Mafia Game #4 The Play

bkw1982 said:
Well the "eveidence" you presented for me was very weak, and i still think you are holding a grudge because i slammed your roleplaying. and you weren't to the first to bring up the votes for mee mee or cl, you jumped on others ppl votes. Mad was the first to pegg mee mee, and Cl was just a dog pile. Your batting 1000 cause u followed others
Click to expand...

"Weak" in your opinion, others may diagree.

Never said I was the first to peg any of them, but I have been right every time. And I was on CL before the "dogpile." While everyone else was jumping on Nola I was trying to point out CL, but at the time not many would agree.
 
Dangerdoll said:
I am more sure of Coler than I am about King but I am still suspicious of him. The thing is, I am more sure of Coler because of his posting style this game. If it's due to unforseen circumstances, ok, it might be an error but I'm not taking chances. King is next on my list though. I like to be one ahead of the game.
Click to expand...

I'm not ready to toss a vote yet as there is still lots of time, but I agree w/ DD about Coler's posting style. What's concerning, is that when confronted with being mafia, the often eloquent and resourceful Coler only responds (and continues to respond) with "I'm not mafia"...and that's it.

A lot of times when folks are mafia, they haven't been helping the town all that much, and they've been mostly following other's leads, so there's not a whole lot that they can point to in their defense. Hence, we get the defense "I can't say it any other way....I'm not mafia."

Like I said though, I'm not voting yet.... when everyone votes so early, it seems to make the 48 hour day/night cycle really drag.
 
SHK_ATK said:
MAN I finally have to write down notes to play this game. What a day let me answer some "?"'s first

Judge post 731 you ask why vote for DD? Well because I too have a Mafia Meter and she was making it go off. PLUS she has been "innocent" in other games so well that it fooled the doc and she ended up being Mafia. I have a mix feeling with her to tell you the truth but my eye is still on her, I like how when someone mentions her its automaticly oh well YOU must be mafia, as she said that about me and julie.I haven't called anyone who questions DD mafia that I don't think is mafia, If you pay attention, I have also questioned people on why they think YOU are mafia...I also don't think NJ is mafia, I wish she would change her votes for other reasons, but Thats my opinion.

730 Zsand. Says im not vocal , True I was more vocal on game one. (A LOT MORE) But as it seems we all have lives, Plus I did not have my 3 week old son either, a lot of fish tanks work, and a project in the mix (pred tank yaay) I have worked a lot this week but tom (well today) is my day off so expect more posts, PLUS I have drill this weekend so expect not to hear from me at all, I might just die from an embrassing illness...

817 jenson Funny how you arent sure of my status b/c of a pathetic reason, well shk has been "following" jpappy and sandy, I HAVE NOT if you go re read my posts (there should be a few to begin with) I have been nothing but consistent I have not pegged anyone else or changed my votes so who am I following? BTW in that very same post you agreed with sandy aout someting orge said....So what jenson that makes you following sandy? that must make you mafia huh?? please.... weak reasoning.

807 I like this one ORGE asks about my opinion about what has transpired I have not posted a single thing then BAMM on post 853 im a mafia member?......then on the whole mafia meter wtf CL was CONFIRMED and he was a 3!!!!!!!!! get out im not the only one who caught that either. Im a 4? But yet people on my list are 5's??? Ill go ahead and say it now. my 4th person for MY list is orge things arent adding up for me.

854 john larson im mafia b/c I am quite. well look at all my posts and look at the times of my posts ALWAYS are after 12AM I post but **** I have to read a bunch of crap to get into the game, at 1st it was alright until someone wanted to quit, then everyone whinned about it, then I get into the game then Again someone wants to quit and I waste hours reading pages of posts of people accused of cheating and watching peoples profile..........things get way out of hand way to frequently.


I like to observe the game and see who makes MY mafia radar go off, and I feel like so far its been consisten with votes. We will see what Mee Mee REALLY is she claims to be "innocent" but in this game those are only words.
Click to expand...

I have only read this far, so I am sure, ill have to post a billion times!
 
Ok I was thinking about it. Last night the Mafia would of had two investigations, and they voted Sovran to Whack. To me that means that they thought Sov was either Doctor or Vigilante. since they did not Hit a Character, that means they have missed on both of their investigations thus far. 17 players left, 4 Mafia, 13 Innocent. They now know what three of us are so if they got lucky last night they will probably hit the Vig tonight, otherwise they will be guessing again hoping to hit the doctor or Vig.

2/10 shot 20% probability that they will get one of our Characters in the next Night.
 
I think they voted sovran, because she was an obvious innocent, ..Thats my opinion, and take it for what its worth.....If they couldn't find what they were looking for, take an innocent no matter what, My hunch is, they investigated people other than her, ..And are sitting on that info, because you guys are screaming guilty on one, and if we do the worst of their dirty work, they stay hidden much better.
 
Yup that's what I'm saying judge, they had two investigations that turned up nothing so they whacked an Innocent we all presumed Innocent, leaving us to squabble amongst ourselves. I don't think they would leave a Character in play though if they knew their identity, that would be pretty foolish IMO.
 
I don't think the Mafia would make 3 mistakes in a row, so I feel Sovran was just an easy target and killing her off would not lead back to them somehow. I will go back and reread Sov's posts just in case, but I want to say that I still have my suspicions on KOTD. If he is a concerned townie, I would think that he would have put his vote on CL the first night if he didn't believe Nola was Mafia. Especially if he had any suspicions at all about CL, who was only trailing by a few votes. And I can see that he might have had suspicions on DD, but it doesn't make sense to put a vote where it won't count as there weren't that many more pple to vote that night, 1st day or no.
 
man this game is sooooo much fun!!!! my poor fish must miss me!!! i feed them and count them then run to the computer. man i'm a geek. anyhow being my first game i don't feel as though i've been as helpful to the town as i would have liked to be, and in fact at this point have basically let the more experienced townies lead and i have followed. I trust Z and judge and know they are innocent and influential townies, and i carefully consider both of thier opinions. Sorry to bandwagon. Will try harder not to in mafia #5!!!
 
well..looks like we got another one :D only 4 to go!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom