Mafia Game 3

I'm willing to go on with the game.

Ice I'll disagree with your reasoning for thinking FL is mafia. I do have some suspicions, but she's not my top pick for mafia. I'm more in line with suspecting 13
 
"13" said:
OK i know this is a reach but in the thread for mafia 4 ( good reason to keep games separate from one another ) cory lover says he wants to play something other than a innocent don't no if that means he is a innocent or just posted that to mislead anyone still playing game 3 ?
Click to expand...

You know...in that same thread i had said pretty much the same thing...it was along the lines of..."Im sick of being innocent!!!" I've been an innocent the 2 games that i have played.

Since no one really has a reason why they are voting for me, then all I can really say is, I am an innocent. Take it or leave it.
 
13 has been rubbing be wrong so to speak in this entire game.......he just seems Mafia. Therefor I'm going with my gut feeling and I vote to lynch 13

BTW 13, I was trying to throw no one off by saying that I was innocent in the other thread. I am innocent, like I have been in the other two games. Period.

CL
 
In the event that I'm whacked, I want to post my thoughts of the remaining players...

'13' - Mafia, as I've already stated....

Captain Caveman - I pulled together an argument as to how he might be mafia, but it's a reach for me. Coler & JL66 were 4 for 4 in calling mafia, though. IMO probably innocent, but I'm willing to go after him for Coler/JL66.

Cory Lover - Relatively few posts in the thread. Could be a lurking strategy, but if he were mafia, don't you think he'd be having a little more fun trying to run people around as opposed to REALLY lurking for the whole game? I'm leaning innocent.

IceH2O - I'm leaning innocent on IceH2O. Ice H2O had suspicions cast upon him from the beginning by Ogre (same as myself). While he really made me nervous on Day 3 when we were going after Sovran, DD & Ogre by suggesting that we 'split the vote,' I think he had the town's best interest at heart. Yesterday I noted some concerns about Ice posting seemingly innocent messages to the mafia asking for surrender, etc. and I'm glad I did. Not because I necessarily still have the concerns, but because Plantling's response to my concern mostly cleared Ice in my mind.

In her response, it looks to me like she's goading Ice to respond rashly...maybe switch his vote to me. Here's how I read what she's saying: 'Ice, you're gone next! Are you and the townies gonna take that!? This madman is on a power trip! He must be mafia.'
plantling said:
I think Mad's on a power thing. I wonder who else he'll name after they get rid of Ice? Go on Mad, name your top three besides me.
Click to expand...

Jensons - Not very many posts, but she jumped on the Sovran lynch train with me late on Day 2. I think that I made a pretty logical and compelling argument for lynching Sovran that evening, and if Jensons were mafia she wouldn't have jumped on so quickly. Had I posted my argument for Sovran earlier that day, I really think that we could have gotten that ball rolling. I have a pretty good feeling that Jensons is innocent.

FishLady22 - Made Ogre's list of mafia suspects at one point for getting in front of the NeonJ lynching. FL also got really far out in front of the Plantling lynch train. I think FishLady22 is innocent.

Madcrawdad - I hope my actions to date speak for themselves. If I'm ever in a position where it looks like I'm in danger of being lynched, I'll make more compelling arguments for my innocence, but I'm innocent.

JdoubleR - known innocent

BKW1982 - known innocent

There you have my thoughts folks....By the way, I vote to lynch '13'. Pretty sure he's mafia....if not, we can go for Caveman next.
 
Thanks for the vote of confidence Mad! I am going to jump on your train yet again, and say I vote to lynch 13. I like the reasoning of Mad, and am quite frankly at a loss for another player who may be mafia.
~brandy
 
I vote to lynch 13 his posts and voting record speak for themselves
 
For those interested....current vote count

4 '13' - CoryLover, Madcrawdad, Jensons, captaincaveman9

2 FishLady22 - bkw1982, IceH2O


Still to vote:
JdoubleR
FishLady22
'13'
 
I'll switch my vote to Lynch 13 just so there is no way it can be tied. If 13 isn't mafia and CL or CC are they might switch last second to try and tie.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom