Mafia Game 3
- Thread starter KingOfTheDeep
- Start date
FireDancer7905
I'm in love!
To Ogre: press me, if you must. I posted why I thought that each of my top three was Mafia.
Ice: I know that no one can *prove* that they are innocent, but you can try to reason it through as to why you are not, and make other people see that.
Innocent: I am not mafia (I know. I know, you don't have to take my word for it). I did not vote for DP (thanks for taking over!). I have not posted inflamatory remarks with no (though, arguably little in some cases) though behind them. I am willing to listen to reason, and may change my vote accordingly.
My top 3:
1) I still believe that MadCrawdad is mafia. His posts just don't ring true with me (see last post for quotes/reasons, page 21).
2)IceH20: feeling uncertain, though it may just be that you are vocal and defending yourself
3) 13: your few posts seem hollow, accusatory and very "out to get them"
It's unfortunate that we lynched one innocent, and then the mafia got another. They will gain the upper hand, unless we all post, and try really hard not to get offended when someone accuses us. As members of a forum, we are all assumed to be polite, rational adults. The advice sections of AC show how much we really know, and that we can all get our brainpower together to solve problems that we may be oceans away from.
Hoping the Townies get through this one together,
~brandy
Ice: I know that no one can *prove* that they are innocent, but you can try to reason it through as to why you are not, and make other people see that.
Innocent: I am not mafia (I know. I know, you don't have to take my word for it). I did not vote for DP (thanks for taking over!). I have not posted inflamatory remarks with no (though, arguably little in some cases) though behind them. I am willing to listen to reason, and may change my vote accordingly.
My top 3:
1) I still believe that MadCrawdad is mafia. His posts just don't ring true with me (see last post for quotes/reasons, page 21).
2)IceH20: feeling uncertain, though it may just be that you are vocal and defending yourself
3) 13: your few posts seem hollow, accusatory and very "out to get them"
It's unfortunate that we lynched one innocent, and then the mafia got another. They will gain the upper hand, unless we all post, and try really hard not to get offended when someone accuses us. As members of a forum, we are all assumed to be polite, rational adults. The advice sections of AC show how much we really know, and that we can all get our brainpower together to solve problems that we may be oceans away from.
Hoping the Townies get through this one together,
~brandy
so i never saw when you voted for me...
im sorry Ice, I dont mean to sound rude at all.. It is a game of course and rereading my posts i did sound a lil rude.
But anyways...back to neon. I remember reading yesterday neonjulie and bishop bickering back and forth. I just really think its odd that he was lynch by the mafia. Now ask yourselves this question. who did bishop have the most confrontation with? and why would he be lynched? that is one the major reasons for voting for neonjulie. I am not voting for her on a whim...im voting for her because i have a HUGE hunch that she is behind the lynching of Bish....and that she is the mastermind behind the mafia.
I really don't know what to think of Ogre's list...it seems to scream Mafia for a couple of people....but then he could just be saying those things to make the Townies believe that some Mafia are really Innocents and vise versa...That is how we ended up lynching all the Townies in the first game...but then we had a Detective in the second game, but we didn't follow his lead for awhile (real good job at that J)....I have reading and rereading and rereading all the posts we have so far...and I kind of have a inkling on who is Mafia...but I am going to wait out 1 more night to see where everyone goes....
(btw Ogre...Glad your stepdad is doing much better...continued prayers and thoughts from me...off topic..everyone should go to Liv2Padl site in GCC also, posted by DD..thank you DD for doing that)....
(btw Ogre...Glad your stepdad is doing much better...continued prayers and thoughts from me...off topic..everyone should go to Liv2Padl site in GCC also, posted by DD..thank you DD for doing that)....
yeah so what i have only voted for one person and that is IceH20 yesterday and again today. i'm not going to change my vote for any reason. As far as my post's seaming hollow...well maybe i'm just not posting a big fake line of crap ? just like a mafia member would. Its only been 2 days so im sticking with my vote for awhile. heck i'll even vote for IcEH20 again tomorrow if he isn't voted out tonight.
