Mafia Game #4 The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
At this point in the game, I am unsure if any mafia have made any "mafia type" moves.
I really see no reason not to vote for CL. The whole "ma....." thing clinced it for me. If CL did not get lynched, and the mafia let them live, then we would for sure lynch CL the next day.
Are we doing the mafia's dirty work? We will know tomorrow. From what I can tell CL has retracted the whole "ma....." claim and is most likely not the mayor. If CL is the "ma....." then please tell us who you investigated last night.
btw, my list from before was not who I thought was mafia at all. It is just players I respect.
I think we will see a little more mafia action on Day 3.
I really see no reason not to vote for CL. The whole "ma....." thing clinced it for me. If CL did not get lynched, and the mafia let them live, then we would for sure lynch CL the next day.
Are we doing the mafia's dirty work? We will know tomorrow. From what I can tell CL has retracted the whole "ma....." claim and is most likely not the mayor. If CL is the "ma....." then please tell us who you investigated last night.
btw, my list from before was not who I thought was mafia at all. It is just players I respect.
I think we will see a little more mafia action on Day 3.
You will be the first person to know huh?..are you setting it up now?..Cory lover maybe mafia, but I know you are, and I strongly suspect hooked newbie, some pieces just fell together in my head, as I reread things, ...If he is, with or with out my vote, hes probably gone tonight, I am not switching my vote off you., although, I would like to see some more on you!..
Interesting twist there. I always find a sudden switch to left field without any explanations interesting. I am not saying I disbelieve you, just reluctant to start pointing fingers just on a random say so. Please post your reasons for suddenly deciding to get rid of both Coler and Hooked - you might be onto something there, just want to look at your reasoning.
As for my vote, for now I vote to Lynch Cory Lover, but this could be subject to change in light of new arguements.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
JM, by all means, please post your reasoning. If you want us to switch, you have to provide more than that.
As far as I'm concerned, I suspect you lots more than Coler.
As far as I'm concerned, I suspect you lots more than Coler.
Unfortunatly, I can not give my arguments at this time, I may put someone we need in jeopardy, please just believe me, And if I am wrong, you can lynch me, but we need coler gone, like last night.
just give me this, I will try and put together my reasoning, however , i do not have time now, And if I don't get it together, and they lynch me, I can not stress more, to you, to watch hooked newbie! ..
just give me this, I will try and put together my reasoning, however , i do not have time now, And if I don't get it together, and they lynch me, I can not stress more, to you, to watch hooked newbie! ..
Well... I'll say... 
Has anyone ever seen this many votes on one person? Can that many people be wrong? CL has done a poor job of defending his (lack) of strategy, IMO. I know I wasn't perfect last game, but I knew certain innocents were innocent, but this time I strongly feel everyone may have this right. CL has consistently played in suspicious ways.
At this point I also think it's unfair to pull Coler out of nowhere - the guy has been gone on vacation, and he just caught up. It would be completely like mafia to go after someone who has sort of been out of action (through no fault of his own), and who hasn't had the chance to establish much of an identity or reputation. While his posts have been short, he has been forward with his thinking and lists (even if he does put me on it ><), and I can't see why an innocent would depart from a very good guess, to an almost complete unknown - unless that person had a particular wish to see CL live another day, and an innocent to go in their buddy's place.
Has anyone ever seen this many votes on one person? Can that many people be wrong? CL has done a poor job of defending his (lack) of strategy, IMO. I know I wasn't perfect last game, but I knew certain innocents were innocent, but this time I strongly feel everyone may have this right. CL has consistently played in suspicious ways.
At this point I also think it's unfair to pull Coler out of nowhere - the guy has been gone on vacation, and he just caught up. It would be completely like mafia to go after someone who has sort of been out of action (through no fault of his own), and who hasn't had the chance to establish much of an identity or reputation. While his posts have been short, he has been forward with his thinking and lists (even if he does put me on it ><), and I can't see why an innocent would depart from a very good guess, to an almost complete unknown - unless that person had a particular wish to see CL live another day, and an innocent to go in their buddy's place.
Whew! Just got caught up. Mighty interesting discussions today and as I suspected since I haven't been around to roleplay today my name has fallen off most peoples public Mafia lists. Except JL66 which is interesting to me. Why does he continue to count me such a high priority suspect? Rest assured that the roleplaying will return after dinner. My vote remains on CL.
#2 bkw1982: For all my previous reasons.
#3 Now johnlarson66: At first I just thought it was because I was roleplaying but now I think it is because I make an easy target for you to try and put out there. Since you're probably Mafia you would want to have people like myself to point at the take heat off any real Mafia targets we, the citizens, nail. You may still be a civilian that just doesn't like RP, but I'm watching more closely now.
#2 bkw1982: For all my previous reasons.
#3 Now johnlarson66: At first I just thought it was because I was roleplaying but now I think it is because I make an easy target for you to try and put out there. Since you're probably Mafia you would want to have people like myself to point at the take heat off any real Mafia targets we, the citizens, nail. You may still be a civilian that just doesn't like RP, but I'm watching more closely now.
