Mafia Game #4 The Play

[Madcrawdad]

By my estimation, if Hooked Newbie is innocent, then jpappy is our mafia.

It's possible that you're right, Ogre... In looking thru the 1st 2 day's votes:

On day 1 when CL came pretty close to being voted off, JPappy voted for Cory Lover earlier in the day. At some point he recalled his vote for CL (possibly when he saw CL may actually be voted off). Once it was clear that CL would stay and Nola would be voted off, JPappy re-cast the final vote of the day for Cory Lover.

On day 2 when CL was lynched, JPappy got on the Cory Lover train late, way after it was apparent that CL would go (I believe that he was 8th on the CL vote, right after King and right before Mee-mee)

Although I voted for HN tonight, something that had been bothering me when I analyzed the first 2 day's votes was that HN was 4th on the Cory Lover lynch train on day 2. Although not impossible, it's a little early to hop on to lynch one of your mafia buddies.

If enough folks are willing, I'd be willing to change to lynch JPappy tonight.

 

[ZSandmann]

Hmmm, this is an interesting turn. I'm willing to test it, I think bkw has shown me a few things in his last few posts. Maybe I was subliminally gunning for him and jl even though I was trying my best to put more stock in my claims.

I vote to lynch jpappy789.

 

[Madcrawdad]

unvote Hooked Newbie, I vote to lynch JPappy

 

[ZSandmann]

I really just don't feel HN is the last Mafia. If it is jpappy man he has played an All-Star game IMO.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Well, call it my dying breath, but I'll go along... I have no choice.

Recall vote for bkw, I vote to lynch JPappy

 

[ZSandmann]

Your not dead yet, sevenish hours left and four people haven't voted

 

[judgemax]

I think this is interesting..Has me perplexed, I would feel very bad however, if HN is mafia, and we let him walk another night, ..However,if he is mafia, game done tonight..I dunno, I think at this point, I would like to keep mine the same..Just as insurance, I still believe strongly that it is either him, or fl22..at this point, I wanna be sure I am wrong..and, NJ, came outa left field for me..so, I have to say, that one of those two is innocent, IMHO, if its not hooked newbie, it is FL22, ...I wish at some point, I could find the quote by NJ, to fl22, where she goes, hey she called you mafia to..she just replied with ha-ha, not much more...?

 

[johnlarson66]

Ok , no more mr nice girl, heres three mafia players..

coler

KOTD

and

hooked newbie

Here is the "list". I do not see what name Hooked Newbie says is still here. Maybe HN could post what name is still on the list.

I see no reason at all not to follow judgemax's list at this point...

Following is not a bad thing. Unless you are following the mafia.

 

[judgemax]

FL22 was on the final version...

 

[Madcrawdad]

Here is the "list". I do not see what name Hooked Newbie says is still here. Maybe HN could post what name is still on the list.

I see no reason at all not to follow judgemax's list at this point...

Following is not a bad thing. Unless you are following the mafia.

Judge also named Fish Lady and Mee-mee for a total of 5 mafia...

The fact that NeonJulie came out of the blue (ie, not even on Judge's radar), means at least one person on her list is wrong.