ogre would change. His whole strategy at this point is getting me up that tree because I'm big ol bad mafia.

I don't have much to lose - but if I lynch an innocent you can bet sulfur's gonna rain down on me... then again, it'd be something just to say I survived this day.

I would not feel comfortable lynching an innocent to save myself. But I also want to stick around to try and help the innocents win.
Click to expand...

well...think about it, because I've got to hit the hay. I'm so confident that Sovran is mafia that I'm willing to take the hit if I'm wrong. On day 3, folks can offer me up for lynching all they want and I won't fight back AT ALL.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom