Mafia Game #4 The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Yup Charlie I'm assuming that GuppyGuppyFish, NolaPete, and "13" are all innocents as they were able to seemingly walk away without declaring anything to us. That is pretty solid evidence to me compared to what we have to go on on some folks. I would also guess this rules them out as any Special Characters as well.
Guppyguppyfish quit also?
edit: Okay went back and see she is on a camping trip, not quitting the game.
edit: Okay went back and see she is on a camping trip, not quitting the game.
Alright, not sure how reliable my internet connection is so I'll try and make it quick.
I truly believe Nola is an innocent and that he wasn't pleased by ppl's criticism of his roleplay. That along with a surly attitude dug him in a hole and perhaps made him a good target for Mafia. Especially if they want attention turned away from someone else.
Not much has happened to change my mind on CL. Perhaps I'm wrong, but his first post was just too obvious and then later it sounded like he knew he'd messed up. And it appears he is being protected as votes have been swayed by pretty convincing arguments. But I'm not convinced, so I'll have to say I vote to lynch Cory Lover.
And it appears pple are switching their votes around all over the place, but I would just like to remind everyone that perhaps the Mafia wishes us townies to spread our votes just as theirs are most likely spread. Townies, go after who you really think is Mafia who is most likely to get a majority of votes. Also, remember that the Mafia's role is to cause confusion, hence the votes from left field.
I truly believe Nola is an innocent and that he wasn't pleased by ppl's criticism of his roleplay. That along with a surly attitude dug him in a hole and perhaps made him a good target for Mafia. Especially if they want attention turned away from someone else.
Not much has happened to change my mind on CL. Perhaps I'm wrong, but his first post was just too obvious and then later it sounded like he knew he'd messed up. And it appears he is being protected as votes have been swayed by pretty convincing arguments. But I'm not convinced, so I'll have to say I vote to lynch Cory Lover.
And it appears pple are switching their votes around all over the place, but I would just like to remind everyone that perhaps the Mafia wishes us townies to spread our votes just as theirs are most likely spread. Townies, go after who you really think is Mafia who is most likely to get a majority of votes. Also, remember that the Mafia's role is to cause confusion, hence the votes from left field.
Charlie prepares himself for his second bedtime snack of the longest day he can remember in ACville, hoping his vote will matter. Recent buzz at the town hall has Charlie thinking Mee Mee is somehow involved in the mafia's plot to rule, and wonders if he shouldn't change his vote to her??? And the disappearance of Nola and "13"?? Were they actually gone, or had they just gone underground to watch from their rat holes as the town's resolve unraveled?? Charlie looked to the heavens (i.e. rbishop) for answers he hoped would soon come. Maybe another rest would help to clear his mind.
Update thru Post 333
to lynch
CL 1 by jpappy
DD 2 by KOTD meemee
Ice 1 by CL
Nola 6 by Coler mad ogre sov 13 judge
judge 1 by neonJ
meemee 2 by hook DD
Ice 1 by CL
jl66 1 by ggfish
zsand 2 by jl66 bkw
bkw 1 by zsand
no one 1 by Nola
19 of 24 players have voted
Night fall will be at 6 AM EST
At that time, desired PMs to me from certain players should follow shortly after nighttime start.
to lynch
CL 1 by jpappy
DD 2 by KOTD meemee
Ice 1 by CL
Nola 6 by Coler mad ogre sov 13 judge
judge 1 by neonJ
meemee 2 by hook DD
Ice 1 by CL
jl66 1 by ggfish
zsand 2 by jl66 bkw
bkw 1 by zsand
no one 1 by Nola
19 of 24 players have voted
Night fall will be at 6 AM EST
At that time, desired PMs to me from certain players should follow shortly after nighttime start.
Ok I'm at the same place I was earlier today.
1.) bkw1982: Watched thread for 200 posts before jumping in. Then claimed after almost 200 posts that he had no info from those posts. After I called this out twice he voted for me for "posting in italics and switching my vote" (originally CoreyLover).
2. CoreyLover: Jumbled posts, sounded excited at first, possibly for finally getting a role after four rounds then tried to back peddle in later posts.
3. No solid information right now to deepen my list so I won't pick a third right now.
I believe Nola is innocent, I think he tried Roleplaying as I have been and was called out on it, as I and Charlie both were. It still seems to me a bit odd that people would want to play this game without roleplay, it just seems like it wouldn't work but I will not force my opinion on anyone. Play it as you like, I'm having fun. As I said I also think GGF and "13" are innocent because of the ease with which they "quit". I will vote for bkw or CoreyLover for day one. My vote will stand as is for now but if I see that it will be between Nola and CL I will vote CL because I don't want us to kick a civilian even if that civilian may not want to play right now. Tomorrow Nola may decide to give it another shot. I'll be going to bed in an hour or two and will make my final decision then.
1.) bkw1982: Watched thread for 200 posts before jumping in. Then claimed after almost 200 posts that he had no info from those posts. After I called this out twice he voted for me for "posting in italics and switching my vote" (originally CoreyLover).
2. CoreyLover: Jumbled posts, sounded excited at first, possibly for finally getting a role after four rounds then tried to back peddle in later posts.
3. No solid information right now to deepen my list so I won't pick a third right now.
I believe Nola is innocent, I think he tried Roleplaying as I have been and was called out on it, as I and Charlie both were. It still seems to me a bit odd that people would want to play this game without roleplay, it just seems like it wouldn't work but I will not force my opinion on anyone. Play it as you like, I'm having fun. As I said I also think GGF and "13" are innocent because of the ease with which they "quit". I will vote for bkw or CoreyLover for day one. My vote will stand as is for now but if I see that it will be between Nola and CL I will vote CL because I don't want us to kick a civilian even if that civilian may not want to play right now. Tomorrow Nola may decide to give it another shot. I'll be going to bed in an hour or two and will make my final decision then.