Hollow as it may be
Hey just reading through again and came across this...Maybe the reason he was lynched by the mafia ? could there be more to this list than meets the eye...?
wow...lots going on while I was away. like Ogre, I will post my thoughts on folks still playing...hopefully it won't get me whacked:
madcrawdad - innocent. getting some hard looks for saying how he thinks mafia would be playing the game, however, in any strategy game you MUST try to think like your opponent to win.
bkw1982 - trying very hard to look like he's not playing the game. I've seen his name watching the thread, and he's made other posts on AC, but very few here. IMO lurking is a 'mafia move' or at least a 'selfish townie' move....lurking serves no purpose other than creating confusion among the townies. the mafia knows if a lurker is a mafia or townie, but the town has NO idea, and is usually hesitant to lynch a lurker as they're afraid they may be an innocent. I mention that this could also be a 'selfish townie' move, as the mafia is less likely to whack a lurking townie, knowing that a particular lurking townie is causing confusion among the good guys.
JRR - No real read....interesting that he voted at the same time as FL22 and for the same person both days
FishLady - no real read....interesting that she voted at the same time as JRR and for the same person both days
NeonJulie - really erratic on day 1.....claims to have had a 1-day alliance with me? If trying to lynch me is an alliance, I need a new dictionary. Claims not to be allied with IceH2O, but has regularly come to his defense. mafia? possibly
IceH2O - put himself in jeopardy on day 1 by suggesting that folks look hard at lurkers. I think that day 1 is a little early to start lynching lurkers, but I agree with it as a strategy later on, as lurkers serve no purpose but to confuse. also claims not to be allied w/ NeonJ, but has come to her defense on a couple of occasions. mafia? I have no clue.
cory lover - no real read yet
Dangerdoll - so far no real red flags for me, other than she makes some real BIG leaps in her conclusions, which don't always seem sound to me.
Coler - no real read yet....started out lurking, but now playing
Mee-mee - no real read yet....lurking or not able to post? can't tell.
Jessicar613 - no real read yet....but she definitely wants NeonJ gone.
Captaincaveman9 - voted for me yesterday for bogus reason IMO (I didn't seem very nice). Mafia? maybe, but at least guilty of 'untownsmanlike conduct' by not caring if he tossed a townie for a bogus reason.
johnlarson66 - no read yet
Jensons - too few posts....can't read yet...although I did get her vote yesterday.
13 - no read yet, but still going after Ice for suggesting a viable strategy....although probably a better strategy later in the game
plantling - no real read yet
Sovran - my strongest mafia candidate yet. constantly letting everyone know "I'm so confused", "I don't know what I'm doing", "I'm a sheep".....all of this to really say "Psst....I can't be mafia cuz I don't have a clue whats going on". And in case folks forget, Sovran will tell you again "I'm ever so clueless, I should just sit back and watch". then votes for an innocent, and afterwards "Oh dear, I do declare...I think I may have lynched an innocent. The horror." Look hard here folks as this strategy was used by mafia in both of the first 2 games.
Ogre - gets his own post, as I have alot to say here.
Still not voting yet though....do when know when nightfall is?
madcrawdad - innocent. getting some hard looks for saying how he thinks mafia would be playing the game, however, in any strategy game you MUST try to think like your opponent to win.
bkw1982 - trying very hard to look like he's not playing the game. I've seen his name watching the thread, and he's made other posts on AC, but very few here. IMO lurking is a 'mafia move' or at least a 'selfish townie' move....lurking serves no purpose other than creating confusion among the townies. the mafia knows if a lurker is a mafia or townie, but the town has NO idea, and is usually hesitant to lynch a lurker as they're afraid they may be an innocent. I mention that this could also be a 'selfish townie' move, as the mafia is less likely to whack a lurking townie, knowing that a particular lurking townie is causing confusion among the good guys.
JRR - No real read....interesting that he voted at the same time as FL22 and for the same person both days
FishLady - no real read....interesting that she voted at the same time as JRR and for the same person both days
NeonJulie - really erratic on day 1.....claims to have had a 1-day alliance with me? If trying to lynch me is an alliance, I need a new dictionary. Claims not to be allied with IceH2O, but has regularly come to his defense. mafia? possibly
IceH2O - put himself in jeopardy on day 1 by suggesting that folks look hard at lurkers. I think that day 1 is a little early to start lynching lurkers, but I agree with it as a strategy later on, as lurkers serve no purpose but to confuse. also claims not to be allied w/ NeonJ, but has come to her defense on a couple of occasions. mafia? I have no clue.
cory lover - no real read yet
Dangerdoll - so far no real red flags for me, other than she makes some real BIG leaps in her conclusions, which don't always seem sound to me.
Coler - no real read yet....started out lurking, but now playing
Mee-mee - no real read yet....lurking or not able to post? can't tell.
Jessicar613 - no real read yet....but she definitely wants NeonJ gone.
Captaincaveman9 - voted for me yesterday for bogus reason IMO (I didn't seem very nice). Mafia? maybe, but at least guilty of 'untownsmanlike conduct' by not caring if he tossed a townie for a bogus reason.
johnlarson66 - no read yet
Jensons - too few posts....can't read yet...although I did get her vote yesterday.
13 - no read yet, but still going after Ice for suggesting a viable strategy....although probably a better strategy later in the game
plantling - no real read yet
Sovran - my strongest mafia candidate yet. constantly letting everyone know "I'm so confused", "I don't know what I'm doing", "I'm a sheep".....all of this to really say "Psst....I can't be mafia cuz I don't have a clue whats going on". And in case folks forget, Sovran will tell you again "I'm ever so clueless, I should just sit back and watch". then votes for an innocent, and afterwards "Oh dear, I do declare...I think I may have lynched an innocent. The horror." Look hard here folks as this strategy was used by mafia in both of the first 2 games.
Ogre - gets his own post, as I have alot to say here.
Still not voting yet though....do when know when nightfall is?
Mee-mee - no real read yet....lurking or not able to post? can't tell....
really not able to post so much because I have to go to bed early because I have to work early in the morning.....plus I have been reading the posts over and over and over to get a better feeling about people...
really not able to post so much because I have to go to bed early because I have to work early in the morning.....
plus I have been reading the posts over and over and over to get a better feeling about people...its bound to happen....so why the heartfelt explanation...hmmm makes me wonder. there are only 5 mafia. the only reason i am voting for IcEH20 is because he voted for me and im sticking to that for no real reason ( hope your not a innocent by the way otherwise were down 3 )
Ok if we're doing lists here is mine:
bkw1982 - to quiet this game after being very vocal last game. Different strategy or Mafia?
Madcrawdad - a lot of fingers pointed his way. Think innocent
OgreMkV - As much experience as he has at this game and looking lost doesn't add up. Could just be to early in the game.....Mafia?
J Double R - Mafia. To quick to put the next name of the hitlist up to vote.
NeonJulie - Scares the hell out of me, changes votes on a whim.
Cory Lover - been hard to read him watching the other games
Dangerdoll - I thought she was Mafia last game and was wrong, I'm going to wait on her.
mee-mee - Watching but think innocent.
coler - This cat can play as a mafia, think he seems not as sure about his posting as an innocent.
FishLady22 - Mafia. To quick to follow J RR.
sovran - Also believe the I'm lost is a cover. Mafia?
jessicar613 - Posted that she is new in town? hmmmm.
captaincaveman9 - Any truth to the finger pointing? Keeping an eye on.
johnlarson66 - .Bandwagon jumping. Only reason he voted for DP was because I did. ......????
jensons - Believe is innocent
"13" - .quiet, holds grudges, Mad they were pointed out to quickly and doesn't want to be the 1st Mafia lynched?
Plantling - Think they are just getting a feel for the game. Innocent
bkw1982 - to quiet this game after being very vocal last game. Different strategy or Mafia?
Madcrawdad - a lot of fingers pointed his way. Think innocent
OgreMkV - As much experience as he has at this game and looking lost doesn't add up. Could just be to early in the game.....Mafia?
J Double R - Mafia. To quick to put the next name of the hitlist up to vote.
NeonJulie - Scares the hell out of me, changes votes on a whim.
Cory Lover - been hard to read him watching the other games
Dangerdoll - I thought she was Mafia last game and was wrong, I'm going to wait on her.
mee-mee - Watching but think innocent.
coler - This cat can play as a mafia, think he seems not as sure about his posting as an innocent.
FishLady22 - Mafia. To quick to follow J RR.
sovran - Also believe the I'm lost is a cover. Mafia?
jessicar613 - Posted that she is new in town? hmmmm.
captaincaveman9 - Any truth to the finger pointing? Keeping an eye on.
johnlarson66 - .Bandwagon jumping. Only reason he voted for DP was because I did. ......????
jensons - Believe is innocent
"13" - .quiet, holds grudges, Mad they were pointed out to quickly and doesn't want to be the 1st Mafia lynched?
Plantling - Think they are just getting a feel for the game. Innocent
