You're right, it was my old notes. I've now gone through it at least twice. I got it right later! Geez. I didn't see YOU doing any "paperwork!" And while I'm at it, not really voting either.
Mafia Game 3
- Thread starter KingOfTheDeep
- Start date
You're right, it was my old notes. I've now gone through it at least twice. I got it right later! Geez. I didn't see YOU doing any "paperwork!" And while I'm at it, not really voting either.
Hmm... I'm not partial to either of them. But I have reasons to hang on to him for another night. If MadCrawdad feels it's a decent move, I'll consider it. I do think he's mafia.
Hmm - now my head is really spinning. Everyone makes such valid points. RBishop hasn't really defended himself, yet MadCrawdad sounds like a case of "methinks he doth protest too much". Mind you, seeing as this is day one of my first game, I have a feeling that I don't really know what I am doing.
Funny you use that phrase, and haven't drawn a straw yet. *lol*
This is a lot like survivor - only we can't even make alliances behind a bush. Unfortunately we have to stick together, in plain sight. I think Madcrawdad is right because a good thing to do, is divide and conquer, and spread chaos. Everyone vote for someone different, and they tack on those remaining 2 or 3 votes, and swing one of us right out, and we helped them! Or we have to all look at the facts, look at our guts, and make a decision for the majority, fully knowing it's possible we're wrong. Somebody has to go out on round 1...
So tonight I really don't want to see round 3 go out like 1 and 2. The first guy to vote, must be it! But we know that the last 2 times it was completely wrong. That's NOT to say that he's NOT mafia, but the brave ones should not be punished immediately. No one will want to play, and then no one will want to make the first move.
Dwarf puffer was the first person to cast a second vote for someone else already nominated. Yes, typical mafia behavior. But it was a "fishing" vote, and how seriously can votes from 12 hours plus be taken. Well this is kind of silly. Nobody really looks guilty. And the one who does... I feel disinclined to vote out early...
This is a lot like survivor - only we can't even make alliances behind a bush. Unfortunately we have to stick together, in plain sight. I think Madcrawdad is right because a good thing to do, is divide and conquer, and spread chaos. Everyone vote for someone different, and they tack on those remaining 2 or 3 votes, and swing one of us right out, and we helped them! Or we have to all look at the facts, look at our guts, and make a decision for the majority, fully knowing it's possible we're wrong. Somebody has to go out on round 1...
So tonight I really don't want to see round 3 go out like 1 and 2. The first guy to vote, must be it! But we know that the last 2 times it was completely wrong. That's NOT to say that he's NOT mafia, but the brave ones should not be punished immediately. No one will want to play, and then no one will want to make the first move.
Dwarf puffer was the first person to cast a second vote for someone else already nominated. Yes, typical mafia behavior. But it was a "fishing" vote, and how seriously can votes from 12 hours plus be taken. Well this is kind of silly. Nobody really looks guilty. And the one who does... I feel disinclined to vote out early...
Last edited:
I would ask all townies to vote for caveman at this point based upon his willingness to toss someone from the game on such a weak reason (at least make something up that sounds plausible)....is he mafia? I certainly think so at this point.....
a couple of things make me nervous, though. firstly, that Ogre is asking you to change your vote...why? secondly, that you're asking my advice when you wanted to lynch me just a few hours ago.
Hmmm, guess I shouldn't have joined my vote against Ice, I thought it would be a good move to go with the guy who has seen more than any of us concerning the Mafia Game, guess I was too hasty, just kind of feel like I should get it over with the first night...
If/when I get taken out tonight, remember that Ice voted for me, and remember that if someone gets taken out by the Mafia, re-read their lynching votes, it may tell you why they were not wanted to voice themselves anymore.
Well, I'll go feed my guppy fry agaaaaain, and then I'll prolly be to bed. I'm tired, tommorow morning I'll check to see if I'm dead, if I'm not, :woot:, if I am, I guess trying my hand at assertiveness in the Mafia Game isn't the best choice...
I stick with my feelings of Ice. He seems suspicious. He also has no reasons other than me voting for him to lynch me. I'm watching, Ice. But it would indeed blow to anger the vigilant. Oh god, he'd use his 1 hit faster than... Something.
Salutes, Cousin Pete (RIP)
If/when I get taken out tonight, remember that Ice voted for me, and remember that if someone gets taken out by the Mafia, re-read their lynching votes, it may tell you why they were not wanted to voice themselves anymore.
Well, I'll go feed my guppy fry agaaaaain, and then I'll prolly be to bed. I'm tired, tommorow morning I'll check to see if I'm dead, if I'm not, :woot:, if I am, I guess trying my hand at assertiveness in the Mafia Game isn't the best choice...
I stick with my feelings of Ice. He seems suspicious. He also has no reasons other than me voting for him to lynch me. I'm watching, Ice. But it would indeed blow to anger the vigilant. Oh god, he'd use his 1 hit faster than... Something.
Salutes, Cousin Pete (RIP)
As for Ogre voting for me, I think he suspects I'm innocent and thus doesn't want me lynched (?).
I'll go check Cavy's posts, might be that that'll sway me more than Ogre's suspicion and an angry Ice.
Ok, just re-read and edited this on, I change my vote to CaptainCaveman. He seems to throw around lynchings pretty easilly for an innocent.
Btw, it looks like this is starting to get serious and intense, can we PLZ have a Mafia Game 2 (AKA fun roleplay, non-serious game) instead of a Mafia Game 1 (AKA intense mud slinging and ultimate frustration)? I would hate for such a nice game as this to boil down to a bunch of savages squabbling around...
I have no need to defend myself....especially since a definite two mafia have already exposed themselves....
Yup I was. But that was a long time ago, and I said then I was seeking more information (aka "fishing"). I especially have to look at everything Ogre does with a second look, he's got to be the expert here. He could completely be playing me. He really could be playing on my weakness right now not to see the first Voter go up the tree.
But I do agree with you, captaincaveman really seems like the most likely. I don't know if just the two of us can make that happen though. (But three votes, that's more possible.)
I retract my vote for Dwarf Puffer, and
I vote to lynch Captaincaveman.
